Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 669 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
Why? If Panthers will make playoff in 2018 then Panthers will be pick at 27 to 32 in the 1st round. 27 to 31 for 1st round is far so bust. U know better.

Youre not get that much back, not much close.


Few years Raiders trades down from 3 to 9 with Miami. Know what they will got back in return? A 2nd rounder. That is was standard return when draft with no elite QB prospects at front.


If the 49ers gotten a 2nd and 3rd back they would be far gooder damn.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Apr 25, 2017 at 1:49 PM ]
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
Here is a chart from 2015. You can see that PFF only graded him negatively vs the run in one game.

https://gyazo.com/0494fa3b9d8c21f34f6dd1c8bdcd5781

Boom

yeah cause he was in on sub-package with 375 snaps to his name in 2015...when teams ran the ball in those sub-packages we were the 4th worst team giving up over 5 yards per carry (Williams was very underrated) . He looks to me like a sub-package pass rusher, which isn't horrible but that doesn't make him a starter in this scheme.

He's gonna play this yr regardless of who we draft and if he steps it up awesome.... if not we got a guy that can take over for him and we trade AA...good problem to have IMO. We see good teams doing that all the time.

also it's no different then all the people who want LF (beside the fact that a RB is dependent of multiple things to be successful).
Originally posted by NYniner85:
yeah cause he was in on sub-package with 375 snaps to his name in 2015...when teams ran the ball in those sub-packages we were the 4th worst team giving up over 5 yards per carry (Williams was very underrated) . He looks to me like a sub-package pass rusher, which isn't horrible but that doesn't make him a starter in this scheme.

He's gonna play this yr regardless of who we draft and if he steps it up awesome.... if not we got a guy that can take over for him and we trade AA...good problem to have IMO. We see good teams doing that all the time.

also it's no different then all the people who want LF (beside the fact that a RB is dependent of multiple things to be successful).

I'm not arguing against picking Thomas, I just disagree that Armstead is the bum that you were insisting he is.
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
I'm not arguing against picking Thomas, I just disagree that Armstead is the bum that you were insisting he is.

Its been proven that he isn't. Yet NY wont accept the fact.

Time to move on.
Originally posted by NYniner85:

Garrett will be ours 😀
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
yeah cause he was in on sub-package with 375 snaps to his name in 2015...when teams ran the ball in those sub-packages we were the 4th worst team giving up over 5 yards per carry (Williams was very underrated) . He looks to me like a sub-package pass rusher, which isn't horrible but that doesn't make him a starter in this scheme.

He's gonna play this yr regardless of who we draft and if he steps it up awesome.... if not we got a guy that can take over for him and we trade AA...good problem to have IMO. We see good teams doing that all the time.

also it's no different then all the people who want LF (beside the fact that a RB is dependent of multiple things to be successful).

I'm not arguing against picking Thomas, I just disagree that Armstead is the bum that you were insisting he is.

NYniner85,

You can't rationalize taking Thomas by saying AA sucks. You can't draft Thomas and bench AA. You can't draft Thomas and rotate him.

Your reasoning for drafting this guy is what?

He doesn't play LEO, CB, FS, LB. He plays a position we drafted in the 1st round the past 2 years.

No Thanks!
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
I'm not arguing against picking Thomas, I just disagree that Armstead is the bum that you were insisting he is.

Its been proven that he isn't. Yet NY wont accept the fact.

Time to move on.

young how about you move on lol....your love/hate stuff in here is wild.
Originally posted by 49er_Rider:
Originally posted by NYniner85:

Garrett will be ours 😀

Yes zzzir..

If they take Garrett, Trubisky is gone and they know it.
[ Edited by Wu-5Rings on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:00 PM ]
Originally posted by philosoraptor:
He wasn't frequently asked to bend and rush off the edge dude. You are projecting if you think he is going to be a Leo rusher in the pros. His clear strength is as an interior passrusher and runstuffer. Which we have taken in the last two drafts.

I'm not projecting him to play Leo...but your post was ironic as hell.

You make it a point to say what happens in college doesn't matter and it's what is done in the pros...you then make a point that he cannot rush from the outside(btw that's not strictly a role for the Leo) because he didn't do it in college.

He's got the physical and mental ability to rush the passer from the outside, he needs coaching and opportunity. David Shaw said they played him inside because that was the best thing for the team, not that Thomas couldn't handle rushing from the outside.

And yeah at some point teams project what a player can do. JJ Watt was a TE, Richard Sherman was a WR, Terrelle Pryor was a QB. Teams saw their skillsets and thought they could transition to those other roles and obviously they are now having a lot of success after not doing something before.

As has been mentioned in the Thomas thread in 2015 they played him a good amount at NT and had a lot of success there, he played mostly 3T last year and had a great season from that spot. Give him the opportunity and coaching to improve his skills and I see no reason why he cannot succeed as an outside rusher IF we feel that's the best fit for the team. We could just as easily think his best contribution to the team is similar to what Stanford did and play him at 3T in which case he'd be able to put on 10-15 lbs and go to town inside with his strength/speed combo.
Originally posted by JR80Forever:
NYniner85,

You can't rationalize taking Thomas by saying AA sucks. You can't draft Thomas and bench AA. You can't draft Thomas and rotate him.

Your reasoning for drafting this guy is what?

He doesn't play LEO, CB, FS, LB. He plays a position we drafted in the 1st round the past 2 years.

No Thanks!

My realization is simple and what I've been saying for the past month...he's BPA, we were historically bad at stopping the run/rushing the passer (both things he's good at), AA hasn't proven to be worth his draft pick and if he has please show the film to back it up. DL rotates more than any position and I have no problem with getting AA in on some passing downs...I don't see why we can't play all three at times? What happens if we're able to trade AA for say a 2nd? I've read reports that the Packers might be interested.

It's fair you don't want DL I get it...just because we drafted it doesn't mean AA he was the right pick or the future with this new FO.

You bring up other positions, but the players at those positions are reaches and have red flags of their own IMO.

we will find out in a couple days....I hope we trade down but if not I'm going with my boy Thomas. I'm not a flip flopper
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:07 PM ]
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by philosoraptor:
He wasn't frequently asked to bend and rush off the edge dude. You are projecting if you think he is going to be a Leo rusher in the pros. His clear strength is as an interior passrusher and runstuffer. Which we have taken in the last two drafts.

I'm not projecting him to play Leo...but your post was ironic as hell.

You make it a point to say what happens in college doesn't matter and it's what is done in the pros...you then make a point that he cannot rush from the outside(btw that's not strictly a role for the Leo) because he didn't do it in college.

He's got the physical and mental ability to rush the passer from the outside, he needs coaching and opportunity. David Shaw said they played him inside because that was the best thing for the team, not that Thomas couldn't handle rushing from the outside.

And yeah at some point teams project what a player can do. JJ Watt was a TE, Richard Sherman was a WR, Terrelle Pryor was a QB. Teams saw their skillsets and thought they could transition to those other roles and obviously they are now having a lot of success after not doing something before.

As has been mentioned in the Thomas thread in 2015 they played him a good amount at NT and had a lot of success there, he played mostly 3T last year and had a great season from that spot. Give him the opportunity and coaching to improve his skills and I see no reason why he cannot succeed as an outside rusher IF we feel that's the best fit for the team. We could just as easily think his best contribution to the team is similar to what Stanford did and play him at 3T in which case he'd be able to put on 10-15 lbs and go to town inside with his strength/speed combo.

No I said the positions he played in college aren't as important m, it's about what he can do on there pro level. For example, just because jabrill peppers played linebacker in college doesn't mean he can do it in the pros. Just because Thomas played nt and a little de In college doesn't mean he can do either on the pro level. My point is he has never been asked to rush and bend around the edge in a consistent basis and I don't think he can do that at a high level in the pros.
Buck,AA, and Thomas can be 3 down players for us. Thomas would play RDE in base. When Buck goes inside then Thomas switches to LDE and we have a more dominant pass rusher from the right side.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by JR80Forever:
NYniner85,

You can't rationalize taking Thomas by saying AA sucks. You can't draft Thomas and bench AA. You can't draft Thomas and rotate him.

Your reasoning for drafting this guy is what?

He doesn't play LEO, CB, FS, LB. He plays a position we drafted in the 1st round the past 2 years.

No Thanks!

My realization is simple and what I've been saying for the past month...he's BPA, we were historically bad at stopping the run/rushing the passer (both things he's good at), AA hasn't proven to be worth his draft pick and if he has please show the film to back it up. DL rotates more than any position and I have no problem with getting AA in on some passing downs...I don't see why we can't play all three at times? What happens if we're able to trade AA for say a 2nd? I've read reports that the Packers might be interested.

It's fair you don't want DL I get it...just because we drafted it doesn't mean AA he was the right pick or the future with this new FO.

You bring up other positions, but the players at those positions are reaches and have red flags of their own IMO.

we will find out in a couple days....I hope we trade down but if not I'm going with my boy Thomas. I'm not a flip flopper

Me personally I don't get how you give up on a guy after 2 seasons. You can't be successful in the NFL with that thinking.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone