49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 1,001 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

We did have the #q pick at qb, the #6 pick at te, a #10 pick at wr, 3 1st on the o line and Frank Gore. I think we had a record for most 1st round picks starting across the board. The odds of ever being that talented again is slim to nil.
QB was and is the main issue we still have today.

drafting more defense just creates more of the unbalance we have on this team. We need to score points
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

We did have the #q pick at qb, the #6 pick at te, a #10 pick at wr, 3 1st on the o line and Frank Gore. I think we had a record for most 1st round picks starting across the board. The odds of ever being that talented again is slim to nil.
QB was and is the main issue we still have today.

drafting more defense just creates more of the unbalance we have on this team. We need to score points
If they believe a fqb is there - agreed. Take him! otherwise grab the BPA. This draft is loaded at defense. We hit on 3 guys we basically drastically improved the defense in one draft. We picked up a ton of guys on offense in FA.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
So are you happy today about no Championships won 4 years ago ?

we have 0 offense

Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.
Originally posted by Niners99:
I just cant get excited about Solomon Thomas. He's undersized, and we already have guys with his specific skillset.

I feel confident we're not taking him
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.

Was it? It was like 28th with Chip Kelly running the ship. That also partially explains the historically bad d because that's what he does. We're bottom 5 in both realistically.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Why do I have to find Solomon Thomas? You don't need him to be a great d. There's hundreds of ways to skin that cat. We also have a top 45 pick outside of 2 to build like your boy so we're still good.

You just said we could find a good DE in the 2nd as good as Thomas? Unless I read it wrong.

So you assume the same talent will be at the same picks like Gettleman had? What are you even talking about? Drafts aren't built the same way every yr.

The value in this draft is at DB, RB, TE and to a point edge rushers. There aren't a ton of good interior DL in this draft or ones at the level of Thomas and Allen.

I got no problem going with something like Thomas/Wilson/Rvers/Hunt/Reynolds in the first four rds....all for could very well be starters for us this yr
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2017 at 11:41 AM ]
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.

Was it? It was like 28th with Chip Kelly running the ship. That also partially explains the historically bad d because that's what he does. We're bottom 5 in both realistically.

My belief is kyles offesne alone will make us more average/middle of the league. Won't matter if the defense is getting smoked again. Our run defense was horrific after bowman went down. Trust me the coaches and front offense saw this on film.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
So are you happy today about no Championships won 4 years ago ?

we have 0 offense

Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.
historically bad stat wise, but we were winning or down by 3 at the half against good teams and in pretty much every game last year.

2nd half adjustments were the biggest issue
Originally posted by Niners99:
I just cant get excited about Solomon Thomas. He's undersized, and we already have guys with his specific skillset.

Undersized by what 8 lbs? Dude is 21, I'm pretty sure he can put on a couple lbs and still be explosive as a 3-tech.
Originally posted by Niners99:
I just cant get excited about Solomon Thomas. He's undersized, and we already have guys with his specific skillset.

lol wtf? Who?

...please say Ronald Blair.
  • Karma
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,190
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.

Was it? It was like 28th with Chip Kelly running the ship. That also partially explains the historically bad d because that's what he does. We're bottom 5 in both realistically.

What we had last year is irrelevant. With the influx of Free agents, the purging of players, and the comprehensive change in system on both sides of the ball, judging this team's talent based on last year's numbers makes absolutely no sense.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by philosoraptor:
I just have one issue with this. I agree that investing in the tranches is important. But star is a 1-tech, short is a 3-tech, not sure where Vernon plays, Walt and hardy are edge rushers. They diversified there picks across the dline and did it in multiple rounds.

Buckner has already said he is a 5-tech who will play some 3, arik will probably do something similar as he doesn't seem like a Guy who can play the other positions and Blair is probably best fitted as a 3-tech. We would have 4 talented young guys for 2 positions. If Solomon could be a Leo I would be down, I just don't see that. I think we should allow the guys we have some room to grow instead of just overloading the positions.

They also have Charles Jonhson, Addison, he'll just brought back peppers lol.

Peopel got to stop with he can only play 5-tech or 3-tech crap...they will all be schemed into different spots based on play calls and who's on the field. DL make a defense go and there's a reason they get paid big bucks.

Understood, not all those guys were high first rounders though, and they play different positions. Yo can have two de one nose and one 3-tech. Unless you are saying solomon is an edge rusher we have essentially have 4 young players for two spots. That doesn't include the fact earl mitchell can also be a 3-tech. Unless you are projecting solomon to be a leo?

Im not sure what you are getting at with the bolded, it seems like a vague cop out on your part.
Terry McCormick‏ @terrymc13
Robinson said #Titans have fielded couple of fairly serious calls about draft picks. Probably won't have a chance to manifest till draft day
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
So are you happy today about no Championships won 4 years ago ?

we have 0 offense

Defense was historically bad. Offense was a lot better in comparison.
historically bad stat wise, but we were winning or down by 3 at the half against good teams and in pretty much every game last year.

2nd half adjustments were the biggest issue

So you're saying our statistically historically bad offense isn't a concern because our offense kept us close? So you want more offense to make up for the defense?
Originally posted by NYniner85:
You just said we could find a good DE in the 2nd? Unless I read it wrong.

So you assume the same talent will be at the same picks like Gettleman had? What are you even talking about? Drafts aren't built the same way every yr.

The value in this draft is at DB, RB, TE and to a point edge rushers. There aren't a ton of good interior DL in this draft or ones at the level of Thomas and Allen.

I got no problem going with something like Thomas/Wilson/Rvers/Hunt/Reynolds in the first four rds....all for could very well be starters for us this yr

The 2nd is loaded with defensive ends. You know that. I did not say Short will be their in the 2nd this year just it's a multi year build we don't have to hit every piece this year and we can still upgrade the line this year significantly while still hitting other needs.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone