49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 734 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
We're not talking about what we're doing with the 2nd. We still have a 2nd rounder to go d line no matter what we do in the 1st. So I could draft LF and still build like Car and draft a DE/DT in the 2nd. You use the same logic with s.

I brought up Beassn because you said Carolina's d for years. This is not a 1 year discussion. Beason was there from 07-13 so he was part of some of their really good D's. Carolina's starting line is a 1st round nose, a couple vet De's, and a 2nd round dt. The strength is just as much in the lb's which you just ignore because in your mind it's all d line. No.

This.

"Carolina's starting line is a 1st round nose, a couple vet De's, and a 2nd round dt"

Thats a little different than the 2nd, 6th and 15th overall...3 YEARS IN A ROW!!!

You two argue to for the sake of arguing...we draft Thomas and he plays at the pro bowl caliber he can... and both you would be happy as f**k!

If AA has shown to be a quality starter wouldn't be a discussion but he hasn't. Plain and simple. Really don't want to argue anymore this thread is for draft rumors
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2017 at 11:15 AM ]
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

3 straight conference championships and a SB appearance. Sounds good to me.

Just because you address defense doesnt mean you cant build the offense as well.
Latest from Matt Miller
San Francisco 49ers: New general manager John Lynch has locked up what used to be a leaky front office. This is a very hard team to peg right now, but I do continue to hear from rival scouts and general managers that it likes Reuben Foster and Fournette, but may not be willing to take either at No. 2 overall. I don't expect a quarterback in Round 1. The 49ers could try to duplicate last year's draft and trade back into the 20s for more players.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2705378-matt-millers-scouting-notebook-latest-draft-buzz-updated-big-board-more?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=programming-national
  • krizay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 26,638
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
We're not talking about what we're doing with the 2nd. We still have a 2nd rounder to go d line no matter what we do in the 1st. So I could draft LF and still build like Car and draft a DE/DT in the 2nd. You use the same logic with s.

I brought up Beassn because you said Carolina's d for years. This is not a 1 year discussion. Beason was there from 07-13 so he was part of some of their really good D's. Carolina's starting line is a 1st round nose, a couple vet De's, and a 2nd round dt. The strength is just as much in the lb's which you just ignore because in your mind it's all d line. No.

This.

"Carolina's starting line is a 1st round nose, a couple vet De's, and a 2nd round dt"

Thats a little different than the 2nd, 6th and 15th overall...3 YEARS IN A ROW!!!

Except the DL that everyone keeps projecting may not be there.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
There's no one in the 2nd even close to Thomas as for as DL prospects go...please tell me who? This IS the deepest draft at RB in over 10 yrs though that's a fact! No OL no RB.

For yrs is a decade I guess...IF AA actually played to is draft position we clearly wouldn't be having this discussion but he hasn't plain and simple...

DL is the building block of a defense anyone will tell you that...that line gives Thomas and Luke all the freedom they want. Also they still spent top end picks on DL even though they still had good players already there.

Who on Car's d line is like Solomon Thomas? Even Short is a lot different player who came in at 300 and is now tipping 315. He's no tweener. From there you have the stud nose in Star clogging the middle. There's plenty of great d line prospects in the 2nd how it gets built up is going to look different for every team.

I've already shown you they've only spent 2 1sts on the d line since 2003. Victor Green and has 1.5 sacks is not that important to them. He was probably just bpa and at 30 that's what you do. Carolina values there front 7 as a whole not just focusing on 1 aspect.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Apr 25, 2017 at 11:20 AM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

3 straight conference championships and a SB appearance. Sounds good to me.

Just because you address defense doesnt mean you cant build the offense as well.
So are you happy today about no Championships won 4 years ago ?

we have 0 offense
Originally posted by strickac:
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
Chicago will pass on Watson or Trubisky they don't have quartback. they are dumb.

You must be forgetting about Glennon's $18M golden arm.


Glennon is not worth again. Then bears is dumb again over!
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

3 straight conference championships and a SB appearance. Sounds good to me.

Just because you address defense doesnt mean you cant build the offense as well.

I think that's what people are missing...this draft has blue chip defensive prospects at the top. That's what this draft is, so that's what you go for if your a team that had zero pro-bowlers last yr.

We got a HC that can scheme offense and brought in like 8 offensive FAs...we aren't gonna have some elite offense without a FQB and there just isn't one in this draft ...so go with the best players and fill in offense with the vlaue picks.

I got no problem with a balanced draft but at the top there are stud defensive players...just cause the fans what a flashy offensive player doesn't mean it's the right thing to do this draft.
Originally posted by krizay:
Except the DL that everyone keeps projecting may not be there.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

We did have the #q pick at qb, the #6 pick at te, a #10 pick at wr, 3 1st on the o line and Frank Gore. I think we had a record for most 1st round picks starting across the board. The odds of ever being that talented again is slim to nil.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Who on Car's d line is like Solomon Thomas? Even Short is a lot different player who came in at 300 and is now tipping 315. He's no tweener. From there you have the stud nose in Star clogging the middle. There's plenty of great d line prospects in the 2nd how it gets built up is going to look different for every team.

I've already shown you they've only spent 2 1sts on the d line since 2003. Victor Green and has 1.5 sacks is not that important to them. He was probably just bpa and at 30 that's what you do. Carolina values there front 7 as a whole not just focusing on 1 aspect.

No who in the second rd in this draft (compared to Thomas).

As far as when Dave Gettleman has become the GM he's drafted 4 DE in the top 45 the past 4 yrs and that's with Charles Johnson already there.

He values that positon and has had a ton of sucss in Carolina and NY going that route.

Thomas helps in pass rush and stopping the run AA doesn't do that...and people keep thing that we have this stud DL but I haven't seen it at all. Sometime GMs f**k up a pick and imo baalke did with AA why do we have to ride it out with him as a starter? We didn't do that with AJ Jenkins? Maybe all AA will ever be is a 3 down pass rusher and not a 3 down starter...
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
hasn't worked for all Defense for us either

3 straight conference championships and a SB appearance. Sounds good to me.

Just because you address defense doesnt mean you cant build the offense as well.
So are you happy today about no Championships won 4 years ago ?

we have 0 offense

Defense and a great qb win championships. I understand both sides, but I think our defense is in worse shape than our offense tbh.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
No who in the second rd in this draft (compared to Thomas).

As far as when Dave Gettleman has become the GM he's drafted 4 DE in the top 45 the past 4 yrs and that's with Charles Johnson already there.

He values that positon and has had a ton of sucss in Carolina and NY going that route.

Thomas helps in pass rush and stopping the run AA doesn't do that...and people keep thing that we have this stud DL but I haven't seen it at all. Sometime GMs f**k up a pick and imo baalke did with AA why do we have to ride it out with him as a starter? We didn't do that with AJ Jenkins? Maybe all AA will ever be is a 3 down pass rusher and not a 3 down starter...

Why do I have to find Solomon Thomas? You don't need him to be a great d. There's hundreds of ways to skin that cat. We also have a top 45 pick outside of 2 to build like your boy so we're still good.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
Please don't let it be Adams.
I just cant get excited about Solomon Thomas. He's undersized, and we already have guys with his specific skillset.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone