There are 1,037 users in the forums
2012 QB draft class
- 1 2
Jan 26, 2011 at 12:35 PM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,608
Every kid will have some kind of an issue, nobody is a perfect player.
Jan 26, 2011 at 12:45 PM
- GhostofFredDean74
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 30,082
You worry about next year, next year.
Jan 26, 2011 at 12:55 PM
- genus49
- Moderator
- Posts: 28,609
Yea it should be pretty good but you never know how the season shakes out.
This is another reason to stay away from these first round qbs.
I was bummed out Foles didn't come out. He was my #2 guy behind Luck.
This is another reason to stay away from these first round qbs.
I was bummed out Foles didn't come out. He was my #2 guy behind Luck.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:05 PM
- LumpiaJeff
- Veteran
- Posts: 51,513
Not big on Nick Foles. You said he was consistent against his opponents, and IMO he was the opposite. I wouldn't draft him.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:28 PM
- LifelongNiner
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,009
Originally posted by sfout:
Does Harbaugh really "have to" draft a QB this year? Couldn't be be looking towards next years class? No I don't mean Andrew Luck but couldn't he trade for Josh Johnson or Kevin Kolb or sign Kellen Clemens, Dennis Dixon, Chad Pennington, or Drew Stanton and wait until next year to draft a qb? Arguably Johnson, Kolb, Dixon, Stanton are still raw enough to be molding to a specific fit and could transform into our franchise QB, very hypothetical I know, but I am just saying that this years draft is anything but shooting fish in a barrel when it comes to drafting a QB.
Think about it, every QB this year has question marks:
Gabbert: Laziness and fitness.
Newton: Maturity and "off field" issues.
Mallett: Maturity/anger, mobility, "off field" issues."
Locker: Injuries, inconsistent and inaccurate.
Ponder: Injuries, size, in-game decisions.
Dalton: Size and delivery.
Devlin: Competition and mobility.
Stanzi: Injuries, accuracy, in-game decisions.
Kaepernick: Accuracy, in-game decisions.
Johnson: In-game decisions, accuracy.
Enderle: Injuries, arm strength/delivery.
Taylor: Size, accuracy, in-game decision.
McElroy: Size, mobility.
Yes we are looking to develop a QB so a lot of these things are fixable however injuries and maturity might not be that easy. Looking ahead at next years class there is going to a huge crop of QBs, both seniors and draft eligible underclassmen.
Seniors(we know will come out):
Kellen Moore
Andrew Luck
Terelle Pryor
Dan Persa
Bryant Moniz
Brandon Weeden
Kirk Cousins
Ryan Lindley
Stephen Garcia
Nick Foles
Notable underclassmen
Darren Thomas
Denard Robinson
Matt Barkley
Landry Jones
Robert Griffen III
It is safe to say that if Barkley, Thomas, or Jones has a monster year next year they will probably declare. The least likely being Darren Thomas because of the system and his physical size. Look at this years draft class and next years I would much rather we draft immediate impact players and trade/sign a qb(hello Josh Johnson or Kevin Kolb) for this year and devote and entire year to watching next years class for the QB we want.
My top 5 for next years class(excluding Luck):
1. Dan Persa, Northwestern 6-1 205
Undersized but I watched a lot of NW games this year and the first words that came to mind when I watched him were "Steve Young". Scary to make that connection but he is similar sized, runs the same style(not really athletic but can still move) and very accurate.
2. Nick Foles Arizona 6-5 245
Physically reminds of Roethlisberger and has been very consistent against all competition, I think he is ranked preseason #2 behind Luck for next year, might be wrong though.
3. Ryan Lindley, San Diego State U 6-4 215
Admittedly only watched him against the U of U and was impressed with his play, however he isn't a very accurate passer and needs a lot of mechanics work from the limited highlights I've seen.
4. Darren Thomas Oregon 6-3 212
Does well when asked to do the job, limited number of pass attempts and might fall under the category of "game manager". However he is a very mobile and will probably improve in the pocket this year.
5. Landry Jones Oklahoma 6-4 219
Played in a very pass heavy system(600+ attempts this year and 450 last year) and in his second year starting posted a 38 - 12 td/int ratio. Might be the most "pro ready" qb on my list.
What do you guys think?
Do we have to draft a guy this year? Do human beings need air to breathe
? Yes we have to get a guy this year. You don't sit around a wait for who may be available next year. We have to get a guy and get him into the system. The only thing drafting a QB this year all but guarantees is that we probably won't draft a QB in the 1st round next year unless a can't miss type of prospect, like an Andrew Luck falls to us. Look at it this way, if Bill Walsh became the 49ers coach in 1978 I'm certain he would've looked for a guy in the draft that could've ran his offense in 1978. Would that guy turned out to be Joe Montana? Who knows. But you have to get a QB. Especially when you only have David Carr under contract. We don't have the luxury of waiting until 2012.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:40 PM
- canadian49erfan
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,472
Man what do you expect from a kid coming out of college? Every player coming out will have their downfalls, there is no such thing as a perfect player, especially coming out of college.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:41 PM
- SanDiego49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 52,528
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
You worry about next year, next year.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:54 PM
- Overkill
- Moderator
- Posts: 12,049
Originally posted by sfout:
Look at this years draft class and next years I would much rather we draft immediate impact players and trade/sign a qb(hello Josh Johnson or Kevin Kolb) for this year and devote and entire year to watching next years class for the QB we want.
No way we trade for Kolb and spend a high pick next year on a QB. Philly's price is just too high.
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:55 PM
- krizay
- Veteran
- Posts: 26,638
Mmm Hmm didn't I hear this talk last year in hopes of Locker this year?
Jan 26, 2011 at 1:57 PM
- GhostofFredDean74
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 30,082
Originally posted by krizay:
Mmm Hmm didn't I hear this talk last year in hopes of Locker this year?
Jan 26, 2011 at 2:07 PM
- Jcool
- Veteran
- Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:Originally posted by krizay:
Mmm Hmm didn't I hear this talk last year in hopes of Locker this year?
Jan 26, 2011 at 2:13 PM
- hondakillerzx
- Veteran
- Posts: 19,281
brady and montana had plenty of knocks coming out too. they still turned out to be two hall of famers. we need a qb now and we will draft one now. he'll be pretty far along by next year when we can realistically start talking about a superbowl appearance if the harbaugh transformation catches on quickly.
Jan 26, 2011 at 2:14 PM
- HessianDud
- Veteran
- Posts: 22,995
i just hope that there is a quality QB available when we pick in the 2nd. I mean, yeah, just about every QB is going to be a "project" and need some time, but we all knew months ago that any rookie QB we take is going to need time. But just from looking over the senior bowl practice reports, and even recognizing that its very early, it seems like a lot of guys are going to start shooting up the boards and since a lot of teams need QBs...IDK, it worries me that there won't be one there when we pick in the 2nd, and it definitely seems like we will need to get one there, unless we fall in love with a guy at #7 or trade back.
Jan 26, 2011 at 2:32 PM
- sfout
- Veteran
- Posts: 6,443
Yea I am not opposing drafting one this year but I am saying that next years class is pretty stacked compared to our little 3-4 player window that we have this year. Of the 10 players I listed the top 4 will probably be gone by our #2 pick and the bottom half of that list is all day 3 guys. Dalton, Devlin, and Stanzi are pretty much the safetest bets and even if we go with a draft a guy this year, trade for josh johnson and keep Carr for a year that still leaves our 3rd position open at the end of next year. Not to mention it is always a good idea to have a QB on your practice squad.
I've said it ever since Carr played in the Carolina game that we will probably have 3 completely new QBs this spring let alone next year. Even if Harbaugh hasn't "closed" the door on smith coming back he probably wont unless he is going to start, Harbaugh doesn't think the world of Troy and Carr is so expendable it's not even funny. So you guys tell me. If we trade for Josh Johnson/kolb and draft a rookie who would you want to fill that 3rd spot with?(technically 2nd on the depth chart) or would you want to draft one of these guys next year?
I also want to make it clear that I am aware all of these guys are projects, so are all 5 of the guys I listed as my top 5 for next year. If we have Kolb or Johnson starting next year and a rookie being groomed shouldn't we think of rounding out the depth chart completely by signing or drafting another 1 or 2 qbs in the next 2 years? I haven't looked at the 2012 free agent QBs but I like the idea of going completely young at the position and having Harbaugh be the voice of experience and reason to them. I don't like the idea of wasting more money on some 30-35 year old vet to sit on the sidelines when we could actually be proactive and look for a guy coming off his first contract like Stanton, the 3rd stringer in Detroit who could compete against Johnson/Kolb.
I found a draft simulator that actually has us drafting 2 qbs this year: it spit out ponder in the 2nd and Jerrod Johnson in the 7th round.
That is why Montana was a 3rd rounder and Brady was a 6th rounder, they are perfect cases that the draft process is pretty flawed. It does depend on circumstances but they prove that even without Harbaugh the 9ers just need to do their homework and they would do it right.
Harbaugh was tasked with FINDING our QB of the future, that is not specific to drafting him. If Josh Johnson is really worth all the fuss that people are talking about then why should we draft qb? Johnson is only 25/26 and could lead our team for 10 years. Assuming we trade for him or even Kevin Kolb it becomes even more likely that if the 9ers did draft a QB this year it would be an extremly low pick, probably a day 3 player. Again this is why my post about next years class makes sense, if we have a guy like Johnson or Kolb in there plus some 5th rounder from this year and we don't resign Carr(if we don't cut him this off season) what's to stop the 9ers from drafting another day 3 QB next year, or would you rather they sign another younger qb in the market?
I've said it ever since Carr played in the Carolina game that we will probably have 3 completely new QBs this spring let alone next year. Even if Harbaugh hasn't "closed" the door on smith coming back he probably wont unless he is going to start, Harbaugh doesn't think the world of Troy and Carr is so expendable it's not even funny. So you guys tell me. If we trade for Josh Johnson/kolb and draft a rookie who would you want to fill that 3rd spot with?(technically 2nd on the depth chart) or would you want to draft one of these guys next year?
I also want to make it clear that I am aware all of these guys are projects, so are all 5 of the guys I listed as my top 5 for next year. If we have Kolb or Johnson starting next year and a rookie being groomed shouldn't we think of rounding out the depth chart completely by signing or drafting another 1 or 2 qbs in the next 2 years? I haven't looked at the 2012 free agent QBs but I like the idea of going completely young at the position and having Harbaugh be the voice of experience and reason to them. I don't like the idea of wasting more money on some 30-35 year old vet to sit on the sidelines when we could actually be proactive and look for a guy coming off his first contract like Stanton, the 3rd stringer in Detroit who could compete against Johnson/Kolb.
I found a draft simulator that actually has us drafting 2 qbs this year: it spit out ponder in the 2nd and Jerrod Johnson in the 7th round.
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
brady and montana had plenty of knocks coming out too. they still turned out to be two hall of famers. we need a qb now and we will draft one now. he'll be pretty far along by next year when we can realistically start talking about a superbowl appearance if the harbaugh transformation catches on quickly.
That is why Montana was a 3rd rounder and Brady was a 6th rounder, they are perfect cases that the draft process is pretty flawed. It does depend on circumstances but they prove that even without Harbaugh the 9ers just need to do their homework and they would do it right.
Harbaugh was tasked with FINDING our QB of the future, that is not specific to drafting him. If Josh Johnson is really worth all the fuss that people are talking about then why should we draft qb? Johnson is only 25/26 and could lead our team for 10 years. Assuming we trade for him or even Kevin Kolb it becomes even more likely that if the 9ers did draft a QB this year it would be an extremly low pick, probably a day 3 player. Again this is why my post about next years class makes sense, if we have a guy like Johnson or Kolb in there plus some 5th rounder from this year and we don't resign Carr(if we don't cut him this off season) what's to stop the 9ers from drafting another day 3 QB next year, or would you rather they sign another younger qb in the market?
[ Edited by sfout on Jan 26, 2011 at 2:57 PM ]
- 1 2