Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 786 users in the forums

the official draft thread!

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Schulzy:
Originally posted by JDeezy:
Byham only caught 10 passes last year at Pitt.....good blocker, but didn't we have Billy Bajema who couldn't catch and proceeded to get rid of him? Seems repetitive to me.

We don't need a TE who can catch. We need a blocking TE.

I understand that, that's not the point. I'm just saying we got rid of one blocking tight end for another and tried to draft another last year. I agree we struggle with short yardage situations, but that had more to do with the lack of push on the o-line. I would think that the drafting of Iupati would mitigate that to an extent. My only question is who's going to be the 3rd corner? It's not realistic to expect a 6th round pick to be an all world player, but IMO corner was a greater need than blocking tight end. Its all nitpicking at this point, guess this means Dre Bly will be back.
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Originally posted by niner_empire:
call me a pessimist but do these picks mean we're gonna be a conservative run up the middle against a 9 man front and a cloud of dust type offense again? NFL's a passing league now, no?

thts exactly what im scared of. im honestly expecting that and vd's numbers to be way down and crabtree having only maybe 800+ yds

Singletary said that the team is going to remain balanced. He actually directly said that this team is not going to just be a "3 yards and a cloud of dust" team.

I wouldn't be worried.
Originally posted by niner_empire:
call me a pessimist but do these picks mean we're gonna be a conservative run up the middle against a 9 man front and a cloud of dust type offense again? NFL's a passing league now, no?

It hopefully means that the team will be able to abuse people with play action. I love where the team is going. With a legit #1 WR and Davis living up to his potential the team can now run effectively setting up the play action pass. Fits what sing wants to do with ball control and controlling the clock.
2 TE sets with Byham and Davis during 2nd or 3rd and 2 yds are less. These are the yards we need to get to sustain drives or to score TDs in the redzone.
Lets get Brett Swenson!! He can take over for Nedney next year
I think we're 4 deep at CB already. My concern is finding a return man that has value at either CB or WR. And a NT.
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Originally posted by niner_empire:
call me a pessimist but do these picks mean we're gonna be a conservative run up the middle against a 9 man front and a cloud of dust type offense again? NFL's a passing league now, no?

thts exactly what im scared of. im honestly expecting that and vd's numbers to be way down and crabtree having only maybe 800+ yds

all im asking for is balance, taking what the defense gives us. defense crowds the box allow alex smith to audible to pass. change up game plans according to oppositions weaknesses. i dont doubt singletary's ability to motivate, I question his and his staff's ability to coach tactics. i think he still thinks he's in the 80's sometimes. its a thinking mans game now.
Originally posted by oregondave:
Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
Nice, though I'm still a bit confused as I thought the staff wanted some speedster. Whatever. If we can play old-school football I'm all for it. I hate this spread crap sometimes.

Oh and Maddog, you didn't like the Mays and Bowman picks? I figured both were pretty good value for their spots and both address needs. Neither are immediate starters but bad picks? Naw.

The issue is that Niners already have their enforcer in the secondary in Goldson.. They needed a centerfielder who can cover guys. Mays does not provide that for the team.

As for Bowman, he is strictly a 4-3 player. He does not have good rush skills and does not shield blockers very well.

So, while guys are good value on the board...they were not good value for the type of defense we run, especially with the personnel we already possess.

I guess putting a draft board together doesn't mean you always know what you're talking about. "enforcer"? Goldson is our FS - Lewis is the SS. Lewis is our safety in the box, our run supporter. He is the one that is probably on the way out due to contract and concussion issues. We need to replace him. Mays is perfect in that role, and has the potential to be way more versatile than Lewis. IMO, this was our best pick of the draft.

You seem very angry with me, and my assessement. No need to get hostile.

We obviously have a different view of Goldson. He is a strong safety to me, not a free safety. Mays is also a strong safety. So, to me, you have two strong safeties on the team, and a need for a centerfielder, who can cover a ton of ground. Goldson is better closer to the LOS, and hitting guys.

Lewis is a wrap up tackler. Goldson is the enforcer. And, we don't need both of these types of players.
Originally posted by JDeezy:
Originally posted by Schulzy:
Originally posted by JDeezy:
Byham only caught 10 passes last year at Pitt.....good blocker, but didn't we have Billy Bajema who couldn't catch and proceeded to get rid of him? Seems repetitive to me.

We don't need a TE who can catch. We need a blocking TE.

I understand that, that's not the point. I'm just saying we got rid of one blocking tight end for another and tried to draft another last year. I agree we struggle with short yardage situations, but that had more to do with the lack of push on the o-line. I would think that the drafting of Iupati would mitigate that to an extent. My only question is who's going to be the 3rd corner? It's not realistic to expect a 6th round pick to be an all world player, but IMO corner was a greater need than blocking tight end. Its all nitpicking at this point, guess this means Dre Bly will be back.

You answered your own question. The 49ers obviously did not see value at the CB position and 6th round CBs are very unlikely to contribute.

Sorry, I don't see a problem drafting a player who is going to see the field in situation spots on this team. I can't dislike it.

And I know that the obligatory 6th round TE thing is pretty funny and true, but the old regime was making those picks.
Originally posted by niner_empire:
NFL's a passing league now, no?
so what??? even bettere if the other teams concentrate on pass defense when we run them over...
how about g. selvie and b. lang
Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
I think we're 4 deep at CB already. My concern is finding a return man that has value at either CB or WR. And a NT.

We're not 4 deep Paymah can't play......he's a 5th corner at best. It was specifically stated he was added as a valuable special teams player. Maybe he can be the 4th corner, but that's assuming Brown can be the 3rd corner, which he showed he was not ready to be last season.
  • yummy12
  • Info N/A
18 picks away intill 49ers select again
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Originally posted by niner_empire:
call me a pessimist but do these picks mean we're gonna be a conservative run up the middle against a 9 man front and a cloud of dust type offense again? NFL's a passing league now, no?

thts exactly what im scared of. im honestly expecting that and vd's numbers to be way down and crabtree having only maybe 800+ yds

Its all about winning games, I could care less about Crabtree's stats.
Originally posted by walker807:
Originally posted by niner_empire:
call me a pessimist but do these picks mean we're gonna be a conservative run up the middle against a 9 man front and a cloud of dust type offense again? NFL's a passing league now, no?

It hopefully means that the team will be able to abuse people with play action. I love where the team is going. With a legit #1 WR and Davis living up to his potential the team can now run effectively setting up the play action pass. Fits what sing wants to do with ball control and controlling the clock.

yeah, i'm not worried. we'll definitely run the ball more, I'm guessing, but if we have quality blockers it won't appear conservative and boring, because we'll be picking up big chunks of yards. We didn't have enough strength or skill up front to deal with 9 man fronts but we're obviously trying to address that.

This is great, actually, because like walker said a good running game opens up the play action and should take pressure of Smith, which only increases his chances of success this year.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone