There have been 42 picks with Scotty on board:
OG/C - 4 of 42 picks: Rnd 2 (2 picks), Rnd 3 (1 pick), Rnd 4 (1 pick).
OT - 1 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick).
TE - 5 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick), Rnd 6 (2 picks), Rnd 7 (2 picks).
WR - 5 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick), Rnd 3 (1 pick), Rnd 5 (1), Rnd 6 (1), Rnd 7 (1).
QB - 2 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick), Rnd 5 (1 pick).
RB - 4 of 42 picks: Rnd 3 (2 picks), Rnd 4 (1 pick), Rnd 6 (1 pick).
FB - none
Total Offensive = 21
DL - 6 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1), Rnd 3 (1), Rnd 4 (1), Rnd 5 (1), Rnd 6 (1), Rnd 7 (1).
ILB - 3 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick), Rnd 5 (1), Rnd 7 (1)
OLB - 3 of 42 picks: Rnd 1 (1 pick), Rnd 4 (1), Rnd 5 (1).
CB - 5 of 42 picks: Rnd 3 (1), Rnd 5 (1), Rnd 6 (2), Rnd 7 (1). Incl R.Smith as CB.
S - 3 of 42 picks: Rnd 4 (1), Rnd 7 (2).
Total Defense = 20
RS - 1 of 42 picks: Rnd 3 (1 pick) - this was Brandon Williams
Conclusions:
Over 5 years, covering 7 of 42 picks, Scotty has NEVER used more than a single Round 1 pick on ANY one position. Scotty proclaims to be a BPA disciple, but does he have a long term plan to eventually secure a #1 pick at most every position? Is it a DB's turn in this Round 1 rotation?
Over 5 years, the club has drafted only 1 player (Staley) for the NFL OT position. Does Scott value the OT position highly enough? Were there no Round 2-7 OT's, who were the BPA at the time? Odd.
"You can get guards" - in Rounds 2-4, otherwise, just sign them as UDFA's.
Over this period, the club has seemingly shorted the DB area, with R. Smith, drafted as a CB in Round 3, as its only Day 1 pick at this position. (Understand that Rnd 3 is no longer a Day 1 round).
The only previous effort at drafting a RS (B. Williams in Round 3) did not turn out so well. Does Scotty prefer FA to fill this need?
Only 2 of 42 picks were Round 2 selections (both times used to select an OG). Otherwise, the club has shown a propensity to trade (up or down) out of its Round 2 positions.
[ Edited by jimbagg on Feb 2, 2010 at 3:11 PM ]