Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 395 users in the forums

The Aldon Smith thread

  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,497
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by captnkos:
Can he appeal and get it shortened?

I don't know, but let's say he can. Appeals process takes time. If Aldon fails to get it shortened, the suspension will run deep into the season, possible post-season.

Goodell f**ked us big time. This was all a calculated attempt come down extremely hard on Aldon and the team.

Cam Inman ‏@CamInman
As for lighter punishment for Aldon Smith through an appeal, NFL spokesman Greg Aiello said in an email "The appeal process is concluded."
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by crabman82:
Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:
I don't have a problem with Any length of suspension. If he don't want suspended then don't be a dumb ass. It's easy.

i feel similar. who i feel bad for is the fans who convinced themselves it would be 2-3 games. i was prepared for something like this, but i'm sure some others are pretty shocked.

Meh. I don't really care about a suspension like this. It hurts the 49ers, which sucks, but so what. Cleaning up the game is what's important. I'd be more worried that Ray Rice can KO his wife and only get 2 games for it.
Originally posted by theduke85:
Originally posted by baltien:
Originally posted by natrone06:
It comes down to the pattern of behavior. I really think the incedent at the airport was the nail in the coffin. If Godell didn't believe rehab had any impact on Aldon he was unlikely to consider it when handing down the suspension.

Smart move by him also waiting till after he said he was wrong about ray rice to suspend aldon for that length.

What are you talking about? NO charges were filed in the "incident" you described. It boiled down to some petty he said/she said stuff.

That's why the DA didn't press forward with charges, because it would've been laughed out of court.
Who cares? Stop making excuses for Aldon. Goodell does not care about the court of law, he cares about personal conduct. Unless you think the LAX was just completely fabricated by the TSA agents, then you have to admit that Aldon displayed poor judgement. The guy was already on thin ice, to exacerbate the situation even more by doing something stupid made it even worse.

It comes off as so apologetic and defensive when people say, "well, he didn't get charged", or "well, he's charges were reduced". That doesn't matter! Goodell does not care about the charges, he cares about the fact that Aldon put himself into bad situations in the first place!

Uh, it does matter because if someone is to be punished for a crime or misconduct.....then a probable instance of said misconduct should exist. Aldon is no angel, however, you are essentially defending Goodell's idiocy in that if he *thinks* you did something wrong he reserves the right to punish you regardless of the facts. That isn't his place.

As much as he may think he is, Goodell isn't God.
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Oscar ‏@BetterRivals 50s
It sounds like 9 games is a settlement. Aldon can be around the team, just not play in games. And he CANNOT appeal. #49ers

what kind of deal is that?
Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:
I don't have a problem with Any length of suspension. If he don't want suspended then don't be a dumb ass. It's easy.

I agree with the second part of your statement. I just feel it's excessive.
Ray Rice has gotta be the happiest guy in the Nfl right now.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,497
Ian Rapoport ‏@RapSheet

#49ers LB Aldon Smith has already appealed and lost. So the 9-game suspension is final.
Originally posted by crabman82:
Cam Inman ‏@CamInman now
As for lighter punishment for Aldon Smith through an appeal, NFL spokesman Greg Aiello said in an email "The appeal process is concluded."


Welp, that's that. 9 games it is. Might explain why this took so long. The ruling and appeal process probably all happened behind the scenes, unknown to the media. I'd rather that be the case than Goodell completely catching us off-guard with his madness.
9 games is the appeal? What kind of joke is that?
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Oscar ‏@BetterRivals 50s
It sounds like 9 games is a settlement. Aldon can be around the team, just not play in games. And he CANNOT appeal. #49ers

WOW that is crazy. How the hell did that get settled on
Originally posted by Jcool:
Ian Rapoport ‏@RapSheet

#49ers LB Aldon Smith has already appealed and lost. So the 9-game suspension is final.

wow

well be cant get in trouble EVER again
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Starting to think he was just caught off guard with the question and just brushed it off. Like "yeah, yeah, sure, we'll consider it"...

He was never going to take the time in rehab into account. I'll that talk about "It's not about punishment, it's about stopping the behavior" was b******t. He's a f**king liar. He planned on screwing us from the very start. Look how long he dragged this out and the ruling is absurd.

Roger just basically made himself look even more bad, I too think he was caught off guard but there are other ways of going around the question. At least say " no comment at this time, we'll look at the case and make a decision" i can live with 4 or 5 games but 9 tho? While a wife beater gets 2? Roger Goodell is Bullsh*t
NO OTHER NFL PLAYER WILL GET ANYWHERE THAT KIND OF F^^^&K**** TIME WITHOUT VIOLATING substance abuse policy which SMITH HAS NOT DONE!!!!GOODALL ISTHE Biggest f^k*n tool in the NFL that IMBECILE LOSER D*BAG. SMith has not HURT ANYONE PHYSICALLY!!!! AND has already gone into rehab and is BY AL ACCOUNTS CLEAN WHAT a frickin dou&bag GOOdall F$%^Face Jerk. Give it extra hard to thiose working to help themselves jerkoff!!! Go give yourself a concussion you giant TOOL!
It will be a test of our team's character... The thing that brings some solace out of this is that hopefully, by December/January we will have Bowman, Aldon, Lattimore, and Dorsey/ or Martin for the playoff run
Hopefully The Lambs cut Michael Sam and the 49ers scoop him up to help Lynch and Lemon.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone