NFL Network's Top 10: "Worst Free Agent Signings"

10. RB Emmitt Smith to the Cardinals

9. QB Scott Mitchell to the Lions

8. RB Ahman Green to the Texans

7. QB Jeff Garcia to the Browns

6. WR David Boston to the Chargers

5. QB Neil O'Donnell to the Jets

4. WR Andre Rison to the Browns

3. Raiders Super Bowl MVPs (Desmond Howard and Larry Brown)

2. WR Alvin Harper to the Buccaneers

1. Anyone to the Redskins


Comments? Reactions?

[ Edited by PTulini on Apr 27, 2011 at 22:01:43 ]

Tully Banta-Cain... Who was the Motherf**ker that said he'd get 15 sacks

Where the hell is "Nate Clements to the 49ers?"

Just watched that as well. Dominic Rhodes should have been MVP but Manning got it instead but he could have been on the list for the Raiders as well. We have had a couple as well...Lawrence Phillips, Gabe Wilkins, Antonio Langham, Brandon Jones, etc.

Brandon was 16.5 for 5 years and only had 1 catch. Tully didn't sign for that much. Nate has gotten no where near that 80 million and hasn't been that bad. I think they kind of went based on expectations as well because there have been more recent ones that have gotten a lot more money than those in the past. Like they said 17 million was huge, now it's 50-100 million.

[ Edited by Gore_21 on Apr 27, 2011 at 22:21:52 ]

albert haynesworth has got to be the worst

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
albert haynesworth has got to be the worst

He's included at #1.

Aren't most of those signings of players that were already near the end of their careers?

how is lawrence phillips not on this list?

Originally posted by backontop:
how is lawrence phillips not on this list?

Because its based on players who were good before going to another team in free agency.

Philips is top 10 on the all time NFL bust list.

Originally posted by aman49:

Originally posted by backontop:
how is lawrence phillips not on this list?

Because its based on players who were good before going to another team in free agency.

Philips is top 10 on the all time NFL bust list.

ahh wasn't aware they had to be good before. I was basing it on him ending Steve Young's career.

The Redskins

Adam Archuleta
Deion Sanders
Dana Stubblefield
Jeff George
Jeremiah Trotter
Albert Haynesworth
Donovan McNabb
Brandon Lloyd

Javon Walker to the Raiders.
DeAngelo Hall to the Raiders.

Originally posted by Kalen49ers:
Javon Walker to the Raiders.
DeAngelo Hall to the Raiders.

Good ones

Originally posted by zillabeast:
Where the hell is "Nate Clements to the 49ers?"

I dont see how Clements belongs anywhere near this list.

antonio langham