Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
There are 629 users in the forums
Trent Edwards is a Free Agent
Nov 30, 2010 at 11:07 PM
- jojomellon
- Member
- Posts: 1,793
Nov 30, 2010 at 11:08 PM
- AB81Rules
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 34,201
Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Dec 1, 2010 at 2:54 AM
- GEEK
- Veteran
- Posts: 19,432
Originally posted by AB83Rules:Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Okay they have names per se, but they are producing at a level similar to an Arnaz Battle. They are not blue chip WR players yet. They could be if they continue to develop, but they aren't really household names at the moment.
Dec 1, 2010 at 7:45 AM
- binary2nd
- Member
- Posts: 1,345
Garrard is turrible, let's move on.
Dec 1, 2010 at 9:06 AM
- jojomellon
- Member
- Posts: 1,793
Originally posted by AB83Rules:One's a third round pick with no 1000 yard seasons, the other is a second year 4th round pick. You're right. Those guys are huge names. He's throwing to two Jerry Rices!Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Dec 1, 2010 at 12:36 PM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,494
Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by AB83Rules:One's a third round pick with no 1000 yard seasons, the other is a second year 4th round pick. You're right. Those guys are huge names. He's throwing to two Jerry Rices!Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Sims-Walker isn't a no name...he's not a Moss but he's not a slouch either
Dec 1, 2010 at 5:01 PM
- Rubberneck36
- HOF
- Posts: 141,822
Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by AB83Rules:One's a third round pick with no 1000 yard seasons, the other is a second year 4th round pick. You're right. Those guys are huge names. He's throwing to two Jerry Rices!Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Exactly, Sims-Walker isn't a no name...he's not a Moss but he's not a slouch either
Sims-Walker is a very good WR. How come everytime someone makes a point, they bring a super super star into it. There is only one Jerry Rice, but he isnt the only great or good WR...jeez
And there have been plenty of great players picked in the late rounds bubby.
Dec 1, 2010 at 6:08 PM
- jojomellon
- Member
- Posts: 1,793
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by AB83Rules:One's a third round pick with no 1000 yard seasons, the other is a second year 4th round pick. You're right. Those guys are huge names. He's throwing to two Jerry Rices!Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Exactly, Sims-Walker isn't a no name...he's not a Moss but he's not a slouch either
Sims-Walker is a very good WR. How come everytime someone makes a point, they bring a super super star into it. There is only one Jerry Rice, but he isnt the only great or good WR...jeez
And there have been plenty of great players picked in the late rounds bubby.
No doubt about that all, I'm just saying, Garrard is throwing to two inexperienced guys and still putting up very efficient numbers. He had a few bad games but has had a very good year overall.
Dec 1, 2010 at 9:59 PM
- jrg
- Veteran
- Posts: 166,549
Trent Edwards is a free agent.
Good for him.
Good for him.
Dec 2, 2010 at 7:02 AM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,494
Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Rubberneck36:Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by AB83Rules:One's a third round pick with no 1000 yard seasons, the other is a second year 4th round pick. You're right. Those guys are huge names. He's throwing to two Jerry Rices!Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by GEEK:no doubt hes inconsistent, but the DA comparison still makes no sense. Garrad's played very well as of late. And hes throwing to no name WR's.Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by Frisco69ers:Originally posted by jojomellon:
Garrard is completing 66 percent of his passes, 17tds to 11 ints, rating of 94. Leading the league in TD %.
Absolutely atrocious.
just wait and see he is alot like Derek Anderson 1 good year and then
Um, he's been a starter since 06, only had one really down year. So your comparison makes no sense,
He's been inconsistent and the reason why he's been the starter for the most part is because they don't have a franchise QB to replace him nor have they brought in any legit competition.
how are Mike Sims-Walker and Mike Thomas no name WRs?
Exactly, Sims-Walker isn't a no name...he's not a Moss but he's not a slouch either
Sims-Walker is a very good WR. How come everytime someone makes a point, they bring a super super star into it. There is only one Jerry Rice, but he isnt the only great or good WR...jeez
And there have been plenty of great players picked in the late rounds bubby.
No doubt about that all, I'm just saying, Garrard is throwing to two inexperienced guys and still putting up very efficient numbers. He had a few bad games but has had a very good year overall.
Garrard is not a great QB, he is playing better then I thought he would this year but he is not a "get me to the Superbowl" kind of guy.
Dec 2, 2010 at 8:04 AM
- lamontb
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,400
Yep Garrard has played very well. Especially after basically being written off by everybody. And with his and the coaches job on the line he stepped up instead of folded. And he has his team in 1st place in the division with Schaub and Manning.
Dec 3, 2010 at 2:27 PM
- hondakillerzx
- Veteran
- Posts: 19,281
if we get Harbaugh maybe he brings in Edwards, he was a baller at stanford in harbaughs system. with our annual end of the year "run" we wont be close enough to get at Andrew Luck without giving up our whole draft. could sign edwards as a backup and draft a rook to groom.
Dec 27, 2010 at 11:59 AM
- TheXFactor
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,990
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
if we get Harbaugh maybe he brings in Edwards, he was a baller at stanford in harbaughs system. with our annual end of the year "run" we wont be close enough to get at Andrew Luck without giving up our whole draft. could sign edwards as a backup and draft a rook to groom.
very good point
Dec 27, 2010 at 12:34 PM
- fanmusclecars
- Veteran
- Posts: 9,222
Originally posted by lamontb:
Yep Garrard has played very well. Especially after basically being written off by everybody. And with his and the coaches job on the line he stepped up instead of folded. And he has his team in 1st place in the division with Schaub and Manning.
Garrard finally had a bad game yesterday.
Still had a career high season though.
Dec 27, 2010 at 9:23 PM
- WillisToHOF
- Veteran
- Posts: 173
Trent Edwards in a niner uniform makes me 