Kyle Williams

This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

- add to that, there was a game where he tried to be cute and 1-hand a sideline pass... which is cool when it works, but when it costs us first downs? Not so much.

- He was also responsible for at least one of those back-to-back "pick" plays that cost us another drive. (NFCCG)

So the mistakes were certainly abundant... but he did show flashes as well. Bottom line... jury's still out.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

After that Seattle game, I didn't feel comfortable with him at all on special teams. But had no issues when he was in at Wide Receiver. I always had an ancy, on-the-edge-of-my-seat kinda feeling when he would wave his hand to return punts, but never did I expect what happened in the NFCC

Originally posted by oldman9er:
- add to that, there was a game where he tried to be cute and 1-hand a sideline pass... which is cool when it works, but when it costs us first downs? Not so much.

- He was also responsible for at least one of those back-to-back "pick" plays that cost us another drive.

So the mistakes were certainly abundant... but he did show flashes as well. Bottom line... jury's still out.

LMAO this is REALLY starting to sound like an Alex Smith type thread but instead with kyle williams

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

After that Seattle game, I didn't feel comfortable with him at all on special teams. But had no issues when he was in at Wide Receiver. I always had an ancy, on-the-edge-of-my-seat kinda feeling when he would wave his hand to return punts, but never did I expect what happened in the NFCC

Yeah me to. He made some blunders during the regular season, but never cost us a game.

Then he cost us a superbowl.... A f**king superbowl....

Originally posted by oldman9er:

^ guys, I think it's somewhere in the middle here.

Kyle has shown great hands at times to pluck the ball... occasionally better than most of the receivers we have had (which isn't saying that much).

He also has a whole lot more to prove before calling him special. Right now, I view him as quality depth at the # 3 thru # 5 spot.

We can't fairly call him special or great... we can't fairly call him teh suxxorz...

No one is calling him special. I'm just saying he's the most complete receiver we have and because of that, he will be used often. We signed Mario and Moss to give us primarily deep threat speed, but neither of these guys have proven to be underneath guys. Crabtree needs to prove he can play faster. Ginn is anything but a complete receiver. AJ can't even show RAC in his highlights so he has to prove it.

Kyle is the only receiver we have that has shown all facets of the position ie., complete.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

After that Seattle game, I didn't feel comfortable with him at all on special teams. But had no issues when he was in at Wide Receiver. I always had an ancy, on-the-edge-of-my-seat kinda feeling when he would wave his hand to return punts, but never did I expect what happened in the NFCC

Yeah me to. He made some blunders during the regular season, but never cost us a game.

Then he cost us a superbowl.... A f**king superbowl....

lol watch him become the next Steve Smith and help us win 2 more though

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

After that Seattle game, I didn't feel comfortable with him at all on special teams. But had no issues when he was in at Wide Receiver. I always had an ancy, on-the-edge-of-my-seat kinda feeling when he would wave his hand to return punts, but never did I expect what happened in the NFCC

Yeah me to. He made some blunders during the regular season, but never cost us a game.

Then he cost us a superbowl.... A f**king superbowl....

Luckily I knew he wasn't COMPLETELY useless..And didn't call for his head. Yes I was pissed after the game, in shock, but I hadn't lost all rational thought. Some people on the other hand, (as we all know) did want his head along with his family's

Originally posted by WillistheWall:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
This guy made some plays but also made some blunders during the season. I recall him fumbling in the regular season as well and also making mental errors (SEA game where he fell down and gave up and was blasted by MROB).

He had an AWFUL game at Seattle on special teams... Made risky diving catches on punt returns, and yeah the play you mentioned. I didn't forget those mishaps before the Giants game.....

Yup, When the amount of blunders = the amount of good plays, that is not good.

After that Seattle game, I didn't feel comfortable with him at all on special teams. But had no issues when he was in at Wide Receiver. I always had an ancy, on-the-edge-of-my-seat kinda feeling when he would wave his hand to return punts, but never did I expect what happened in the NFCC

Yeah me to. He made some blunders during the regular season, but never cost us a game.

Then he cost us a superbowl.... A f**king superbowl....

lol watch him become the next Steve Smith and help us win 2 more though

Hopefully, but unlikely.
'
He will probably be remembered for the fumbles and that's it.

Has he been cut yet?

This guy is making the team fo sho

lets just hope he doesnt have to return punts anymore

Originally posted by Tman:
This guy is making the team fo sho

lets just hope he doesnt have to return punts anymore

Apparently he was taking them in practice....

Please JH, learn ur lesson.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by Tman:
This guy is making the team fo sho

lets just hope he doesnt have to return punts anymore

Apparently he was taking them in practice....

Please JH, learn ur lesson.

As long as it is not a play-off game it is fine.