Originally posted by 5280High:Originally posted by NinerGM:Originally posted by TonyStarks:
Peyton Manning and Drew Brees are once in an era QB's.
That being said, they aren't perfect. The last super bowl was won on onside kicks and defensive t.d.'s.
I would Peyton Manning is .... not sure about Brees yet. If anything Brees, like Montana may have found the best system with Peyton as coach. We will see if New Orleans can sustain that output. Time is always the test.
Manning and Brady are certainly once in an era QB's, Brees needs to do it consistently for more than just two years to show he is more than the next Rich Gannon with Raiders, Trent Green with the Chiefs or Kurt Warner with the Rams/Cards (though you can make the argument that Warner is a HOF). Brees seems like a good guy so I'm rootin for him, but not penciling him in as a sure fire hall of famer just yet.
And I think I know what's missing... Optimism Hopefully this season will answer everyones questions.
I was a doubter of K. Warner when he was with the Rams, but after he managed to revive his career with the Cardinals, and played the key role in bringing them to the SB, I think the guy will have as a good shot at a HOF spot as any QB out there. The number of QBs who had brought more than one team to the SBs could be counted with just a few fingers. Even the great Montana could not take the Chiefs to the SB.
Brees will need one or two more great seasons to be a shoo-in for the HOF. Before 2009, he was just a slightly better Matt Schaub.
Manning will be voted in as soon as his 5 years wait is through.