This time, I don't use the CBS ranking only but I have spent a look at it and at NFL's big board respectively.
1st round (trade-down)
DT/DE Carl Davis, Iowa
Though his production was not constant, the guy seems to have all one would demand from a 5trech-prospect: he can play against the run and the pass, very athletic for his size and ovr. After a good year of coaching he could rise to a permanent starter on a very high level.
Alternative: CB, OG, WR
2nd round (trade-up)
OT/OG Cedric Ogbuehi
According to my research, he wasn't very good at LT but that is not why I am drafting him though Staley will turn 31 this year. I see Boone's successor here in the very first place but he also could take over for Davis at RT so that the latter one is able to move inside.
However, he is versatile and he is a first-round talent but "thanks" to his ACL tear, he could fall to this spot (like Tank in his draft respectively).
Alternative: OT (Jake Fisher), ILB
2nd round (original)
OLB/DE Owamagbe Odighizuwa, UCLA
I hope that he will fall due to his medical. Right now, he is more of a run-stuffer but has the demeanor to improve in the pass-rush pretty fast. Imho, he could be a short- or long-term replacement for Brooks (the latter one could move inside as suggested by some users here).
According to MD, other writers and my eyes this guy NEVER gives up on a play. NEVER. This kind of a player is always an improvement for a team.
Alternative: ILB
3rd round
WR Chris Conley, Georgia
seems to be more than just a workout warrior. He has got all the physical abilities one needs in a #1-WR, nice hands, experience in a run-heavy system, SEC-proven. Very nice character.
Alternative: different WR, RB
4th round (original)
NT David Parry, Stanford
Even if Mangini won't switch to a 2-gap-NT, we need a short- to mid-term alternative due to Ian Williams' huge injury-proneness. Dial and TJE can play this position as well but Dial seems to be more suitable at LDE and TJE is solid, very good backup, but not much more for now.
4th round (comp)
TE Blake Bell, Oklahoma
that one is very risky but besides an ageing Vernon Davis nobody is trustworthy. Vance will get another season to prove himself, Carrier and Celek in particular have showed that they could be capable but that's about it. We need to draft an additional TE, at least on day 3.
5th round
OLB/DE Zach Wagenmann, Montana
could be a servicable pass-rushing OLB. Perhaps he will push Lemonier a little bit.
6th round
RB Trey Williams, Texas A&M
I don't trust Reggie Bush's health at all. This guy can be a very dangerous returner and a reliable 3rd-down catcher, iirc. Just think of McCluster.
7th round (original)
CB/FS Deshazor Everett, Texas A&M
a FS-backup is needed, imho. Very agressive guy, perhaps not the best fit at CB or even at FS but I would try it out anyway, it's jiust a 7th-rounder
7th round (comp)
DT/DE Tory Slater, West Georgia
very athletic guy with huge upside, former WR. We have interviewed this guy. Practice squad in 2015.
OT/OG that high?
-you mean a first-round talent that low would be a steal if you ask me. True, for now the Tackle-positions, the RT in particular are set. But, like I have stated, Ogbuehi is a reaction to Boone's expiring contract. If we can extend Boone, then Ogbuehi would be a backup with starter quality for a very low price.
way too many OLBs!!!!
Aldon is entering his contract year and he is stupid enough to commit another stupid move. Lynch will play his 2nd season in the NFL, he is still a talent who could experience a down year, Skuta is gone, Brooks in his contract year and a very expensive btw and Lemonier is a nobody so far.
Thus, there is absolutely no need to overlook this group in the draft at all. Furthermore, we could move Brooks inside and solve the ILB-problem for at least a year. Or we could cut Brooks.
no backup-RB for Hyde?
Hunter is still there, we got some other prospects on the roster. And I cannot fill every need. Look at Rawls from Central Michigan as a priority FA if needed.
no QB?
this year's class is VERY weak, no thanks.
no CB high?
I don't rule out Baalke picking a CB early. We simply have a lot of solid players and Brock. And like with the RB, I cannot fill every need.
WR late?
sure, why not? We got a year to develop the guy into a starting WR.
we cannot keep all the d-liners we got after the prior acquisitions and this draft at all!!!!
true. Slater will land on the PS. Williams, Dorsey, Dockett, JSmith, Carradine, Dial, TJE, Parry, Davis is a lot. In 2014, we have carried 8 d-linemen so one will have to go. Imho, Dorsey is a candidate, if Mangini indeed wants to install a 2-gap-NT. Otherwise, TJE or Dial will be gone.
Also, we could leave four instead of five Safeties on the roster, especially if Ward is still viewed as a slot Corner.
4 RBs?
another difficult roster situation. Could be solved through a cut of Jerome Simpson in order to keep only 5 WR on the active roster and see Trey Williams as a kind of a tweener.
don't like your solutions!!!
Then trade away our original 4th-rounder. Parry is the only guy I could really pass on in my mock.
Any comments that can be useful for the discussion?
[ Edited by communist on Apr 21, 2015 at 4:05 AM ]