Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports
Anyone who follows the San Francisco 49ers on a regular basis knows that their general manager, Trent Baalke
, is stubbornly old school when it comes to building his football team. Baalke, who's an unapologetic Bill Parcells
disciple, seems married to the notion that running the ball and playing stout defense is the only way to go. While it's certainly hard to argue against this philosophy, the game has changed some since Parcells' heyday. Yes, being able to run and stop the run is still very valuable, but the NFL has evolved into a passing league.
Now I'm not saying that throwing the ball all over the field is the only way to win, but I would argue that sustaining long-term success has a lot to do with having an upper echelon quarterback and playmakers at his disposal. Can you win if you don't have those things? Absolutely, but the championship window will be a short one (i.e. the 49ers from 2011-2013). Baalke doesn't seem to feel the same way however, and he almost treats the quarterback and wide receiver positions like an afterthought.
The evidence for this theory is in the way he's approached the roster in recent years. Baalke has said repeatedly (and I agree with him) that you build your team through the draft. He's right, and successful franchises like the Green Bay Packers and Pittsburgh Steelers have shown that drafting well and rewarding your own players is the key to staying competitive. But those teams take a more balanced approach to drafting, where as Baalke seems to ignore players who, you know, actually make plays. In some instances Baalke seems to overdraft certain positions, despite a wide array of needs.
For example, the Niners have selected seven cornerbacks (seven!) since 2014. Those players are Jimmie Ward
, Dontae Johnson
, Keith Reaser
, Kenneth Acker
, Will Redmond
, Rashard Robinson
and Prince Charles Iworah
. Despite all of the attention they've paid to the position in the draft, there's a very good possibility that the undrafted Chris Davis
could end up winning the slot role this year. Were all of those corners really necessary? Wouldn't it have made more sense to concentrate on other areas that needed help like receiver or quarterback?
Let's look at the wide out position first. While the team looked good in 2013-2014 with Anquan Boldin
and Michael Crabtree
as starters, it was obvious a need was on the horizon. Boldin was getting older and Crabtree wasn't long from free agency. It was the perfect time to address the position via the draft, and develop a legitimate starter to take over in the coming years. This never seemed like a priority to Baalke though, who instead tried to hit on mid-to-late round picks the last four years. Did he become gun-shy after missing so badly with A.J. Jenkins
in the 1st-round of 2012? It's possible, but after you fall off the horse, you have to get back on. if you're afraid to draft certain positions, maybe you shouldn't be a general manager.
Either way, Baalke's wide receiver selections have been both uninspired and ineffective, as the list below points out.
||Receptions with 49ers
||Missed 2015 recovering from torn ACL
||First season with the team
Now Patton and Ellington will get their first crack at playing significant snaps this season, but neither is a sure thing at this point. With the results being mixed on those two at the moment, it's beyond frustrating the the only two selections at the position the past two seasons where a 4th-rounder coming off an ACL tear, and a 6th-round flyer. It seems like another pass catcher would have been a screaming need to me. They did splurge on Torrey Smith
as a free agent, but he's primarily a deep threat, and has no one to complement him at the moment.
Maybe though, just maybe, the issue isn't with guys like Patton and Ellington, but with the person who's supposed to be delivering the football. Now you could argue that the Niners thought they had a franchise quarterback with Colin Kaepernick
and there was no need to draft another one, but I would make two points against that.
The first is that if the team was so convinced Kaepernick was the answer, why did they give him what basically amounted to a year-to-year contract? When you give a player that type of deal, it's obvious that questions still linger about them moving forward. If that was the case, it would have made sense to draft another quarterback to develop. The second point is that even if you love your starter, it still can't hurt to have a good backup that's been brought along in your system. Take the New England Patriots for example. Having Tom Brady
didn't stop them from drafting Ryan Mallett
or Jimmy Garoppolo
, as those players not only provided the team with insurance, but also valuable trade chips.
Instead, Baalke decided to go the retread route by bringing in Colt McCoy
and Blaine Gabbert
, and almost ignoring the position all together in the draft. The only two quarterbacks selected since Kaepernick in 2011 were B.J. Daniels
(7th-round, 2013) and Jeff Driskel
(6th-round, 2016). The result is that the Niners have no idea what to expect behind center this year, and could be starting from scratch in 2017.
Obviously, the upcoming season still needs to play out, and there's always the possibility that someone like Gabbert or Patton could step up and prove themselves to be cornerstone pieces moving forward. But right now that would be an upset, and not something the 49ers can hang their hats on. Let's just hope that Baalke, if he's still the general manager, eventually comes to his senses and starts to address his roster like it's 2016, and not 1986.
Al Sacco has been covering the 49ers since 2013, and has had his work used by national outlets such as ESPN and USA TODAY. If you'd like to reach Al with a media request, please contact him via Twitter @AlSacco49
Date: August 22, 2016 at 12:47 PM
Comment: I wondering why we draft so many cb's
im not agianst it in any way, i mean trying to find that gem in the late round at that cb is excellent if that is what he is trying to do?
Date: August 20, 2016 at 8:45 AM
Comment: My best guess is that Baalke can't grade the offensive side of the ball. As far as drafting a QB in the first round, it puts too much pressure on Baalke. Plays it safe by drafting O-Lineman and D-backs.
Date: August 19, 2016 at 7:49 PM
Comment: To be perfectly fair though, had I chosen AJ Jenkins in the first round I would be terrified to pick a WR again too.
By: Mike Cortese
Date: August 18, 2016 at 7:07 PM
Comment: I agree with this article in many aspects. We are drafted to heavy in one position and ignoring other positions of need. however, this year there was no clear receiver trading up for that stood out. I think Baalke should have gone after a cornerback in the 2016 draft class, and a clear middle linebacker that can be a difference maker.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 7:46 PM
Comment: Its always been the qb kap ,you dont get worse in your prime or need a coach to hold your hand..a franchise qb should make a receiver great not stare down the target or only see one side of the field and is breaking fingers with baseball motions pass. instead they stop running there routs because they are not getting the ball anyways.receivers careers die with the 49ers, it's funny how they leave and revive there careers somewhere else now then can suddenly play again..Crabtree said it best get in them books and learn what your doing out there or greg cosell break down of kap..
Date: August 17, 2016 at 7:14 PM
Comment: The title of this article is misleading: Why have the 49ers ignored the quarterback and wide receiver positions? Yet this article focuses ONLY on Baalke. If this article is truly going to ask this question over that time period, one needs to look at each 49er regime during those drafts and ASK THE QUESTION, rather than assume or create some sort of false consistent decision-making/evaluation of players for every year reviewed. Al you make the mistake many make in their criticism of the 49ers, in that you don't criticize the 49ERS, you only single out one guy - who as we all know from the coaches' mouths themselves, Baalke never, ever is the draft czar - especially for QBs and WRs.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 3:40 PM
Comment: We did draft a QB in Kaep, then a funny thing happened, we found success and our picks were no longer top 10. This year we were in the top 10, but the price was to steep. I agree we need QB, but miss and you pay for it for many years especially have if you package picks, look at the past, there have been many misses. As for wr, I think if you look at those who succeeded they also had a good QB. So get a QB is more important than. Remember scheme was dictated by HC and OC not Baalke with the exception of Tomasula. Walsh aways said that you can build an offense with schemes. Plus it is a matter if you see someone you like. There have not been any worth it.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 2:28 PM
Comment: My bad, thought Phil Simms was in the Hall. Must have been thinking about his induction into the Giants Ring of Fame, or whatever it was called. That said, Parcels always had decent to great quarterbacks. I don't know what to make of Baalke. He seems to focus on defense, from which he does have a good eye.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:57 AM
Comment: I wouldn't say he's completely ignored it. This past year, we couldn't possibly give up the draft capital to get Goff or Wentz.. who I believe aren't stars in this league. Not even close. We had to rebuild this team up front. There wasn't a FA on the market worth signing... at least from the QB standpoint.
However, I do think we have swung and missed on some WR's. If there was any way we could have gotten an Alshon Jeffery.. that would have made Blaine Gabbert's life easier.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:53 AM
Comment: I just don't get how he can't find a decent reciever...he drafted Jenkins when Jeffrey was still on the board... why not steal a scout from a team that can actually draft wrs like the Giants or another team can't hurt bc ballke is pathetic at getting offensive playmakers
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:41 AM
Comment: No doubt that in order to be a perennial upper echelon team we will need to find that franchise QB we have lacked since 1999. I like the foundation we are building now, but we are still 2 or 3 good drafts away from being a powerhouse again. Baalke needs a guy who knows a good QB when he sees one. Maybe Chip Kelly is that guy. For both of their sakes he'd better be.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:39 AM
Comment: Parcel's quarterback in New York was Phil Sims, who is in the HOF... He didn't get there handing the ball off. I think it has a lot more to do with Baalke whiffing on receivers and quarterbacks in the draft and free agency, than his philosophy.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:10 AM
Comment: I don't see taking a long shot like that as being all that different to what we have done, and unlikely to achieve anything much. But if none of the current guys can make it, next year we are going to have to put together a mega deal to trade up to the top.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 11:07 AM
Comment: You seemed to mention that most of his WR selections have been mid to late round picks but failed to mention that so have the DB's. It's no surprise that Baalke is not great at selecting offensive talent. However, he is not alone in the selection process.
With Chip Kelly at the helm now, I expect better WR and QB selections in the future. This offseason was all about building up the offensive and defensive lines. while also getting some DB's who can press and jam recievers at the line for our new man coverage defense. Expect this franchise to go after a QB, WR and pass rushing OLB early in next years draft.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 10:41 AM
Comment: Not sure what really promising qb's Baalke has passed up in the draft Al.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 10:18 AM
Comment: Niners didn't learn from their own mistakes and they had to deal with personnel around to keep this "boat" floating. The worst part gonna be that 2017 offseason ain't gonna be a promising one either on FA or Draft. Watson, Kaaya and Falk could fit Kelly's system but not gonna put any of them as week 1 rookie starter then veteran FA's besides Brees are average at best (Mark Sanchez, Brian Hoyer,Landry Jones, Geno Smith,Mike Glennon, Ryan Nassib) to be bridge passer until rookie is groomed.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 10:09 AM
Comment: Baalke won't have a choice next year, if he still has a job. With all that cap space and his draft picks, they won't have any more excuses to fill these skill positions FINALLY.
Date: August 17, 2016 at 10:07 AM
Comment: Too many "red shirt" and "potential value" drafts, plus lack of knowledge/ability to draft offense. I believe that as a GM, Baalke is in over his head.