Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 646 users in the forums

2026 Draft Grade

Shop Find 49ers gear online

2026 Draft Grade

  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
with 110 votes, 45% of respondents have voted D+ or lower.

another 16% at C-.

Excessive influence on the value of the Black pick. Take that out and that number will diminish by 2/3.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
The same clowns that earn a living making worthless draft predictions are now making worthless draft evaluations.

Always got the "well he only failed because of the scheme fit or coaching" when the player or players dont pan out. That way you are never wrong in your evaluations.

That's a legitimate reason why a lot of players fail. Drafting a big arm QB for an offense that is mostly ball control or a QB that runs a lot when you want them to stay in the pocket is a common mistake. I remember when the Niners drafted Aaron Banks. We all thiught that was a pretty good pick. Well he had some injuries and it turned out he wasn't a good fit for the zone blocking scheme.

There are more misses than hits by every team. The general feeling is if you can get 2 starters out of every draft you've done well. If you get a guy that becomes a future hall of famer like Warner or Kittle then you've struck gold. Half the players in the league were undrafted. If teams hit on more picks there wouldn't be so many undrafted players.

The idea of trying to rate the draft when the players havn't even been to training camp yet is laughable. I admit I was confused at some of the picks because I hadn't heard much about them. In all the years I've followed the draft the Niners have picked a lot of players I didn't know much about. Many of them turned out to be very good. Some ended up in the HOF.

I have always believed that the HC and GM know more about the players than any of us does. We might see a certain guy in a couple games and watch some highlights. They evaluate talent based on all the game film from every game. They see the good and bad. None of us has access to all the reports they do. The one thing I hate is when fans say they could have picked so and so in a later round. Nobody knows if that guy would still be there. We don't know what other teams are going to do. The Rams took a QB with the 13th pick that most people felt would last until the end of the 1st or maybe the 2nd round. He probably won't play for at least a year and maybe 2. Was it a bad pick? Not if they like him and he ends up being a solid starter.
[ Edited by CatchMaster80 on Apr 27, 2026 at 1:49 PM ]
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 35,291
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
The same clowns that earn a living making worthless draft predictions are now making worthless draft evaluations.

Always got the "well he only failed because of the scheme fit or coaching" when the player or players dont pan out. That way you are never wrong in your evaluations.

That's a legitimate reason why a lot of players fail. Drafting a big arm QB for an offense that is mostly ball control or a QB that runs a lot when you want them to stay in the pocket is a common mistake. I remember when the Niners drafted Aaron Banks. We all thiught that was a pretty good pick. Well he had some injuries and it turned out he wasn't a good fit for the zone blocking scheme.

There are more misses than hits by every team. The general feeling is if you can get 2 starters out of every draft you've done well. If you get a guy that becomes a future hall of famer like Warner or Kittle then you've struck gold. Half the players in the league were undrafted. If teams hit on more picks there wouldn't be so many undrafted players.

The idea of trying to rate the draft when the players havn't even been to training camp yet is laughable. I admit I was confused at some of the picks because I hadn't heard much about them. In all the years I've followed the draft the Niners have picked a lot of players I didn't know much about. Many of them turned out to be very good. Some ended up in the HOF.

I have always believed that the HC and GM know more about the players than any of us does. We might see a certain guy in a couple games and watch some highlights. They evaluate talent based on all the game film from every game. They see the good and bad. None of us has access to all the reports they do. The one thing I hate is when fans say they could have picked so and so in a later round. Nobody knows if that guy would still be there. We don't know what other teams are going to do. The Rams took a QB with the 13th pick that most people felt would last until the end of the 1st or maybe the 2nd round. He probably won't play for at least a year and maybe 2. Was it a bad pick? Not if they like him and he ends up being a solid starter.

Great points Mr. Master of the Catch❗💯%👍🏆
[ Edited by Giedi on Apr 27, 2026 at 1:57 PM ]
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
with 110 votes, 45% of respondents have voted D+ or lower.

another 16% at C-.

Excessive influence on the value of the Black pick. Take that out and that number will diminish by 2/3.

There's a lot of question marks, not just "the Black pick."

Why pass on Cooper to take Stribling 5 picks later? Stribling is a better blocker, but cooper gets open better.
Why pass on Lomu to take two more developmental tackles later? You could still take Cruz as a developmental project.
We didn't draft a IOL. 27 other teams in the nfl did.
Here is what skynet says about drafting IOL: Interior line depth is now treated as a must-fill every draft cycle

Kyle and Lynch can provide answers to these questions, but the fundamentally its clear we are picking the best players that fit our system, rather than adjusting the system to fit the best football players available.
Weekend came and went and my brain still cant comprehend this mess of a Draft for the 49ers. I See no Immediate Impact players in there.

Has any body got a clear answer by Shanny/Lynch as to why a 3rd Rb Again??? with Major Glaring Issues on OL. Kittle replacement and Edge Pass rush help.

Out of all this picks i only see 1 the DT Halton making it to 5yrs with the 49ers.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 25,471
Originally posted by MTninerfan:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by MTninerfan:
Originally posted by Dshearn:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by MTninerfan:
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Shouldn't of used AI.

AI would've drafted the league consensus regardless of scheme fit and got an A grade from everyone.

I asked AI(gemini), "If I told you to come up with a system to pick the best nfl draftees that fit what the San Francisco 49ers coaching staff likes to do, give me the explanation as to why you chose the guys they drafted this year", here is what it came up with:

The San Francisco 49ers' 2026 draft class—headlined by WR De'Zhaun Stribling and RB Kaelon Black—is a textbook example of the "Shanahan-Lynch System." This system isn't just about raw talent; it's a rigorous filter for positionless versatility, high-end motor, and specific physical archetypes that fit their scheme.

Here is the system I'd use to evaluate these picks and the explanation for why these specific players were the "right" choices for San Francisco.

1. The "YAC-First" Wide Receiver Filter,
The System Rule: If a receiver can't block and can't create 5+ yards after the catch (YAC), they don't play for Kyle Shanahan.

  • The Pick: De'Zhaun Stribling (WR, Ole Miss)
  • Why he fits: At roughly 6'2", Stribling fits the physical profile of a "big slot" or "X" receiver who can handle the physical demands of the 49ers' run-heavy schemes. Shanahan loves receivers who play like "angry runners" once the ball is in their hands (think Deebo Samuel or Jauan Jennings). Stribling was drafted because he has the frame to crack-block safeties and the play-strength to break the first tackle on a slant route.

2. The "Bobby Turner" RB Protocol,
The System Rule: Do not overspend on RBs. Look for "One-Cut" runners with elite vision who can find the "cutback lane" in the Outside Zone scheme.

  • The Pick: Kaelon Black (RB, Indiana)
  • Why he fits: Running back coach Bobby Turner has a legendary track record of turning mid-to-late-round backs into 1,000-yard rushers. Black fits the mold of a "slasher"—a runner who doesn't dance in the backfield. He sees the hole, plants his foot, and gets vertical. With Christian McCaffrey leading the way, the 49ers needed a younger, cheaper insurance policy with the speed to threaten the edge on a toss play.

3. The "Wide-9" Defensive Line Mold
The System Rule: Defensive Line Coach Kris Kocurek wants "get-off" speed over everything. If a D-Liner can't explode off the ball in the first 1.5 yards, he isn't a 49er

  • The Picks: Romello Height (EDGE) and Gracen Halton (DL)
  • Why they fit: The 49ers operate a "Wide-9" front where the ends line up way outside the tackles. This requires extreme burst. Height and Halton are typical "Kocurek projects"—high-motor players who might have lacked elite college stats but possess the "explosive 10-yard split" that the 49ers' front office values. They are drafted to be rotational "wave" rushers who keep Nick Bosa fresh.

4. The "Length and Versatility" Secondary Check
The System Rule: With Raheem Morris influencing the defense, the team now prioritizes length and "do-it-all" versatility over pure lockdown speed.

  • The Pick: Ephesians Prysock (CB)
  • Why he fits: Prysock is a massive corner (6'4") who fits the trend of the 49ers moving toward longer, more physical defensive backs. The system here is to find players who can play "Match-Quarters" or "Cover 3" while having the size to tackle physical RBs in the flat. He follows the Deommodore Lenoir developmental path: high-upside length that can be coached into a starter by Year 2.

5. The "Agility-Over-Power" O-Line Standard
The System Rule: Offensive linemen must be able to move laterally. If a guard is too "heavy-footed," they can't reach the edge on a zone stretch.

  • The Pick: Carver Willis (OL)
  • Why he fits: Willis is the prototypical "Shanahan Lineman"—athletic and lean enough to get out in space and lead-block for a screen or a sweep. While the team needs to find an eventual successor to Trent Williams, Willis provides the interior depth required to keep the run game efficient.

Summary Checklist: Why this class?The 49ers didn't just pick "the best players available." They picked the players who survived these specific filter

  • Violence: Do they hit people? (Stribling/Prysock)
  • Suddenness: Do they have a fast 10-yard split? (Height/Black)
  • Intellect: Can they handle the most complex offensive playbook in the NFL? (Black/Willis)

Very interesting. It seems a pretty reasonable analysis. What does it mean? That our rigorous player selection requirements to fit shanny's system are inflexible and forcing us to throw a lot of quality draft talent in the garbage.

Hence no one understands what we're doing.

Maybe if we loosened up a bit we could get the best of all possible worlds.

I feel this only explains our quirky player selection and not our positional randomness.

The only thing that matter is can they play....

You start taking guys like Greenlaw, Huff, Purdy, Kittle in the 3rd...and sure a bunch of talking heads might have an issue....but it is not a real issue. It is just a bunch of people that think they know something acting like they know something.

I think its totally fair game to bag on any and all NFL teams when it comes to drafts...the whole thing is mostly a crap shoot...but at the end of the day draft picks only exist to gamble on players.

It is cool to call them out for gambling on the wrong players, but lets not loose sight of the vast majority of these dudes will not see year 4 in the NFL. Your guys, their guys...some other teams guys...they all fail.

So when we are talking about draft talent in the garbage...dude...a good chunk of these dudes are going to prove to not be NFL gold anyway.

It's hilarious watching people lose their minds over draft grades. These "grades" are based on "value" relative to pre-draft rankings, which become meaningless after the top 20 picks anyway. The 49ers clearly draft the guys they deem worth the gamble, regardless of what the "experts" think.

If these picks work out, critics will still moan about "poor value." If they don't, those same people will act like geniuses—even though most late-round picks fail regardless of their perceived value. Ultimately, if these guys hit and the team keeps winning, Lynch is safe. If not, he's gone. That's just the life of an NFL GM.

The problem with your argument is that none of the reaches by Kyle/Lynch have worked out. So there is simply no historical defense for their method.

Kittle, Warner, Demo, Greenlaw, Purdy? All later round guys who worked out. They haven't hit on early round guys(besides bosa), but they have drafted All-Pro's in later rounds, which has helped keep them a contender pretty much every year, which is why they still have jobs. Most NFL GM's can't say that.

Warner was a very slight reach but nothing crazy. And a 3rd round pick. Demo 5th, Kittle 5th, Purdy 7th, Greenlaw 5th. As I and others have stated, they draft pretty well in later rounds and are good at selecting UDFA's.

Those of us who are criticizing the draft are talking about the early round reaches and complete dismissal from Kyle/Lynch about draft value. They make their board and that's it; they don't care about the consensus nor value. They literally stated it. The problem is that simply hasn't worked out, so they have no justification for reaching the way that they do.
  • KiwiM
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,088
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
They still don't have anyone that can start at safety. I guess we will be throwing out last year's tactic again hoping the WRs drop the ball when they are open

There are a quite a few safeties still available in free agency and it no longer against the comp pick formula as its after the draft. We opened up more cap room over the weekend too by re-doing deals on the team.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by KiwiM:
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
They still don't have anyone that can start at safety. I guess we will be throwing out last year's tactic again hoping the WRs drop the ball when they are open

There are a quite a few safeties still available in free agency and it no longer against the comp pick formula as its after the draft. We opened up more cap room over the weekend too by re-doing deals on the team.

A quick look; Xavier Woods of the Titans is available. A fair upgrade over Brown in coverage but not so great against the run. Spotrac estimates his marker value at $4.8M/yr. That is roughly $1M more than Brown is getting now. Overall, he is not that much better than Brown.

Jimmy Ward and Harrison Smith are available. They both come with a respirator and a walker.

There are a number of others but they are all guys we would be screaming at next fall.
Originally posted by 49HD87:
Weekend came and went and my brain still cant comprehend this mess of a Draft for the 49ers. I See no Immediate Impact players in there.

Has any body got a clear answer by Shanny/Lynch as to why a 3rd Rb Again??? with Major Glaring Issues on OL. Kittle replacement and Edge Pass rush help.

Out of all this picks i only see 1 the DT Halton making it to 5yrs with the 49ers.

I posted this in the John Lynch thread, but it fits in here as well. This is a less pessimistic view of the draft from one of the 49er content creators. Don't know much about him, so feel free to take it for whatever you think it's worth. You should also check out the video that jonnydel did about the draft. If you actually take the time to watch them, I think it will give you a different perspective on the draft. If all of these guys can actually realize the potential that the team saw in them, this could end up being a pretty interesting class. Go Niners!

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
There's a lot of question marks, not just "the Black pick."

Why pass on Cooper to take Stribling 5 picks later? Stribling is a better blocker, but cooper gets open better.
Why pass on Lomu to take two more developmental tackles later? You could still take Cruz as a developmental project.
We didn't draft a IOL. 27 other teams in the nfl did.
Here is what skynet says about drafting IOL: Interior line depth is now treated as a must-fill every draft cycle

Kyle and Lynch can provide answers to these questions, but the fundamentally its clear we are picking the best players that fit our system, rather than adjusting the system to fit the best football players available.

After signing Trent Williams OT was not an early round need so taking Lomu was off the table

one of the OT is a guard who will compete for the starting spot

as for cooper it was clear he wasn't the target because we wanted someone to stretch the field and cooper would not do that I'm convinced the target at 27 was KC and once he was gone it pivoted to stribling
Originally posted by dj43:
A quick look; Xavier Woods of the Titans is available. A fair upgrade over Brown in coverage but not so great against the run. Spotrac estimates his marker value at $4.8M/yr. That is roughly $1M more than Brown is getting now. Overall, he is not that much better than Brown.

Jimmy Ward and Harrison Smith are available. They both come with a respirator and a walker.

There are a number of others but they are all guys we would be screaming at next fall.

Only positive wirh Jimmie would be he'd be in the right place and would make the tackle. Otherwise it could be bad from an athletic standpoint.

ok - with a little time to get more depth on these picks, I believe I can see better the logic of some of these picks - very skill targeted draft:

1. STRIBLING = Jennings with real speed - Jennings could break away with his physicality, but he wasn't a deep threat. And the 2025 season highlighted the limitations of 9ers receivers as deep threats that could open up the field. If the 9ers had a receiver that was tough underneath, a +run blocker, AND a deep threat, that could really put defenses in a bind and reduce how predictable the 9ers offense was last year. Now if KS will actually let the guy get on the field, the 9ers offence might be onto something special with him.

2. DE HEIGHT - Commentators are praising the value here. I'm no expert, but in the highlights I saw he seemed to be only a speed upfield rusher - BUT with the motor and speed to also chase down from behind. This may be exactly what they needed if guys can push the pocket (Osa, Mykel when inside) a guy to close out the flush out.

3. RB BLACK - Someone the trust on 3rd down?? -- He may not be a jitterbug, but he was effective. But more importantly, it's hard to take CMC off the field because he is also really smart/good at blitz pick up. Black is actually a competent receiver, but more importantly absolutely stones guys in blitz pick up. If you are truly fielding a pass down set - 4 receivers, 1 back - and want to spell CMC from the dirty work against blitzers, your back-up has to be capable of 3rd down blitz pick-up, and yet if the blitz doesn't come, then slip out to the flat, etc. He doesn't need to be CMC the receiver, or even CMC the runner.

4. DT Halton - Per Height - disruption up the middle forcing QB to flush.

5. CB Prysock AND LB Dugger -- they may seem unrelated, but I think both these picks are potential hybrid safety roles. Prysock with his length could press outside, but he also seems rangy enough to play the middle coverage disruptor and run supporter. Dugger seems like he could fill the same role as a former safety -- hybrid coverage linebacker / safety. It seemed like they were searching for this role with Pinnock and Brown last year, but neither could really do it.

And lastly - LG competition with the OTs Willis and even Cruz - yeah, he could be a swing tackle, but I think they are going to let the best player play LG regardless of how they are labeled. If Colby got stronger, he could be in the mix.
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

We didn't draft a IOL. 27 other teams in the nfl did.
Here is what skynet says about drafting IOL: Interior line depth is now treated as a must-fill every draft cycle

Drafting an OT that you plan to play at OG *is* drafting IOL. They literally announced him as a Guard.
[ Edited by captveg on Apr 27, 2026 at 5:06 PM ]
I truly hope this class becomes good-great for us 1st bc we need it to be for the future and 2nd to shove it to all the so called analyst, reporters who act like they know football, mostly Grant Cohn, I honestly don't know how he hasn't gotten beat up by a player yet with the disrespect he talks.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone