LISTEN: 49ers Defensive Coordinator Search & Roster Musings →

There are 206 users in the forums

Deebo vs Aiyuk

Shop Find 49ers gear online

Deebo vs Aiyuk

Without cmc and kittle deebo is significantly more of an asset. With them he's significantly less. We can give any of those dudes a short pass and have them bruise it for a big gain

Aiyuk is a better pure receiver which makes him for valuable because he's harder to replace what he brings currently. He also seems to have gotten tougher over the years.
After rewatching the game I realized that I forgot how involved Deebo was as well. 5 catches for 55 yards. He was targeted during clutch moments as well but just didn't get those TDs.

I think we are going to see these two alternating big games and Brock is going to get them both over 1000 yards!
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
In an octagon? Or a power slap match?

Dude power slap is wild 😝
BA is the odd man out
Haha....so unfaithful
Both. Duh. 🙄
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
In an octagon? Or a power slap match?

Dude power slap is wild 😝

Sure is. If you want an instant TBI this is your sport!
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
why do fans always want to divide the fan base with choose a side crap

Because they are fake ass fans. Probably follow Grant Cohn.
Real Niner Fans don't get down like that. 💯
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 38,582
Deebo is a superstar. Aiyuk is quickly showing he's the better overall WR. However Deebo can break a game open from anywhere on the field...
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
In an octagon? Or a power slap match?

Dude power slap is wild 😝

Sure is. If you want an instant TBI this is your sport!
getting close to this


Originally posted by BigBug415:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
why do fans always want to divide the fan base with choose a side crap

Because they are fake ass fans. Probably follow Grant Cohn.
Real Niner Fans don't get down like that. 💯

That's a pretty basic and simple minded take, do assume that someone is a "fake ass fan" because they ask a question like this. Granted the question made more sense before we cleared up so much cap space, but the reality is that with the salary cap, teams do face decisions like this. Our cap situation aside, not many teams have two highly paid wide receivers.

Any real fan would know that.
Aiyuk is more important to this team IMO. I think Deebo is looking better then last season and will have a better season this year. But if I had to choose one to keep going into the future i am definitely keeping Aiyuk. I thought this for a long time. Not just reacting to Aiyuk's massive game 1.
Aiyuk can run the full route tree. It's hard for Deebo to compete with that.
Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:
Without cmc and kittle deebo is significantly more of an asset. With them he's significantly less. We can give any of those dudes a short pass and have them bruise it for a big gain

Aiyuk is a better pure receiver which makes him for valuable because he's harder to replace what he brings currently. He also seems to have gotten tougher over the years.

Aiyuk has also been way more durable than Deebo so far.

If we cannot afford to keep them both, I am keeping Larry Fitzgerald *cough* I mean Brandon Aiyuk over Anquan Boldin *cough* I mean Deebo Samuel.
Originally posted by Bloodless:
Aiyuk is more important to this team IMO. I think Deebo is looking better then last season and will have a better season this year. But if I had to choose one to keep going into the future i am definitely keeping Aiyuk. I thought this for a long time. Not just reacting to Aiyuk's massive game 1.

Hard to say who's more important, unless you're Kyle, but Aiyuk is more exciting. Deebo does that hard work taking punishment running the ball, so I say keep both.
Share 49ersWebzone