Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 821 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by ads_2006:
Originally posted by RiceOwensStokes:
He made some bad throws sure, but Brock Purdy was also missing his top 5 WRs. Any other qb this would be a justifiable excuse for a bad performance. But when it's Purdy? "Lol not so good without the averagers"


He missed this one. He didn't play well at all. I'm tired of some 49ers fans being unable to admit fault with Brock Purdy. Every god damn QB has a bad game from time to time it happens. But nope it's always an excuse with Brock. He wasn't good yesterday and was a reason the team lost. That's it. Doesn't mean he's garbage now he just had a bad game.
Originally posted by ads_2006:
Originally posted by RiceOwensStokes:
He made some bad throws sure, but Brock Purdy was also missing his top 5 WRs. Any other qb this would be a justifiable excuse for a bad performance. But when it's Purdy? "Lol not so good without the averagers"


What's the problem with this play exactly? This is likely a completion to Cooks if Cooks and Kittle didn't run into each other.
  • bvc49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,945
I wouldn't want anyone else as my QB
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by ads_2006:
Originally posted by RiceOwensStokes:
He made some bad throws sure, but Brock Purdy was also missing his top 5 WRs. Any other qb this would be a justifiable excuse for a bad performance. But when it's Purdy? "Lol not so good without the averagers"


What's the problem with this play exactly? This is likely a completion to Cooks if Cooks and Kittle didn't run into each other.

He missed Watkins for what should have been a TD.
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
He missed this one. He didn't play well at all. I'm tired of some 49ers fans being unable to admit fault with Brock Purdy. Every god damn QB has a bad game from time to time it happens. But nope it's always an excuse with Brock. He wasn't good yesterday and was a reason the team lost. That's it. Doesn't mean he's garbage now he just had a bad game.

I can admit he had a bad game but on the flip side i seen countless posts even from well known NFL content creators saying Purdy's MVP chances are over. 1 bad game and that's it for him apparently. He's the only QB that can't have a bad game i guess. It's ridiculous.

Also I'd like to see any QB have a good game with their top 5 WRs missing. We'll probably never get a chance to see that since that only seems to happen to us.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by BleedsRedNGold:
Look at the film. Cowing gave up on the scramble drill.

Yeah I saw that Cowing is a bum

Yep. Upon further review, Cowing stopped running. So Purdy being Purdy and not throwing his teammate under the bus during the postgame interview.

Yeah, I was tryna figure out why Brock worded it the way he did in the presser. Did not make sense. Oh yeah, Brock isn't gunna be like that and say Cowing is a lazy scrap lol
I didn't like how Brock played yesterday but to say this is a cliche now. But in my opinion though, I think Brock played better than Mahomes yesterday. Mahomes was just anemic the whole game. At least Purdy played with some aggressiveness.
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
He missed this one. He didn't play well at all. I'm tired of some 49ers fans being unable to admit fault with Brock Purdy. Every god damn QB has a bad game from time to time it happens. But nope it's always an excuse with Brock. He wasn't good yesterday and was a reason the team lost. That's it. Doesn't mean he's garbage now he just had a bad game.
Why are you even worried about other 49er fans, like you said it doesn't mean anything
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by BleedsRedNGold:
Look at the film. Cowing gave up on the scramble drill.

Yeah I saw that Cowing is a bum

Yep. Upon further review, Cowing stopped running. So Purdy being Purdy and not throwing his teammate under the bus during the postgame interview.

Yup, I'm so tired of seeing cowing screw up plays. Hell of a catch by Bates though, incredible play by him. I'm ready for cowing to be cut, whoever we trade for - at any position, can have his roster spot. Lol
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
He missed this one. He didn't play well at all. I'm tired of some 49ers fans being unable to admit fault with Brock Purdy. Every god damn QB has a bad game from time to time it happens. But nope it's always an excuse with Brock. He wasn't good yesterday and was a reason the team lost. That's it. Doesn't mean he's garbage now he just had a bad game.
Why are you even worried about other 49er fans, like you said it doesn't mean anything

Everytime Purdy has a less than stellar game his critics quickly start saying he's a system QB or whatever. His game wasn't bad yesterday. He made som good throws and missed some but his favorite targets were all missing. Only Kittle was there for the entire game. It's hard for any QB when there top 4 receivers are all missing. Even CMC was only in there for about half the plays yesterday.

He wasn't great yesterday but he wasn't terrible either. He wasn't the reason the defense allowed the Falcons to control the clock and score 23 straight points.
Originally posted by Montana:
Yeah, I was tryna figure out why Brock worded it the way he did in the presser. Did not make sense. Oh yeah, Brock isn't gunna be like that and say Cowing is a lazy scrap lol

Brock said he was looking at Kirk. Haven't seen an all - 22 view from behind the play, but in the couple of broadcast highlights that were behind the play it looked like he was looking at Kirk the whole way.
Originally posted by miked1978:
I can admit he had a bad game but on the flip side i seen countless posts even from well known NFL content creators saying Purdy's MVP chances are over. 1 bad game and that's it for him apparently. He's the only QB that can't have a bad game i guess. It's ridiculous.

Also I'd like to see any QB have a good game with their top 5 WRs missing. We'll probably never get a chance to see that since that only seems to happen to us.

So true, just an average game by Brock, but like you said ANY QB would of done worse IMO with the weapons we had and McCaffery being out half the game.

Originally posted by 49erF90:
I didn't like how Brock played yesterday but to say this is a cliche now. But in my opinion though, I think Brock played better than Mahomes yesterday. Mahomes was just anemic the whole game. At least Purdy played with some aggressiveness.

Mahomes has not been that good at all this year and Allen has cost his team with ridiculous int's that seal the game. Again, Purdy has done WAY better vs top D's like Den or Sea in comparison to some of the "best" viewed qbs. Brock is still playing the BEST out of any qb this year, given the circumstances.
  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 11,941
Originally posted by miked1978:
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
He missed this one. He didn't play well at all. I'm tired of some 49ers fans being unable to admit fault with Brock Purdy. Every god damn QB has a bad game from time to time it happens. But nope it's always an excuse with Brock. He wasn't good yesterday and was a reason the team lost. That's it. Doesn't mean he's garbage now he just had a bad game.

I can admit he had a bad game but on the flip side i seen countless posts even from well known NFL content creators saying Purdy's MVP chances are over. 1 bad game and that's it for him apparently. He's the only QB that can't have a bad game i guess. It's ridiculous.

Also I'd like to see any QB have a good game with their top 5 WRs missing. We'll probably never get a chance to see that since that only seems to happen to us.

Idk. Maybe he had a bad game according to the standards we hold him to, but overall he was moving the offense in chunks. Being a gunslinger he's always going to make boneheaded mistakes like those 2 INTs, but overall he looked pretty impressive moving the team with a junk roster. I think the stat was the Niners moved the ball into Atl side of the field in 10 possessions. Yes his TOs cost us the game but I didn't look inept.
Originally posted by genus49:
Just one of those games with two terrific defensive plays that you just tip your hat to.

Though while I didn't think so during the game footage I do think it's BS that they called that an interception by Bates. The fact that you have the ref with his back to the play(where he can't see when the ball is actually brought in to time it to the foot) saying it's a pick and the guy who faced the play saying it was incomplete and they rule it an interception is incredibly ridiculous. Guaranteed had they stuck with the guy facing the plays call it stays as an incomplete pass.

When you slow it up that foot comes up before he secures the ball IMO. In order for his foot to still be touching dude must have spiderman grips where the ball just sticks as soon as it touches his fingers. Pretty sure no real human alive even a great NFL safety has that ability.

Of course it's still on Brock for trusting Cowing to do the right thing. Don't take that risk unless you trust the guy in that area to fight for the ball.

Second pick was another great play and one of those where Purdy simply didn't see him with the rush in his face and the guy delaying his drop. Still needed all of his 6'5 frame to go up and get that ball down to pick it off. That ball is a completion over probably 90% of the linebackers in the NFL right now.

Definitely not his finest hour but all things considered nobody in their right mind should be worried about Brock moving forward. As always the issue is the health of the guys around him. Need Mike and the other guys back asap.

Having an ugly game going into the bye week is never fun but when it brings you into the bye at 6-1 with a 2.5 game lead in the division maybe it's not a bad thing this time.

Front office may have needed an L to make trading a higher priority(we'll see how they respond)
Anyone on the squad buying their own stink now gets a reality check.
Ugly tape all around - offense, defense and special teams. Nobody safe. Enjoy your rest, heal up from any injuries/wounds but come back hungry and ready to play our best football after the bye.

Purdy didn't play up to his standard this week, but all this talk of "he s**t the bed" and he played terrible are way over the top. The Falcons D made 2 AMAZING plays on defense, and on the first one, Cowing just quit on the play on stopped running the sideline. Purdy also threw slightly high and behind Watkins on a big completion over the middle that might have been a TD if he leads him in stride, and missed Watkins another 1-2x.

Then there was the refs screwing Watkins on what should have been a TD on an absolute dime by Purdy at the pylon and another big completion that Watkins couldn't secure through the play.

Still, Purdy threw for 288 yds, 20 points and had them in position to go for the win at the end of the game. If 3-4 plays go differently, its the difference between a sub par game and a heroic performance.

Not a good game for Purdy, but literally every aspect of the team played sub par today. Let's not forget back to back fumbles by the RB's, fumble by Kittle, and only 3 pressures by the DL on 34 drop backs.
Originally posted by SB49er4life:
Purdy didn't play up to his standard this week, but all this talk of "he s**t the bed" and he played terrible are way over the top. The Falcons D made 2 AMAZING plays on defense, and on the first one, Cowing just quit on the play on stopped running the sideline. Purdy also threw slightly high and behind Watkins on a big completion over the middle that might have been a TD if he leads him in stride, and missed Watkins another 1-2x.

Then there was the refs screwing Watkins on what should have been a TD on an absolute dime by Purdy at the pylon and another big completion that Watkins couldn't secure through the play.

Still, Purdy threw for 288 yds, 20 points and had them in position to go for the win at the end of the game. If 3-4 plays go differently, its the difference between a sub par game and a heroic performance.

Not a good game for Purdy, but literally every aspect of the team played sub par today. Let's not forget back to back fumbles by the RB's, fumble by Kittle, and only 3 pressures by the DL on 34 drop backs.

I laughed a bit at the bolded. That was the correct call however we feel about the rule itself.

Still a good throw by Brock, and an almost great catch.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone