QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Crown:
I don't know how history will judge Purdy.

I do know he has been to more superbowls than the gods Allen and Lamar.

Doesn't mean he is better. But it does mean something.

Allen with KS and the roster Purdy has had since coming into the league would be an absolute cheat code. Lamar wouldn't be as good as Purdy has been.

lol you act like Allen has had s**t rosters. James White has been on par with 2024-2025 CMC. Purdy has had s**t for WR's with Jennings as his best in the last two seasons. Allen has had a pretty decent TE, a lot better than Tonges. Let's not forget Purdy has been in a tougher division. Too bad Purdy doesn't play the Jets, Phins and Brady-less Patriots.

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Allen with KS and the roster Purdy has had since coming into the league would be an absolute cheat code. Lamar wouldn't be as good as Purdy has been.

more often than not, Josh Allen has proven he possesses the choker's gene, not the clutch gene. not sure scheme can fix that.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Allen with KS and the roster Purdy has had since coming into the league would be an absolute cheat code. Lamar wouldn't be as good as Purdy has been.

more often than not, Josh Allen has proven he possesses the choker's gene, not the clutch gene. not sure scheme can fix that.

I'm leaning on that side of the fence too

Originally posted by Grande:

Originally posted by Crown:
I don't know how history will judge Purdy.

I do know he has been to more superbowls than the gods Allen and Lamar.

Doesn't mean he is better. But it does mean something.

This won't be popular but if he wins a ring he's Steve Young territory.

If he doesn't he's Jeff Garcia or Jimmy Garoppolo

Nope. Young had 7 or so passing titles and two MVPs. But based off his first four years alone + winning a ring, he's definitely top 3 - 5.

Its really a helluva start and while some may think he took over a good team- he did, but the offense went to another level when he took over.

I'd already put him over Jimmy G.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Allen with KS and the roster Purdy has had since coming into the league would be an absolute cheat code. Lamar wouldn't be as good as Purdy has been.

more often than not, Josh Allen has proven he possesses the choker's gene, not the clutch gene. not sure scheme can fix that.

I would like to see if that stands true with the 19-23 49ers roster and KS. I would be willing to bet it would be a different outcome for Josh. Plus how many QBs have that "gene" Mahomes? I can't think of anyone else that is currently playing.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Crown:
I don't know how history will judge Purdy.

I do know he has been to more superbowls than the gods Allen and Lamar.

Doesn't mean he is better. But it does mean something.

Allen with KS and the roster Purdy has had since coming into the league would be an absolute cheat code. Lamar wouldn't be as good as Purdy has been.

lol you act like Allen has had s**t rosters. James White has been on par with 2024-2025 CMC. Purdy has had s**t for WR's with Jennings as his best in the last two seasons. Allen has had a pretty decent TE, a lot better than Tonges. Let's not forget Purdy has been in a tougher division. Too bad Purdy doesn't play the Jets, Phins and Brady-less Patriots.

Rosters change every year. Purdy has had some years with good healthy receivers and some with virtually none. He's usually had CMC and Kittle to throw to which isn't bad. Allen has had mostly average WRs. Buffalo's defense has often let this team down in the playoffs.

In any case I doubt. many teams would take Purdy over Allen. Allen is a unique player with size, speed and a powerful arm. He also runs really well. Purdy is fine and he can certainly win but Allen is a notch above nearly every QB as far as overall traits. He often asked to put the team on his back more than any other QB with the possible exception of Lamar Jackson. I'm not sure Allen would be a great fit with the Niners but it would be fun to see.