QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I heard they can get out of the contract with minimal cap implications after 2026. If they keep him beyond that they can't get out of it without a big cap hit. Purdy needs to play well the rest of this season and next year or they may very well move on.

There are no outs in the contract.

Such a dumb contract. He was not the QB to give that kind of money to. Hopefully they can somehow surrounded him will elite guys at the skill positions again if they want to replicate 2023.

I'm sure you have more information on the situation than the team...

Nonstop overreactions here. Some of you are just complaining to just complain. It's happening with Purdy. It will happen with Mac. Only solution is to find an elite QB like Mahomes/Allen and that's not easy to do and would require a lot of roster and coaching turnover...in which case you'd be complaining about the rest of the roster and the coaching.

Wait.. you don't think any teams have ever given out bad contracts? Every contract the 49ers have ever done has 100% of the time worked in their favor?

I'm saying when it comes to the QB position the team understands who they have better than fans or people outside of the building.

Bad contracts happen, we've had 2 of them in recent history. However Jimmy G and Kap were different people who had different strengths and weaknesses.

You thinking Purdy isn't worth it. The team feels he was. It's up to him to prove them right. 2 games into his career after the extension which technically isn't even kicking in until next season is way too early to make any claims like he shouldn't have been signed.

The guy has a pretty good track record in the area that we've seen many regular season studs fold under pressure.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by Chance:
No, because the data shows--the eyeballs show--that Purdy was operating at an elite level in his own right. His average depth of throw has led the league since he's been behind center. His tape shows elite level anticipation throws, high level pocket maneuverability, and top notch processing. It's lazy to just pass off all his successes onto his supporting cast, then blame all his failures on himself. It's a truly dumb argument, but I guess you must think Mahomes is just a guy too, since he's been good, not great for the past two seasons.

FWIW Josh Allen won the MVP award last year with his leading WRs being Khalil Shakir who had 76 catches for 821 yards and 4 TDs and Mack Hollins with 31 catches for 378 yards and 5 TDs.

If we're being honest Lamar should've been MVP last year.

There was a time when a guy like Pierre Garçon was considered a nobody. Shakir has been a pretty solid WR. Just because he's not a huge name or early draft pick doesn't mean he's bad. He also had a top of the 2nd round rookie WR, first round TE and a great group of running backs, great OL and solid defense. Acting like he had scrubs is ignorant.

Let's not forget the one game Shakir missed last year Allen was 9/30 and 131 yards and 1 TD. Not exactly MVP numbers…

Originally posted by pillageDatazz:

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
You guys will never have the guts to accept that Brock is just another overpaid mid-tier QB

Second coming of Jimmy G string

A better deep throwing and playoff performing Jimmy G is worth the money…

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by bud49:
Brock take allll the time you need to get better. I want you back on the field fit and healthy with no excuses for the turnovers.

health is not the issue, it's trying to force it to CMC too many times. He needs to get back to hitting the open guy and not trying to take care of his homies

Quick when was CMC not open?

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
You guys will never have the guts to accept that Brock is just another overpaid mid-tier QB

No. But he did play scary sh%tty against the jags. That is true. Concussed maybe. Numb arm maybe. No idea what but he needs to get right before stepping on the field. No question.

Seems like you're really plugged in on the season.

Originally posted by derrickt:
Could it be that Brock even further is forcing the ball knowing how good his backup is? It's. It's not so much his lack of accuracy but judgement lately of taking care of the ball.

Brock is starting to be an injured alot lately also.

Here we go again…

Show me the plays where the issue was judgement and not accuracy.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
You guys will never have the guts to accept that Brock is just another overpaid mid-tier QB

No. But he did play scary sh%tty against the jags. That is true. Concussed maybe. Numb arm maybe. No idea what but he needs to get right before stepping on the field. No question.

We know what the issue is. It's called Turf Toe and it really messed up his accuracy. Not counting wet weather games, it was by far the worst game of his career accuracy-wise.

I can see that affecting Brock this year but what happened last year?
I think he is just taking too many risks with the ball.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by derrickt:
Could it be that Brock even further is forcing the ball knowing how good his backup is? It's. It's not so much his lack of accuracy but judgement lately of taking care of the ball.

Brock is starting to be an injured alot lately also.

Here we go again…

Show me the plays where the issue was judgement and not accuracy.

Not judgement but slow reads. He seemed to get stuck in his takes. That's why i mentioned the concussion.

Was the toe responsible for all the hospital balls? I don't know. That's why im wondering if his elbow is acting up.

One thing that doesn't help is our crappy pass blocking line which constantly gets our quarterbacks hit. It would be nice if they could have a clean pocket once in awhile. And Trust me, Mac Jones will go down quicker and harder than Brock. So our off-season strategy of totally disregarding a replacement for brendell and an upgrade on mckivitz does seem to make no sense whatsoever.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Not judgement but slow reads. He seemed to get stuck in his takes. That's why i mentioned the concussion.

Was the toe responsible for all the hospital balls? I don't know. That's why im wondering if his elbow is acting up.

One thing that doesn't help is our crappy pass blocking line which constantly gets our quarterbacks hit. It would be nice if they could have a clean pocket once in awhile. And Trust me, Mac Jones will go down quicker and harder than Brock. So our off-season strategy of totally disregarding a replacement for brendell and an upgrade on mckivitz does seem to make no sense whatsoever.

Yes. Several players talked about that being the issue with that injury.

Which were the slow reads btw?

Originally posted by bud49:
I can see that affecting Brock this year but what happened last year?
I think he is just taking too many risks with the ball.

Will ask you the same question, what were these too much risk throws?

Cuz to me the issue in that Jags game was clearly accuracy related.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Not judgement but slow reads. He seemed to get stuck in his takes. That's why i mentioned the concussion.

Was the toe responsible for all the hospital balls? I don't know. That's why im wondering if his elbow is acting up.

One thing that doesn't help is our crappy pass blocking line which constantly gets our quarterbacks hit. It would be nice if they could have a clean pocket once in awhile. And Trust me, Mac Jones will go down quicker and harder than Brock. So our off-season strategy of totally disregarding a replacement for brendell and an upgrade on mckivitz does seem to make no sense whatsoever.

Yes. Several players talked about that being the issue with that injury.

Which were the slow reads btw?

I dont know how anyone can even say "slow reads" when talking about Brock.

It is so obvious Brock holds the ball looking for a deep dagger down after down. That is not a slow read, that is a greedy QB....totally different ...

IMO Brock wanting Blood on every throw is his superpower, but I think it is totally fair to want Brock to be more in the moment....the line and weapons are not idea for what Brock wants to do....lets hope he adapts.... Right now staying upright and helping his line should have been priority one...lets see if he figures that out when he gets back on the field

Originally posted by Dshearn:
I dont know how anyone can even say "slow reads" when talking about Brock.

It is so obvious Brock holds the ball looking for a deep dagger down after down. That is not a slow read, that is a greedy QB....totally different ...

IMO Brock wanting Blood on every throw is his superpower, but I think it is totally fair to want Brock to be more in the moment....the line and weapons are not idea for what Brock wants to do....lets hope he adapts.... Right now staying upright and helping his line should have been priority one...lets see if he figures that out when he gets back on the field

That superpower was a lot more effective when he had a well-trained BA, along with Kittle, running those deep routes than with the crew he had at the end of last year and since the second quarter of the first game this year.

In the past, the 'zone had a special nickname for him given as the result of him taking those chunk play options. He is the same guy now, with the same personality, and the same play caller. The difference now is that the car only has air in one of the four tires - not rolling very well.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by bud49:
I can see that affecting Brock this year but what happened last year?
I think he is just taking too many risks with the ball.

Will ask you the same question, what were these too much risk throws?

Cuz to me the issue in that Jags game was clearly accuracy related.

Well let me ask what is the issue with the TD to int ratio from last year to now? Jags game "possibly" could have been an accuracy issue "maybe" but he did have some checkdowns. I'm not saying bench Brock he just need to cleanup the mistakes.

Brock is the best

Originally posted by bud49:
I can see that affecting Brock this year but what happened last year?
I think he is just taking too many risks with the ball.

Yeah last year he wasn't that good neither. It's not just this year. He was pretty mid most of last year as well. Fans don't wanna admit it but 2023 might've been an anomaly when he had the offensive player of the year in CMC.