There are 302 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,389
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Brock is still clearly hurting, IMO. I hope he has a nice bounce back. I'm disappointed that they rushed him back but maybe Mac wouldn't of been better cause his knee is pretty messed up.

we are super injured and it just doesn't seem to be getting better. I hope we can pull off a win on TNF, and the long rest week will help the guys get better

anyone who watches other games will see that nearly everyone has struggled this year.

my biggest concerns are still the o line and special teams. Our defense could be fixed with a trade for a good d end, which a handful can be bought.

silver lining is we played god awful and still had a chance to win it. I hope we have a big time bounce back against the rams. Let's hope the young guys bounce back and the team comes out with mad energy.

Bro, he just played poorly. Bad decisions, poor placement, isn't taking what is there etc etc.

We gotta get over the "he's hurt" stuff, all these players aren't playing at full health. It's football.

I like Brock and glad he's our dude, but at some point we gotta stop with the excuses. So he can only play well when the OL is perfect, it's 75 and sunny and he feels 100%?

We aren't gonna win many games when he's turning the ball over so much. I could be wrong but 1142 passing attempts with 34 TOs isn't good. Feel like Lawrence is better there and that's not a good thing

This post is spot-on. He played this way in week 1—and he played this way last season. It is now a trend. A bad one.

He did not play this way in week 1. His accuracy and ball placement was excellent week 1. We can call out the bad without extreme takes.

And NY that goes for you too, no need for hyperbole. Brock doesn't need a perfect OL or 75 and sunny. Guys need to make plays out there. It goes both ways...does every pass have to be perfect to be caught? Is it too much to ask that a ball not be bobbled up in the air so the defenders can grab it? Farrell fumbling it pretty sure had nothing to do with Purdy. Neither did Bourne dropping a huge 3rd down conversion and possible TD throw or the punt return TD allowed right after that play.

Purdy played poorly. I don't know if his injury was an issue but I do know there were plenty of sloppy mistakes by the players not named Purdy. And we're somehow shocked that QBs with inconsistent play around them aren't dominant? Bourne had 3 drops all on his own. A WR who Brock has barely practiced with and he's playing 2nd most WR reps in the game.

You take this game and flush it. Much bigger fish to fry now and arguably a bigger challenge, especially if Pearsall can't play. Everyone has to play better if we want to win Thursday and it definitely starts with Brock but no he doesn't need perfection...but whoever is out there also has to make plays for their QB. It won't always be pretty but guys get paid for a reason. If the play is there to make, make it or you're not beating good teams. We no longer have the roster to simply dog walk everyone.

It wasn't excellent in week 1. He had 2 ints and won the game on a 50/50 ball at best.

He was a lot better week 1 than yesterday, but wasn't great.
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
20 ints in last 19 regular season starts, definitely a trend.

atleast hes taking some blame.

Got dam - I knew it was bad, but not that bad.
I wanted to chalk up last year as a bad team year and believe this year will be different. But. This year is starting out worst than last year. I'm a big Brock fan and hope he turns it around.

Dramatic much?

We're 3-1. We were 2-2 last year with Bosa, Aiyuk, Jennings, Kittle all healthy.
Originally posted by pd24:
It wasn't excellent in week 1. He had 2 ints and won the game on a 50/50 ball at best.

He was a lot better week 1 than yesterday, but wasn't great.

I'm pretty sure what I wrote isn't confusing and yet you still managed to misinterpret it.

His accuracy and ball placement was excellent week 1
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
20 ints in last 19 regular season starts, definitely a trend.

atleast hes taking some blame.

Got dam - I knew it was bad, but not that bad.
I wanted to chalk up last year as a bad team year and believe this year will be different. But. This year is starting out worst than last year. I'm a big Brock fan and hope he turns it around.

Dramatic much?

We're 3-1. We were 2-2 last year with Bosa, Aiyuk, Jennings, Kittle all healthy.
You seem to be the dramatic one.
Originally posted by tankle104:
That game yesterday was just disheartening as a whole, IMO. I think We are better than that.

the only position that I think is a glaring weakness is pass rush. Without bosa we have nearly no pass rush. I'd like to see us make a trade.

hopefully this short week lets the guys forget and we can have a big bounce back. I'm concerned about Ricky

>>>the only position that I think is a glaring weakness is pass rush

Pass rush is definitely one of the areas of concern, but I'm more concerned with our inability to run the ball, especially in the endzone. The O-Line is often decent at pass protection, but they seem inept in run blocking this year....all of the opponents so far have been able to stuff the run. We need to be able to punch it into the endzone instead of settling for 3 points. And Trent Williams looks either hurt or just getting old.

Time for Shanahan to start putting some more emphasis on the O-Line in the next few drafts. He probably won't but I don't think we are winning any more trophies unless he changes his view. Maybe Lynch can override him on this because Shanny seems stubborn in not addressing a very glaring need.

I hope we can beat the Rams this Thursday, but I think 3-2 is coming. No way this team is a legit contender for a SB so I hope they don't give away draft capital to rent an expensive edge rusher this year.
  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,389
In his last 17 games he has played he is has a 7-10 record. 24 TDs and 16ints.
  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,389
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by pd24:
It wasn't excellent in week 1. He had 2 ints and won the game on a 50/50 ball at best.

He was a lot better week 1 than yesterday, but wasn't great.

I'm pretty sure what I wrote isn't confusing and yet you still managed to misinterpret it.

His accuracy and ball placement was excellent week 1

Thats great he competed over 70% of his passes. The turnovers and decision making was still bad.
  • irief
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 639
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
20 ints in last 19 regular season starts, definitely a trend.

atleast hes taking some blame.

Got dam - I knew it was bad, but not that bad.
I wanted to chalk up last year as a bad team year and believe this year will be different. But. This year is starting out worst than last year. I'm a big Brock fan and hope he turns it around.

Dramatic much?

We're 3-1. We were 2-2 last year with Bosa, Aiyuk, Jennings, Kittle all healthy.

3-1 in spite of Brock, not because of him. Mostly because of Saleh and a little Mac Jones.
  • Sickaa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,714
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
20 ints in last 19 regular season starts, definitely a trend.

atleast hes taking some blame.

Got dam - I knew it was bad, but not that bad.

He's basically a turnover machine at this point
  • irief
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 639
I used to be a fan of Brock's, but we've seen this movie before and it doesn't have a happy ending.
Originally posted by irief:
I used to be a fan of Brock's, but we've seen this movie before and it doesn't have a happy ending.

This is the risk teams make when they sign a QB to a big long term contract out of fear he'll enter free agency. Several teams do this in order to lock up their QB but after one or two seasons it's not always easy to make an accurtate assessment of the player's ability. It's a trend in ther NFL and it can cost the team dearly if they make the wrong decision.
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
20 ints in last 19 regular season starts, definitely a trend.

atleast hes taking some blame.

Got dam - I knew it was bad, but not that bad.
I wanted to chalk up last year as a bad team year and believe this year will be different. But. This year is starting out worst than last year. I'm a big Brock fan and hope he turns it around.

Dramatic much?

We're 3-1. We were 2-2 last year with Bosa, Aiyuk, Jennings, Kittle all healthy.
You seem to be the dramatic one.

You literally claimed this year is starting out worse than last year when we have a better record despite missing some of our best players on offense.
Originally posted by irief:
I used to be a fan of Brock's, but we've seen this movie before and it doesn't have a happy ending.

Any chance you want to share the powerball winning numbers since you have a view of the future?

At least you're a good fit for the webzone. We love to overreact here.

Our leading player in targets by 14 is CMC. Quick tell me which offense is looking great when the most targeted guy in the passing game is your RB?
Originally posted by irief:
3-1 in spite of Brock, not because of him. Mostly because of Saleh and a little Mac Jones.

Brock has played in 2 games.

One he won by doing the opposite of what you claimed he does and that's throwing a game winning TD missing 2 of his top weapons entering that game.

The second he was bad in however one pick bounced of McCaffrey's hands into the defender, a fumble by the backup TE after a first down into Jags territory. A huge drop(one of several) by Bourne which could've been a TD or minimum first down conversion and a huge gain, followed by a punt return TD.

Brock played poorly but there was also plenty other bad in that game that attributed to the one loss not Brock related.
  • pd24
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,389
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by irief:
3-1 in spite of Brock, not because of him. Mostly because of Saleh and a little Mac Jones.

Brock has played in 2 games.

One he won by doing the opposite of what you claimed he does and that's throwing a game winning TD missing 2 of his top weapons entering that game.

The second he was bad in however one pick bounced of McCaffrey's hands into the defender, a fumble by the backup TE after a first down into Jags territory. A huge drop(one of several) by Bourne which could've been a TD or minimum first down conversion and a huge gain, followed by a punt return TD.

Brock played poorly but there was also plenty other bad in that game that attributed to the one loss not Brock related.

That's all great. The point most people are making is he isn't playing up to what he is paid. His last 17 games show that, not just yesterday.

It may have been a mistake to pay him and we won't know until the end of this season or the next.

Since the Harbaugh days, this team has only been good when the money was invested everywhere else except the QB position. We paid a QB a lot 3 times in the last 10 or 11 years, whenever their money started to kick in cap wise, we went downhill.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone