QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Originally posted by kdoggie:
What the what. Let's be very clear here.

Jimmy doesn't escape a collapsing pocket and look downfield for open receivers like BCB. Jimmy doesn't have the legs to move up or around defenders looking to sack him. Jimmy doesn't scare defenses bc he's not as multi-dimensional as BCB.

There's a reason why Aiyuk and Kittle are putting up better numbers with BCB at QB. Because he can AND will take those shots downfield.

For those pro Jimmy, go back and look at the tape in the NFCCG. Go back and look how many times Kittle and Aiyuk were streaking up the sidelines wide ass open and Jimmy G never looked their way. Aiyuk was dejected AF for being so open and Jimmy not going his way. Ever. That's what you guys yearn for? Get real. We finally have a QB that can run the offense that Shanny wants to run. Enjoy the damn ride.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Teams have to wonder if Jimmy would be any good on their teams when he's not surrounded by all-star talent at nearly every position and doesn't have one of the two best offensive minds in the game calling plays for him. If a random 7th round rookie can come in and perform just as well as him, why should they pay him a ton of money?

Originally posted by q0c0p:
Jets will pay a lot for jimmy. They have a good team. Just missing the qb

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

Originally posted by ItsX4Number6:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

People act like Purdy outplaying Jimmy is a knock on Jimmy but Purdy has played better than most QBs ii. The entire league including beating and outplaying Brady, Tua, and Geno.

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by q0c0p:
Jets will pay a lot for jimmy. They have a good team. Just missing the qb

Or they can just give up a high draft pick for either Trey or Purdy, and have a cheaper QB for three years with more upside.

Why pay $16 million + for a 31 year old vet with maxed out potential vs. $1 to $8 million for a younger more talented QB?

Jimmy was traded for a 2nd with only 2 starts under his belt, that's less starting experience than either Brock and Trey at this point.

Plus, Jimmy isn't a good fit for the Shanahan system, he'll do better in Las Vegas or New England.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by ItsX4Number6:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by SinceXVI:
If Purdy wins #6, I'm sure Saleh will be on the line offering a 1st and Wilson for Trey, and the Niners would listen.

If NYJ don't go after JG they're crazy. I'll THROW MIA in that category if Tua chokes away the playoffs

Jimmy's market is tanking with each win by Purdy, as teams can see that the Niners are better off without hom, as they're putting up more points and completing more downfield plays.

that's not really true at all.

People act like Purdy outplaying Jimmy is a knock on Jimmy but Purdy has played better than most QBs ii. The entire league including beating and outplaying Brady, Tua, and Geno.

It's all relative to the talent that's around them. Would Purdy still be outplaying them if he was on their teams?

Originally posted by libertyforever:
When Jimmy was traded to SF, he was ready to play. And I think the Patriots could easily have gotten more in the trade if it was done during the off-season.

Trey is nowhere near ready to play. If a team wants to win and compete right away, they should trade for Jimmy and not Trey. Also, people know what Jimm G is, a top 15 QB or close to that.

Trey has a higher ceiling but also a very low floor. He can be a top 5 QB or a complete bust, or anywhere in between.

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by libertyforever:
When Jimmy was traded to SF, he was ready to play. And I think the Patriots could easily have gotten more in the trade if it was done during the off-season.

Trey is nowhere near ready to play. If a team wants to win and compete right away, they should trade for Jimmy and not Trey. Also, people know what Jimm G is, a top 15 QB or close to that.

Trey has a higher ceiling but also a very low floor. He can be a top 5 QB or a complete bust, or anywhere in between.

Nowhere near ready to play …
he's 2-2. I guess we know his floor.