QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
So, your going to keep him on the team for the next 3 years and get nothing for him when he walks?

What you think Bock is never gonna get hurt and gonna be an all-pro…no matter what? How about you let s**t play out? Those draft picks are gone regardless..that cash is tied to SF regardless.

Making rash decisions like that are silly.

Agreed. Through 6 seasons under Shanahan we have finished 1 season with the same QB playing every game. It would be dumb to get rid of Trey.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Alright, people the gushing over Brock is getting ridiculous. He's good, let's not jinx it and go overboard about it.

This is true. He's been good, but Kyle has set up a lot of easy throws for him and Brock has had quite a few throws where it's hard to even figure out who he was trying to throw it to. That said, a 7th round rookie running the offense this well has shown just how much Jimmy was holding this offense back.

So was Kyle not setting up easy throws for Trey and Jimmy or were they just not hitting on them?

Of course he was setting up easy throws for Jimmy. Brock's emergence just shows how much he was propping up Jimmy all of this time. Seeing how much better a 7th round rookie is performing than him, it's hard to say if Jimmy would even be a starting caliber QB in another offense without Kyle. After watching Brock, it's hard not to be mad that we wasted so much time on Jimmy now that we know how fraudulent he was.

As for Trey, sure Kyle probably set up some easy throws for him too, but the difference is that Trey didn't have Kittle or CMC for his games. Trey was also always intended to be a multi-year developmental project, so I'm not surprised that he was still struggling to find a groove in this offense due to his lack of experience.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
So was Kyle not setting up easy throws for Trey and Jimmy or were they just not hitting on them?

Why we putting Jimmy and Lance in the same category? We got 4 yrs worth of legit film of Jimmy and like 100 passing attempts for Lance

Because some fans want to make it out to be that all of Purdy's success has come from gimmie plays set up by Kyle. As if Purdy is merely a passenger and not the one in the driver's seat. The truth is, this offense has been better with Purdy than it has been with Jimmy. If Kyle was the real difference maker, why wasn't he setting up all of those same gimmie plays for Jimmy? Not to say that Jimmy wasn't playing well but so far Purdy has been out playing him this season. When I see such bs being posted, I am going to call it out. Give Purdy credit where credit is due and stop downplaying it, is all I'm asking.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
So was Kyle not setting up easy throws for Trey and Jimmy or were they just not hitting on them?

Why we putting Jimmy and Lance in the same category? We got 4 yrs worth of legit film of Jimmy and like 100 passing attempts for Lance

Because some fans want to make it out to be that all of Purdy's success has come from gimmie plays set up by Kyle. As if Purdy is merely a passenger and not the one in the driver's seat. The truth is, this offense has been better with Purdy than it has been with Jimmy. If Kyle was the real difference maker, why wasn't he setting up all of those same gimmie plays for Jimmy? Not to say that Jimmy wasn't playing well but so far Purdy has been out playing him this season. When I see such bs being posted, I am going to call it out. Give Purdy credit where credit is due and stop downplaying it, is all I'm asking.

Obviously, NY doesn't see Brock as the future.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Alright, people the gushing over Brock is getting ridiculous. He's good, let's not jinx it and go overboard about it.

This is true. He's been good, but Kyle has set up a lot of easy throws for him and Brock has had quite a few throws where it's hard to even figure out who he was trying to throw it to. That said, a 7th round rookie running the offense this well has shown just how much Jimmy was holding this offense back.

So was Kyle not setting up easy throws for Trey and Jimmy or were they just not hitting on them?

Of course he was setting up easy throws for Jimmy. Brock's emergence just shows how much he was propping up Jimmy all of this time. Seeing how much better a 7th round rookie is performing than him, it's hard to say if Jimmy would even be a starting caliber QB in another offense without Kyle. After watching Brock, it's hard not to be mad that we wasted so much time on Jimmy now that we know how fraudulent he was.

As for Trey, sure Kyle probably set up some easy throws for him too, but the difference is that Trey didn't have Kittle or CMC for his games. Trey was also always intended to be a multi-year developmental project, so I'm not surprised that he was still struggling to find a groove in this offense due to his lack of experience.

LOL Sure yeah right bloke lol

That is why they tried to start Trey this year? Because he was a multi year project That bit by itself just does not make logical sense. Jimmy won 70% of his games this year and around 67% of his games that he play in SF in the past 5 years. No other QB who started for the 49ers, including Trey, has been able to get anywhere near that until Purdy has come along. JG did not get those wins because he is as bad a player as you make out. He did it because he is a very efficient QB and this year was second in the league for efficiency.

Purdy is close to JGs efficiency but because he is explosive in the first 10 yards his ceiling is higher. He is also more accurate than JG outside the numbers. Trey is not as good as Purdy in these two areas either, nor efficiency.

But keep up the funny takes. You gave me a laugh

Originally posted by mayo49:
Just repeat what you just did in drafting Trey. If Brock flames out, draft a QB in the next few years. Come on, use your common sense, brother.

Here's some common sense SF has a most $20M in DM if they move him…you have him for 3 yrs if you want at a reasonable price. We ALL know SF goes though QBs like water and your plan is to have Brock and who? You gonna have to actually pay money for a legit backup/vet.

let's stop being instant gratification reactionary emotional fans for 2 secs. How about that for some common sense?

what's even sillier is you want to draft another QB if Brock fails lol…you actually gonna let that one develop or no?

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Agreed. Through 6 seasons under Shanahan we have finished 1 season with the same QB playing every game. It would be dumb to get rid of Trey.

All of this is obviously hypothetical but what if..

Baltimore moves on from Lamar due to his injuries and contract negotiations. They tag and trade Lamar then offers us a 1st for Trey?

What if Washington offers their 1st?

Basically, what would have to be the offer for you to even consider it?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Just repeat what you just did in drafting Trey. If Brock flames out, draft a QB in the next few years. Come on, use your common sense, brother.

Here's some common sense SF has a most $20M in DM if they move him…you have him for 3 yrs if you want at a reasonable price. We ALL know SF goes though QBs like water and your plan is to have Brock and who? You gonna have to actually pay money for a legit backup/vet.

let's stop being instant gratification reactionary emotional fans for 2 secs. How about that for some common sense?

what's even sillier is you want to draft another QB if Brock fails lol…you actually gonna let that one develop or no?

It is NOT 20m to move him. It would be 20 million to CUT him. 11 million to TRADE him.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Just repeat what you just did in drafting Trey. If Brock flames out, draft a QB in the next few years. Come on, use your common sense, brother.

Here's some common sense SF has a most $20M in DM if they move him…you have him for 3 yrs if you want at a reasonable price. We ALL know SF goes though QBs like water and your plan is to have Brock and who? You gonna have to actually pay money for a legit backup/vet.

let's stop being instant gratification reactionary emotional fans for 2 secs. How about that for some common sense?

what's even sillier is you want to draft another QB if Brock fails lol…you actually gonna let that one develop or no?

Draft one if you can't develop one. Come on, NY don't be so hard-headed.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Just repeat what you just did in drafting Trey. If Brock flames out, draft a QB in the next few years. Come on, use your common sense, brother.

Here's some common sense SF has a most $20M in DM if they move him…you have him for 3 yrs if you want at a reasonable price. We ALL know SF goes though QBs like water and your plan is to have Brock and who? You gonna have to actually pay money for a legit backup/vet.

let's stop being instant gratification reactionary emotional fans for 2 secs. How about that for some common sense?

what's even sillier is you want to draft another QB if Brock fails lol…you actually gonna let that one develop or no?

His 3 years expires at the end of next season doesn't it?

You agree that Purdy has now performed better than Trey and Purdy is most likely the starter next year right? And that Trey will only get an opportunity now before his three years expires if Purdy gets hurt? Right?

Purdy will win SBMVP and people will still be like "hold ur horses guys, too small of a sample size!"

lol

Originally posted by krizay:
It is NOT 20m to move him. It would be 20 million to CUT him. 11 million to TRADE him.

I'm seeing almost $17M

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I'm seeing almost $17M

17 would've been before this season. We are technically already in the 23 season as far as cap purposes go

Originally posted by mayo49:
Draft one if you can't develop one.

Lol so draft one and LET HIM develop? You gonna do that next time or no?

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
Purdy will win SBMVP and people will still be like "hold ur horses guys, too small of a sample size!"

lol

im hyped about brock but you are out of your mind if you think 4 starts is enough to crown him franchise qb. Let the season play out first.