QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Our michigan picks haven't been all that great lol...

Ambry Thomas, Ronnie Bell, our damn kicker...

Jake Moody 2023: 21-25 FGs (84%), 60/61 XP (98.4%)

Robbie Gould 2022: 27/32 FGs (84.4%), 50/51 XP (98%)

Overall:
Moody: 81/86 (94%)
Gould: 77/83 (92.7%)

But not a word about Gould last year and people want him back even now. Moody has done just as well this year

🤔🤔🤔

— Where's the defense? (@kittlefacts) January 8, 2024

ambry has come around - he's blossoming under wilks. Ronnie bell is still a rookie but has a lot of promise, I just don't want him in jennings role these playoffs are all. The kicker worries me because he's a rookie but I think he will be just fine long term.

I'll check it in the playoffs where Robbie was perfect.

Originally posted by Silky:
I respected NY during the Trey Lance era. It didn't pan out. NY is a Niner fan first and I'm sure he's thrilled with the progress Brock has made. It's ok to support someone, be wrong, and support the next guy without being labeled a hater. Can't we all just enjoy the season we've had so far without someone having to be right?

I don't believe NY ever hated on Brock. Guy had a handful of games to show us what he could do and was coming off a major elbow injury. It was not crazy to want to see a proper competition to make sure 49ers got the right guy for them long term.

They got the right guy for them long term. Now we know. Everyone should be on board now. Absolutely no reason to give people a hard time for wanting to see more from months ago when there was a ton of uncertainty about the QB position.

Originally posted by Silky:
I respected NY during the Trey Lance era. It didn't pan out. NY is a Niner fan first and I'm sure he's thrilled with the progress Brock has made. It's ok to support someone, be wrong, and support the next guy without being labeled a hater. Can't we all just enjoy the season we've had so far without someone having to be right?

The problem is in never admitting he was wrong and continuing to pretend that under some specific set of circumstances, that only he could envision, Lance would have been "the guy."

Originally posted by 49ers81:

Originally posted by Silky:
I respected NY during the Trey Lance era. It didn't pan out. NY is a Niner fan first and I'm sure he's thrilled with the progress Brock has made. It's ok to support someone, be wrong, and support the next guy without being labeled a hater. Can't we all just enjoy the season we've had so far without someone having to be right?

The problem is in never admitting he was wrong and continuing to pretend that under some specific set of circumstances, that only he could envision, Lance would have been "the guy."

I thought it was because we haven't seen him around much this season except after the 49ers lose.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Silky:
I respected NY during the Trey Lance era. It didn't pan out. NY is a Niner fan first and I'm sure he's thrilled with the progress Brock has made. It's ok to support someone, be wrong, and support the next guy without being labeled a hater. Can't we all just enjoy the season we've had so far without someone having to be right?

I don't believe NY ever hated on Brock. Guy had a handful of games to show us what he could do and was coming off a major elbow injury. It was not crazy to want to see a proper competition to make sure 49ers got the right guy for them long term.

They got the right guy for them long term. Now we know. Everyone should be on board now. Absolutely no reason to give people a hard time for wanting to see more from months ago when there was a ton of uncertainty about the QB position.

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Brock could win 10 Super Bowls, 6 MVPs, and be first ballot Hall of Famer and Nick Wright would still say he's a system QB and average.

Brock Purdy could win 10 super bowls, 6 MVP's, and be a first ballot hall of famer, and for whatever reason some of you would still care what this professional troll has to say.

Stop giving him clicks. He's saying these things to rile you up and get views/clicks, and it's working.

Nick the dick. What a dick. What a dick.

Tom green looking MFer lol

i could give two s**ts about what any of these daytime sports "analysts" have to say. Some of the dumbest minds in sports. Good for them to find a way to make $$ off doing/knowing nothing.

Pretending to be a Purdy fan again?

Pretending that everyone hates your favorite QB again?

I didn't say hate. But hundreds of posts about lack of arm talent and then dozens of "I told you so" posts in the gameday thread after interceptions or bad plays is enough evidence for me. NY demands a tall, fast, big arm QB; which Purdy is not.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ers81:

Originally posted by Silky:
I respected NY during the Trey Lance era. It didn't pan out. NY is a Niner fan first and I'm sure he's thrilled with the progress Brock has made. It's ok to support someone, be wrong, and support the next guy without being labeled a hater. Can't we all just enjoy the season we've had so far without someone having to be right?

The problem is in never admitting he was wrong and continuing to pretend that under some specific set of circumstances, that only he could envision, Lance would have been "the guy."

I thought it was because we haven't seen him around much this season except after the 49ers lose.

Both of these. I'm not the only one who see the hypocrisy.

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Brock could win 10 Super Bowls, 6 MVPs, and be first ballot Hall of Famer and Nick Wright would still say he's a system QB and average.

Brock Purdy could win 10 super bowls, 6 MVP's, and be a first ballot hall of famer, and for whatever reason some of you would still care what this professional troll has to say.

Stop giving him clicks. He's saying these things to rile you up and get views/clicks, and it's working.

Nick the dick. What a dick. What a dick.

Hahaha my name is Nick and I hate that his is too.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Brock could win 10 Super Bowls, 6 MVPs, and be first ballot Hall of Famer and Nick Wright would still say he's a system QB and average.

Brock Purdy could win 10 super bowls, 6 MVP's, and be a first ballot hall of famer, and for whatever reason some of you would still care what this professional troll has to say.

Stop giving him clicks. He's saying these things to rile you up and get views/clicks, and it's working.

Nick the dick. What a dick. What a dick.

Tom green looking MFer lol

i could give two s**ts about what any of these daytime sports "analysts" have to say. Some of the dumbest minds in sports. Good for them to find a way to make $$ off doing/knowing nothing.

Lol I said the thing a little while ago, crazy how much he looks like Tom Green now

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Brock could win 10 Super Bowls, 6 MVPs, and be first ballot Hall of Famer and Nick Wright would still say he's a system QB and average.

Brock Purdy could win 10 super bowls, 6 MVP's, and be a first ballot hall of famer, and for whatever reason some of you would still care what this professional troll has to say.

Stop giving him clicks. He's saying these things to rile you up and get views/clicks, and it's working.

Nick the dick. What a dick. What a dick.

Tom green looking MFer lol

i could give two s**ts about what any of these daytime sports "analysts" have to say. Some of the dumbest minds in sports. Good for them to find a way to make $$ off doing/knowing nothing.

Pretending to be a Purdy fan again?

Pretending that everyone hates your favorite QB again?

I didn't say hate. But hundreds of posts about lack of arm talent and then dozens of "I told you so" posts in the gameday thread after interceptions or bad plays is enough evidence for me. NY demands a tall, fast, big arm QB; which Purdy is not.

Someone having a different opinion of you doesn't give you the right to question their fandom. Even if he did think Trey played better than Purdy, which I don't think he did, it doesn't mean he doesn't like Purdy.

Heck, I was a fan of Trey and I disagreed with some of NY's points, and I voice those disagreements. Specifically the point about a players upside. I said having superior physical traits alone doesn't mean you have more upside. There's lost upside in someone's mental capabilities as well. Purdy's processing alone probably gives him more upside IMO.

This is a weird time now because it's almost unanimous that everyone loves Purdy, while Jimmy and Trey were two of the most controversial QBs in NFL history, not just on the 49ers.

Your threshold for how much criticism is acceptable doesn't really matter. I think criticizing someone's take is fair, but Jimmy is gone, Trey is gone, let's just be objective what we're seeing. We're all fans of the team and Purdy is clearly playing at the highest level since Garcia or Young.

Originally posted by Waterbear:
Someone having a different opinion of you doesn't give you the right to question their fandom. Even if he did think Trey played better than Purdy, which I don't think he did, it doesn't mean he doesn't like Purdy.

Heck, I was a fan of Trey and I disagreed with some of NY's points, and I voice those disagreements. Specifically the point about a players upside. I said having superior physical traits alone doesn't mean you have more upside. There's lost upside in someone's mental capabilities as well. Purdy's processing alone probably gives him more upside IMO.

This is a weird time now because it's almost unanimous that everyone loves Purdy, while Jimmy and Trey were two of the most controversial QBs in NFL history, not just on the 49ers.

Your threshold for how much criticism is acceptable doesn't really matter. I think criticizing someone's take is fair, but Jimmy is gone, Trey is gone, let's just be objective what we're seeing. We're all fans of the team and Purdy is clearly playing at the highest level since Garcia or Young.

If NY was doing a troll job like Cortez or others like him do in the Kyle threads I think it does. Or if NY bet on other teams to win the SB because he didn't think Purdy was up to it.

Otherwise I would agree.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by ninerjok:
Brock could win 10 Super Bowls, 6 MVPs, and be first ballot Hall of Famer and Nick Wright would still say he's a system QB and average.

Brock Purdy could win 10 super bowls, 6 MVP's, and be a first ballot hall of famer, and for whatever reason some of you would still care what this professional troll has to say.

Stop giving him clicks. He's saying these things to rile you up and get views/clicks, and it's working.

Nick the dick. What a dick. What a dick.

Tom green looking MFer lol

i could give two s**ts about what any of these daytime sports "analysts" have to say. Some of the dumbest minds in sports. Good for them to find a way to make $$ off doing/knowing nothing.

Lol I said the thing a little while ago, crazy how much he looks like Tom Green now

Tom Green with long hair. I was the first one to call that out a couple of months back. Its so true. He looks just like him.

lol I actually like Nicks takes sometimes.... I don't agree with his Purdy takes this year, but it was just opposite of whats happening now when Jimmy was the QB... it was Nick just saying Jimmy G doesn't have it with chris bossard bringing up stats of Jimmy G saying he does have it or is a great qb....

Originally posted by bud49:
I'll check it in the playoffs where Robbie was perfect.

As of now, Moody's still perfect as well.