Which starting QB would you prefer next year?

Originally posted by Heroism:

Someone really asked this? SMFH.

Originally posted by cjsmoove:
I can' believe somebody actually made this thread

I know what you mean...boowhaaaaaa.......!

Cousins and 2 firsts hands down. That's an easy choice. Cousins is older, but they're probably near the same level of ability and we could do a lot with 2 extra 1sts.

Originally posted by 49erThrowback:

Assumes the Niners can get Cousins if they want him, and that some QB-hungry team would be willing to part with two first round picks for Garoppolo. Which scenario do you like better, taking the big picture into account?

Easy. Give me Kirk Cousins and the 2 firsts.

Then we can trade Kirk to ANOTHER QB needy team (obviously because of Beathard) for another 2 first rounders. This will give Beathard enough time to develop into a FQB.

Right before Beatherd is at the cusp of being a FQB, we trade him for an additional 2 first rounders.

We'll go into the 2019 draft with 8 first round picks. We'll obviously trade those also to another team needing a QB.

By 2023 we should've traded enough to have all 32 picks in the first.

Originally posted by HERN:

Easy. Give me Kirk Cousins and the 2 firsts.

Then we can trade Kirk to ANOTHER QB needy team (obviously because of Beathard) for another 2 first rounders. This will give Beathard enough time to develop into a FQB.

Right before Beatherd is at the cusp of being a FQB, we trade him for an additional 2 first rounders.

We'll go into the 2019 draft with 8 first round picks. We'll obviously trade those also to another team needing a QB.

By 2023 we should've traded enough to have all 32 picks in the first.

HERN for GM!

Ty Detmer or Elvis Grbac

Originally posted by HERN:

Originally posted by 49erThrowback:
Assumes the Niners can get Cousins if they want him, and that some QB-hungry team would be willing to part with two first round picks for Garoppolo. Which scenario do you like better, taking the big picture into account?

Easy. Give me Kirk Cousins and the 2 firsts.

Then we can trade Kirk to ANOTHER QB needy team (obviously because of Beathard) for another 2 first rounders. This will give Beathard enough time to develop into a FQB.

Right before Beatherd is at the cusp of being a FQB, we trade him for an additional 2 first rounders.

We'll go into the 2019 draft with 8 first round picks. We'll obviously trade those also to another team needing a QB.II

By 2023 we should've traded enough to have all 32 picks in the first.

This really is the only answer that makes sense.

Can we sign Michael Robinson out of retirement? He flashed at Penn state :/

Garoppolo - 4 years younger and a better arm and accuracy.

At the moment, based on Cousins film and Jimmy Gs Pats/49ers film, we got the right guy.

Originally posted by bigmur49:

Originally posted by HERN:

Originally posted by 49erThrowback:

Assumes the Niners can get Cousins if they want him, and that some QB-hungry team would be willing to part with two first round picks for Garoppolo. Which scenario do you like better, taking the big picture into account?

Easy. Give me Kirk Cousins and the 2 firsts.

Then we can trade Kirk to ANOTHER QB needy team (obviously because of Beathard) for another 2 first rounders. This will give Beathard enough time to develop into a FQB.

Right before Beatherd is at the cusp of being a FQB, we trade him for an additional 2 first rounders.

We'll go into the 2019 draft with 8 first round picks. We'll obviously trade those also to another team needing a QB.II

By 2023 we should've traded enough to have all 32 picks in the first.

This really is the only answer that makes sense.

Perfect sense!

There is a Garoppolo thread. There is a Cousins thread. Right now, who is going to offer us 2 firsts for a Garoppolo just about to go out of contract? And why should we consider swopping, in effect, Garoppolo for Cousins? I prefer Jimmy. The two 1sts would make it a tough decision but as there is no indication at all that this complex collection of deals is at all doable, let's stay in reality and in the appropriate threads.