49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 768 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
Opting for a more fluid offense, the Niners may cut Bruce Miller. With Gore gone, Miller's lead blocking is less valuable. Particularly if Millard shows an ability to make yardage running the ball, the Niners might go with Millard and four TEs.

Please no starter named Pears. Trying Boone at LG to help him prepare his footwork should he need to replace Staley is bogus. Playing Boone at RT would prepare him just as well. This is either a concern for Boone's salary request or the threat of him leaving the team next year.

It sounds asinine to even consider cutting a top 3 FB (who can catch as well) BUT, like you noted, if Millard appears to add more versatility, this is something the coaches need to consider esp. regarding a trade or cut:

$1,746,500 (cap count) $446,500 (dead money) $1,300,000 (cap savings)

It does seem silly but with the log jam at TE and having so many good RBs I can't see them keeping two FBs. I thought maybe they would move Millard around with a little TE thrown in but they drafted Bell and Anderson!

Yeah, for technical purposes, I have Millard as an H-back until Carrier comes back from the PUP...it's a way to keep both Millard and Bruce (FB) on the 53...BUT, I just saw that Hyde has already lost 15 pounds. That' a lot for a power back...in my mind, this is a clear-cut move to a ZBS where we don't need a FB as much (or if at all). Something to think about...

Baalke recently told Matt Barrows of the Sacramento Bee that Hyde has dropped 15 pounds and is looking "extremely good" with the additional quickness.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Yeah, for technical purposes, I have Millard as an H-back until Carrier comes back from the PUP...it's a way to keep both Millard and Bruce (FB) on the 53...BUT, I just saw that Hyde has already lost 15 pounds. That' a lot for a power back...in my mind, this is a clear-cut move to a ZBS where we don't need a FB as much (or if at all). Something to think about...

Baalke recently told Matt Barrows of the Sacramento Bee that Hyde has dropped 15 pounds and is looking "extremely good" with the additional quickness.

Hyde will still be good size for a RB and Davis is very stout. My question would be--Who are the best recievers out of the backfield (besides Bush). Millard seemed very smooth as a reciever in college so he may have an edge. Roman seemed to think Miller was a great receiving threat... ...

Problem is...they can line up VD, Bell or Anderson in the backfield as well. But I can see a lot of empty backfields next year with RB/FB either moving or being replaced by WRs. Kaepernick is a running threat on his own...why tie up another player in the backfield?
Member Milestone: This is post number 3,000 for 9ersLiferInChicago.
Originally posted by Luckycharms:
Originally posted by PopeyeJonesing:
Dahl's primary problem isn't McCray, his problem is Tartt.

IIRC the 9ers went with four safeties last year (Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Dahl).

There are four locks this year: Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Tartt.

Dahl and McCray are both competing with the whole rest of the team for a ST slot.

Last year the 4 safety's were Reid, Bethea, Dahl, and McCray. Ward was listed as a CB, but early in TC last year the coaching staff mentioned he and DJ could play safety in emergencies. So this year with the addition of Tartt that will leave Dahl and McCray fighting for that last safety spot.

I would prefer we stick with McCray since he's younger and cheaper, plus I look at his ST ability as about the same as Dahl, along with his play on the field.
I don't understand why people keep counting Ward as a safety. On this roster he's a CB. Dahl and McCray will be battling for a roster spot. And frankly, I wish we finally cut bait with Dahl. Just like last season, L.J has more upside, versatility, and athleticism, and cheaper.

At some point in the season I predict that Tartt will take over the SS from Bethea at some point in the season. The kid is that good! He's gonna make an excellent nickle and dime LB.
Originally posted by genus49:
I know it leads to some good discussion but I never understood attempting to make the 53 prediction before camp/presesaon.

So much changes whether due to injuries(hopefully not) or due to performance or lack there of.

The TE/FB group is one I'm really intrigued by and want to see how they look in camp/preasason

Vance McDonald - I still think he's a good player who was mis-used by the previous coaching staff but he needs to help himself
Blake Bell - just curious to see if he's worth the hype
Busta Anderson - I love this guy and I'm not sure we can stash him on the PS

When it comes to FB i'm really intrigued by Trey Millard and hope he can make the roster. I wouldn't be shocked if he beat out Miller but the team could view him as an H-Back.

We're talking so much about these hybrid players and certainly a guy like Millard fits that role.
Because as fans it's fun to talk about and debate. It's what fans do.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
Opting for a more fluid offense, the Niners may cut Bruce Miller. With Gore gone, Miller's lead blocking is less valuable. Particularly if Millard shows an ability to make yardage running the ball, the Niners might go with Millard and four TEs.

Please no starter named Pears. Trying Boone at LG to help him prepare his footwork should he need to replace Staley is bogus. Playing Boone at RT would prepare him just as well. This is either a concern for Boone's salary request or the threat of him leaving the team next year.

It sounds asinine to even consider cutting a top 3 FB (who can catch as well) BUT, like you noted, if Millard appears to add more versatility, this is something the coaches need to consider esp. regarding a trade or cut:

$1,746,500 (cap count) $446,500 (dead money) $1,300,000 (cap savings)

It does seem silly but with the log jam at TE and having so many good RBs I can't see them keeping two FBs. I thought maybe they would move Millard around with a little TE thrown in but they drafted Bell and Anderson!

Yeah, for technical purposes, I have Millard as an H-back until Carrier comes back from the PUP...it's a way to keep both Millard and Bruce (FB) on the 53...BUT, I just saw that Hyde has already lost 15 pounds. That' a lot for a power back...in my mind, this is a clear-cut move to a ZBS where we don't need a FB as much (or if at all). Something to think about...

Baalke recently told Matt Barrows of the Sacramento Bee that Hyde has dropped 15 pounds and is looking "extremely good" with the additional quickness.

FYI, Miller's cap savings is only $481K, he has $819K of his base salary guaranteed since he was on the roster on April 1st.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
FYI, Miller's cap savings is only $481K, he has $819K of his base salary guaranteed since he was on the roster on April 1st.

Thank you AB!
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
FYI, Miller's cap savings is only $481K, he has $819K of his base salary guaranteed since he was on the roster on April 1st.

Thank you AB!

No prob bud, that's why I'm here, and it may be an extra $40K as he may have not earned his workout bonus as he was away from the team. Not sure if the $40K is factored in, I can't remember.

I don't think the 49ers could legally hold that $819K from him if cut, they made the choice to keep him on the roster, and the NFLPA would say that, they chose to keep him, so Bruce Miller is entitled to that guarantee.
AB, how does it work if we trade someone that has guaranteed money? The salary transfers but we pay the bonus and the guarantee?
Is Brooks the backup in case either Wilhoite or Bowman are injured? Late in camp, the Niners may still sign Lance Briggs as a backup.
[ Edited by Paul_Hofer on Jul 19, 2015 at 10:23 AM ]
Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
Is Brooks the backup in case either Wilhoite or Bowman are injured? Late in camp, the Niners may still sign Lance Brooks as a backup.

Tomula has stated there is no plan to move Brooks to ILB. Moody is next up. Lance Briggs?
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Jul 19, 2015 at 10:18 AM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
Is Brooks the backup in case either Wilhoite or Bowman are injured? Late in camp, the Niners may still sign Lance Brooks as a backup.

Tomula has stated there is no plan to move Brooks to ILB. Moody is next up. Lance Briggs?

Agreed, we have plenty of depth at ILB...Brooks "may" line up more inside on goal line situations but he'll still be our main SAM.

TED: Michael Wilhoite; Philip Wheeler
MIKE: Navarro Bowman; Nick Bellore
From another NT favorite: PG

Running backs (5): Carlos Hyde, Reggie Bush, Kendall Hunter, Mike Davis, Jarryd Hayne (cut: Kendall Gaskins)

Fullbacks (1): Bruce Miller (cut: Trey Millard)

Wide receivers (6*): Anquan Boldin, Torrey Smith, Bruce Ellington, Quinton Patton, Jerome Simpson, DeAndre Smelter (*injured) (cut: Dres Anderson, Issac Blakeney, DiAndre Campbell, Mario Hull, Chuck Jacobs, DeAndrew White)

Tight ends (3): Vernon Davis, Derek Carrier, Blake Bell (cut: Vance McDonald, Garrett Celek, Busta Anderson, Asante Cleveland, Xavier Grimble)

Tackles: (3): Joe Staley, Erik Pears, Trent Brown (cut: Sean Hooey, Patrick Miller, Justin Renfrow)

Guards (3): Alex Boone, Andrew Tiller, Brandon Thomas (cut: Joe Looney, Ian Silberman)

Centers (2): Daniel Kilgore, Marcus Martin (cut: Dillon Farrell, Ben Gottschalk)

Defensive ends (4): Darnell Dockett, Arik Armstead, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Tank Carradine (cut: Lawrence Okoye, Marcus Rush, Kaleb Ramsey)

Nose tackles (2): Ian Williams,Glenn Dorsey (cut: Quinton Dial, Mike Purcell, Garrison Smith)

Outside linebackers (4): Aldon Smith, Ahmad Brooks, Aaron Lynch, Eli Harold (cut: Corey Lemonier)

Inside linebackers (5): NaVorro Bowman, Michael Wilhoite, Philip Wheeler, Nick Bellore, Nick Moody (cut: Desmond Bishop, Shayne Skov)

Cornerbacks (6): Tramaine Brock, Shareece Wright, Kenneth Acker, Chris Cook, Dontae Johnson, Keith Reaser (cut: Marcus Cromartie, Mylan Hicks, Leon McFadden)

Safeties (4): Antoine Bethea, Eric Reid, Jimmie Ward, Jaquiski Tartt (cut: Craig Dahl, L.J. McCray, Jermaine Whitehead)

Specialists (3): Phil Dawson, Bradley Pinion, Kyle Nelson (cut: Corey Acosta)


A lot of this seems correct. A lot not.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 23, 2015 at 10:34 AM ]
Originally posted by ninergold:
AB, how does it work if we trade someone that has guaranteed money? The salary transfers but we pay the bonus and the guarantee?

The guaranteed money that is due transfers to the new team, but we have to take a dead money hit for any bonus money already paid out.
Originally posted by NCommand:
From another NT favorite: PG

Running backs (5): Carlos Hyde, Reggie Bush, Kendall Hunter, Mike Davis, Jarryd Hayne (cut: Kendall Gaskins)

Fullbacks (1): Bruce Miller (cut: Trey Millard)

Wide receivers (6*): Anquan Boldin, Torrey Smith, Bruce Ellington, Quinton Patton, Jerome Simpson, DeAndre Smelter (*injured) (cut: Dres Anderson, Issac Blakeney, DiAndre Campbell, Mario Hull, Chuck Jacobs, DeAndrew White)

Tight ends (3): Vernon Davis, Derek Carrier, Blake Bell (cut: Vance McDonald, Garrett Celek, Busta Anderson, Asante Cleveland, Xavier Grimble)

Tackles: (3): Joe Staley, Erik Pears, Trent Brown (cut: Sean Hooey, Patrick Miller, Justin Renfrow)

Guards (3): Alex Boone, Andrew Tiller, Brandon Thomas (cut: Joe Looney, Ian Silberman)

Centers (2): Daniel Kilgore, Marcus Martin (cut: Dillon Farrell, Ben Gottschalk)

Defensive ends (4): Darnell Dockett, Arik Armstead, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Tank Carradine (cut: Lawrence Okoye, Marcus Rush, Kaleb Ramsey)

Nose tackles (2): Ian Williams,Glenn Dorsey (cut: Quinton Dial, Mike Purcell, Garrison Smith)

Outside linebackers (4): Aldon Smith, Ahmad Brooks, Aaron Lynch, Eli Harold (cut: Corey Lemonier)

Inside linebackers (5): NaVorro Bowman, Michael Wilhoite, Philip Wheeler, Nick Bellore, Nick Moody (cut: Desmond Bishop, Shayne Skov)

Cornerbacks (6): Tramaine Brock, Shareece Wright, Kenneth Acker, Chris Cook, Dontae Johnson, Keith Reaser (cut: Marcus Cromartie, Mylan Hicks, Leon McFadden)

Safeties (4): Antoine Bethea, Eric Reid, Jimmie Ward, Jaquiski Tartt (cut: Craig Dahl, L.J. McCray, Jermaine Whitehead)

Specialists (3): Phil Dawson, Bradley Pinion, Kyle Nelson (cut: Corey Acosta)


A lot of this seems correct. A lot not.

I'm sorry I hate Gutierrez, Dial being cut is not happening, also doubt we keep 3 QBs, Thompson is our PS QB IMO.
Originally posted by NCommand:
From another NT favorite: PG

Running backs (5): Carlos Hyde,Reggie Bush, Kendall Hunter, Mike Davis, Jarryd Hayne (cut: Kendall Gaskins)

Fullbacks (1): Bruce Miller (cut: Trey Millard)

Wide receivers (6*): Anquan Boldin, Torrey Smith, Bruce Ellington, Quinton Patton, Jerome Simpson, DeAndre Smelter (*injured) (cut: Dres Anderson, Issac Blakeney, DiAndre Campbell, Mario Hull, Chuck Jacobs, DeAndrew White)

Tight ends (3): Vernon Davis, Derek Carrier, Blake Bell (cut: Vance McDonald, Garrett Celek, Busta Anderson, Asante Cleveland, Xavier Grimble)

Tackles: (3): Joe Staley, Erik Pears, Trent Brown (cut: Sean Hooey, Patrick Miller, Justin Renfrow)

Guards (3): Alex Boone, Andrew Tiller, Brandon Thomas (cut: Joe Looney, Ian Silberman)

Centers (2): Daniel Kilgore, Marcus Martin (cut: Dillon Farrell, Ben Gottschalk)

Defensive ends (4): Darnell Dockett, Arik Armstead, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Tank Carradine (cut: Lawrence Okoye, Marcus Rush, Kaleb Ramsey)

Nose tackles (2): Ian Williams,Glenn Dorsey (cut: Quinton Dial,Mike Purcell, Garrison Smith)

Outside linebackers (4): Aldon Smith, Ahmad Brooks, Aaron Lynch,Eli Harold (cut: Corey Lemonier)

Inside linebackers (5): NaVorro Bowman, Michael Wilhoite, Philip Wheeler,Nick Bellore, Nick Moody (cut: Desmond Bishop, Shayne Skov)

Cornerbacks (6): Tramaine Brock, Shareece Wright, Kenneth Acker, Chris Cook, Dontae Johnson, Keith Reaser (cut: Marcus Cromartie, Mylan Hicks, Leon McFadden)

Safeties (4): Antoine Bethea, Eric Reid, Jimmie Ward, Jaquiski Tartt (cut: Craig Dahl, L.J. McCray, Jermaine Whitehead)

Specialists (3): Phil Dawson, Bradley Pinion, Kyle Nelson (cut: Corey Acosta)


A lot of this seems correct. A lot not.

Wow...I disagree with much of this!

DL--cut Dial? I doubt this. He had really good minicamps and is working hard. Can't believe he would lose out to Jerod-Eddie and that they would only keep six DL. With the injury histories I can't see this at all!

RBs--Five? I could see Millard instead of Haynes. That would be 4 RBs and 2 FBs (HBs).

OL--Tiller over Looney and Silberman? Maybe but Looney's experience is valuable. Did he lose weight as per instructions? If not this could be true.

TE--Carrier over McDonald? Unless injuries are still hampering McD I don't see this.

S--Would hate to lose McCray but can they sneak him to the PS? Dahl's experience has been valuable but with the addition of Tartt it seems likely he's gone. I can see them keeping Ward as an extra CB/S and then finding room for McCray.

Always fun to speculate but does PG know anything from mini camps that we don't know? Or is he just speculating? Guess it's all speculation at this point!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone