Regarding numb er 10.
I'm starting to wonder if we should start rooting for the cards so they have Home field throughout. If....IF the 49ers manage to make it in, having the Cards with the best record and HF only helps. The 49ers won't have to travel far and it will be a stadium they're very familiar.
I Don't see the 49ers catching up with them, and I still believe that they'll have to win out or just drop one game. If the drop a game, and its to the Seahawks, no playoffs.
There are 491 users in the forums
Week 11 - 2014: Thoughts after rewatching the game...
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:08 AM
- Geeked
- Veteran
- Posts: 10,057
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:12 AM
- Phoenix49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 132,952
"A kid with his physical limitations just shouldn't be producing like he is"
I think people way over-exaggerate his "limitations." Is he the ideal height for an ILB, no, but the guy is only an inch shorter than Bowman and people don't really bring up his height as an issue.
He's built like a tank, was one of the strongest at his position at the Combine. He doesn't have great length or tremendous straightline speed but has very good quickness which combined with his overall awareness, instincts and intelligence gets him to exactly where he needs to be on the field.
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:20 AM
- Marvin49
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 16,506
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
"A kid with his physical limitations just shouldn't be producing like he is"
I think people way over-exaggerate his "limitations." Is he the ideal height for an ILB, no, but the guy is only an inch shorter than Bowman and people don't really bring up his height as an issue.
He's built like a tank, was one of the strongest at his position at the Combine. He doesn't have great length or tremendous straightline speed but has very good quickness which combined with his overall awareness, instincts and intelligence gets him to exactly where he needs to be on the field.
He's 5'11, run a 4.8, and has 29 inch arms.
Those are all physical limitations.
He makes up for all that tho because while runs a 4.8 40, is small areas he's actually very fast. He just has no long speed. That was on display in the preseason when he was running after an INT.
The arms haven't been an issue thus far because he seldom makes arm tackles. He hits with his entire body and runs through the ball carrier. He's also been fairly adept as shedding blockers which is surprising because the O-Linemen have the arms length advantage.
The height....I think it may work to his advantage at times. Seems like he gets low just like a RB and find the hole through the line to crush the ball carrier.
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:24 AM
- NinerBuff
- The Election Dude
- Posts: 21,443
Good breakdown as always
I think Culliver deserves a shout-out too... He and Dontae Johnson stepped up big with our decimated CB situation.
And good call talking about the mis-snaps... that's a problem!
I think Culliver deserves a shout-out too... He and Dontae Johnson stepped up big with our decimated CB situation.
And good call talking about the mis-snaps... that's a problem!
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:26 AM
- NinerBuff
- The Election Dude
- Posts: 21,443
dp
[ Edited by NinerBuff on Nov 17, 2014 at 9:28 AM ]
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:28 AM
- Marvin49
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 16,506
Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Good breakdown as always![]()
I think Culliver deserves a shout-out too... He and Dontae Johnson stepped up big with our decimated CB situation.
And good call talking about the mis-snaps... that's a problem!
Yup...should have mentioned Cully. One of his best games.
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:36 AM
- sdaddy101269
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,737
Originally posted by Marvin49:Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:"A kid with his physical limitations just shouldn't be producing like he is"
I think people way over-exaggerate his "limitations." Is he the ideal height for an ILB, no, but the guy is only an inch shorter than Bowman and people don't really bring up his height as an issue.
He's built like a tank, was one of the strongest at his position at the Combine. He doesn't have great length or tremendous straightline speed but has very good quickness which combined with his overall awareness, instincts and intelligence gets him to exactly where he needs to be on the field.
He's 5'11, run a 4.8, and has 29 inch arms.
Those are all physical limitations.
He makes up for all that tho because while runs a 4.8 40, is small areas he's actually very fast. He just has no long speed. That was on display in the preseason when he was running after an INT.
The arms haven't been an issue thus far because he seldom makes arm tackles. He hits with his entire body and runs through the ball carrier. He's also been fairly adept as shedding blockers which is surprising because the O-Linemen have the arms length advantage.
The height....I think it may work to his advantage at times. Seems like he gets low just like a RB and find the hole through the line to crush the ball carrier.
I think he's playing great too however I disagree on one thing which is he tends to get swallowed up when the olineman gets to the second level. Fortunately for us our defensive front requires double-teams at a couple spots.
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:37 AM
- NinerBuff
- The Election Dude
- Posts: 21,443
Originally posted by sdaddy101269:
I think he's playing great too however I disagree on one thing which is he tends to get swallowed up when the olineman gets to the second level. Fortunately for us our defensive front requires double-teams at a couple spots.
I've seen him shed blockers pretty well, albeit a FB not an O-lineman. Still, he's been extremely impressive making up for his lack of physical tools with incredibly instinctive play.
Nov 17, 2014 at 9:46 AM
- lamontb
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,652
On Fangio I think he's gone if they don't make the playoffs. Some team might make him a head coach and i can't blame them.
Niners never seem to take advantage of turnovers. Same issues the entire tenure. The biggest weakness and why they don't have a ring is red zone scoring. Instead Niners have fg parties.
Kap accuracy was shot yesterday and Borland is a beast.
Niners never seem to take advantage of turnovers. Same issues the entire tenure. The biggest weakness and why they don't have a ring is red zone scoring. Instead Niners have fg parties.
Kap accuracy was shot yesterday and Borland is a beast.
Nov 17, 2014 at 10:18 AM
- Loco49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,815
Originally posted by lamontb:
On Fangio I think he's gone if they don't make the playoffs. Some team might make him a head coach and i can't blame them.
Niners never seem to take advantage of turnovers. Same issues the entire tenure. The biggest weakness and why they don't have a ring is red zone scoring. Instead Niners have fg parties.
Kap accuracy was shot yesterday and Borland is a beast.
At this point I would Take Fangio as HC over Harbaugh. It has become clear that the biggest reason for the team's success under Harbaugh is the defense and not the inconsistent offense that has not progressed in 4 seasons.
Nov 17, 2014 at 10:19 AM
- SolRebe1
- Veteran
- Posts: 13,546
Great read!
Nov 17, 2014 at 10:22 AM
- thl408
- Moderator
- Posts: 33,509
Really disappointed in the offensive showing. I'll be sure to investigate that first thing once the all22 is available. 49ers were 0-2 in the red zone yesterday with one failure to score a TD when Gore/Kap fumbled. The other red zone chance started off poorly on the -7 read/option play on 1st and goal.
It seemed like the 49ers were a bit impatient yesterday with the passing game. They went for chunk plays when it felt like the short passing game was there for the taking. I thought the pass protection was good for the most part and Kap could have hit a bunch of underneath routes as the LBs started to sag into their zones. They flashed a stat during the game where the 49ers were 0-7 passing outside the numbers (on the field), and were doing very well when throwing inside the numbers. Yet they continued to go for chunk plays up the field, down the sidelines. It was as if they thought they should blow out NYG and tried to do that as quickly as possible. Forgetting that to hit big plays deep, they have to first hit little plays short.
Looking big picture, the 49ers did well to win on the road. Didn't look pretty, but to me, it didn't need to be. Now to bunker down and head into the homestretch with the only real road game left in SEA.
It seemed like the 49ers were a bit impatient yesterday with the passing game. They went for chunk plays when it felt like the short passing game was there for the taking. I thought the pass protection was good for the most part and Kap could have hit a bunch of underneath routes as the LBs started to sag into their zones. They flashed a stat during the game where the 49ers were 0-7 passing outside the numbers (on the field), and were doing very well when throwing inside the numbers. Yet they continued to go for chunk plays up the field, down the sidelines. It was as if they thought they should blow out NYG and tried to do that as quickly as possible. Forgetting that to hit big plays deep, they have to first hit little plays short.
Looking big picture, the 49ers did well to win on the road. Didn't look pretty, but to me, it didn't need to be. Now to bunker down and head into the homestretch with the only real road game left in SEA.
Nov 17, 2014 at 10:25 AM
- LottDMontanaO
- Veteran
- Posts: 7,923
Nice breakdown, Marvin. The only thing I'd add is the continuous average-to-poor play of Special Teams in all phases (except for Lee getting back on track). It's such an important part of the game as we know with momentum swings that can happen, etc. Yesterday, the ST play was again pretty bad. On their kick & punt returns, it's almost like the Niners have no chance to score a TD at all (blocking isn't there, etc.). And on kickoff coverage, they need to step it up or Dawson needs to kick it through the end zone. In the second half, the Niners score the quick TD and then Dawson's kickoff doesn't even reach the end zone...and then the Giants return it to the 40 w/ the crappy coverage. Kick the damn ball through the end zone and make them start at their own 20 and go the 80 yards - I'd put my bet on the Niners' D stopping them like they had most of the game. Also, the LS Nelson...what's going on w/ some of those snaps on FGs? Lee saved him the other game w/ the good catch and hold...yesterday, the snap was off again and Lee couldn't bail him out. The Niners really could have used that FG, too, as it would have given just that much more breathing room.
[ Edited by LottDMontanaO on Nov 17, 2014 at 10:29 AM ]
Nov 17, 2014 at 10:28 AM
- Big_Daddy
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,808
I pretty much agree with what you've already posted... lots of good things to take away from this game even if it was ugly... GO ALDON!
Our offensive self-awareness is ridiculous.
--- how many times do we run routes short of first downs or short of the endzone?
--- on ninernation.com there was a post where this guy saw the game live at giants stadium
---- says all giants fans said giants D came to play, played with pride, especially after getting whacked last week
---- says that all our route combinations are extremely simplistic and defenders knew exactly what we were running, CBs were running routes for us
Marv, since you wont say it I will
FIRE GREG ROMAN U PIECE OF s**t!!!!
Our offensive self-awareness is ridiculous.
--- how many times do we run routes short of first downs or short of the endzone?
--- on ninernation.com there was a post where this guy saw the game live at giants stadium
---- says all giants fans said giants D came to play, played with pride, especially after getting whacked last week
---- says that all our route combinations are extremely simplistic and defenders knew exactly what we were running, CBs were running routes for us
Marv, since you wont say it I will

FIRE GREG ROMAN U PIECE OF s**t!!!!