49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 895 users in the forums

Week 3 - 2014: Thoughts after rewatching the game...

Shop Find 49ers gear online
If Carradine and Dial keep being inactive, in spite of Dobbs not having done s**t, I'm just going to lose it.


I also never saw the need to add Lloyd and I still don't see the need for him, any snaps he is getting could be going to Ellington or Patton. Other teams are incorporating their young receivers such as the Cardinals have done with John Brown, also a rookie, who had 2 TD's yesterday. The 49ers are hanging on to an old fossil that has been out of football for over a year.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Sep 22, 2014 at 8:54 AM ]
I agree with you. Kap & Roman were not the problem in this game. The biggest problems in my estimation are:

1. No pass rush
2. Penalties
3. Lack of halftime adjustments by the coaches
4. Missing key stars (but most teams can say the same thing)
Originally posted by grizzlyadams:
I agree with you. Kap & Roman were not the problem in this game. The biggest problems in my estimation are:

1. No pass rush
2. Penalties
3. Lack of halftime adjustments by the coaches
4. Missing key stars (but most teams can say the same thing)

I don't know about you guys but I think the penalties were legit this game. It is well known that you don't try to hit QB's hard and hold up a little to make the tackle. I also thought almost other penalties were called correctly. Our players need to learn to play without committing the penalties.

  1. We are not an intimidating offense. We rarely take any big shots downfield which is upsetting considering the new emphasis on illegal contact. In the last two games, the opponent has beaten us by taking shots downfield.
  2. ARI baited us into forcing Kap to keep the ball on the options. Great game plan since out of all the offensive skilled players, he isn't a specialist at running with the ball if you factor in wear and tear on a defense.
  3. All those close games we have been winning in the past few years under Harbaugh has come back to swing against us now.
  4. We need to stop shooting ourselves in the foot and stop being so comfortable when we have a lead. I don't blame the refs this week as most of our penalties were correct calls.

Overall, I'm not as worried as some because I see some very good things and the main reason for the losses has been us. I just want us to go for some more homeruns on offense...especially when we have a lead.
[ Edited by Joecool on Sep 22, 2014 at 9:08 AM ]
Thanks Marvin, I think it's apparent the fine line between winning and losing can be one play. I agree with you on Tank, there's got to be some reason why he's not in there on passing situations. I think there is more to this story than we are being told. The defense needs time to come together. The loss of Brock is huge. Still, watching Drew Stanton, Christian Ponder, Gus Ferrote, and other no name quarterbacks torch us makes my blood boil.
No pass rush is killing our defensive backfield. They just simply have to cover too long. The Qb's are standing in the pocket taking their time like it's practice.

Dobbs has contributed NOTHING i haven't even heard his name called. Dial is making an impact let tank make one too. I'm tired of us having people we just stash on the damn bench and then proclaim our depth. It ain't depth if you don't use them. Considering how many injuries we have out there we need to use EVERYONE.

Bench lloyd. him and kap are not on the same page, put it patton get ellington more snaps take some deep shots even if they fail.
Defensively the run defense has been back to where it needs to be. The pass rush is the problem if we had pass rush like in the past this defense would be way better. We just don't even bother the qb in the pocket and they make plays easily.

Offensively I don't mind us not running yesterday, uptempo spread offense killed the cardinals and they never had an answer for it. But in true roman fashion we just STOPPED doing it. so yea


Until JIM HARBAUGH decides we need to go out there and score 50 points a game this is going to continue to happen to us. The let's get up some points and then ball control our way to victory has ALWAYS BEEN LAME. ALWAYS but because of the great talent on defense it's worked. It could still work but you need to raise the figure from 17 points to 40.

And finish halves. We could have put all 3 teams away at the half but didn't we punched it in for 28 against dallas that was it.

let the bears get 7 that was it
didn't score against the cards that was it

0 touchdowns in the 2nd half is a COACHING ISSUE NOT A PLAYERS ISSUE
  • Baldie
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 26,264
The spread offense works, use it.
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Thanks Marvin, I think it's apparent the fine line between winning and losing can be one play. I agree with you on Tank, there's got to be some reason why he's not in there on passing situations. I think there is more to this story than we are being told. The defense needs time to come together. The loss of Brock is huge. Still, watching Drew Stanton, Christian Ponder, Gus Ferrote, and other no name quarterbacks torch us makes my blood boil.

there isn't vic is a dude who just does what he wants and plays who he wants.
he would rather have dobbs active who doesn't do anything than to have tank active who does exactly what we need in pass rush situations
he would rather have ward get baptized by fire than to make an adjustment and get him some help until he comes along.

he will tell us that tank isn't up to speed so that's why he's not playing
when it's a damn cop out cause all you need to do is basically what they did with aldon his rookie season which is put him in on passing downs and let him rush the passer.
Tank
Problem number 1: 49ers lack personnel. Injuries, suspensions, lack of depth, overrating some of the players *cough cough* Culliver.

Problem number 2: Bad coaching on Harbaugh and Roman. Fangio gets a pass. Lose Aldon Smith, Bowman, Brock, Dorsey, too much for anyone to overcome.

Problem number 3: Offensive line is a mess. Can we end this Martin experiment please? I'm sorry he was bullied okay. But this guy isn't good. Mike Iupati something is clearly wrong him, I don't think he has recovered. Davis is badly need.

Everybody snarked "It's just preseason" No it wasn't, it was a sign of things to come. You got a bad situation. The team is riddled with injuries/suspensions. And the coaching doesn't know what to do about it.

Problem number 4: Kap is progressing, but he hasn't progressed enough to be a championship QB yet. He is getting better, but quote an old Bill Walsh statement: ""just good enough to get you beat". Right now, that's where he is.
Originally posted by Joecool:
I don't know about you guys but I think the penalties were legit this game. It is well known that you don't try to hit QB's hard and hold up a little to make the tackle. I also thought almost other penalties were called correctly. Our players need to learn to play without committing the penalties.

  1. We are not an intimidating offense. We rarely take any big shots downfield which is upsetting considering the new emphasis on illegal contact. In the last two games, the opponent has beaten us by taking shots downfield.
  2. ARI baited us into forcing Kap to keep the ball on the options. Great game plan since out of all the offensive skilled players, he isn't a specialist at running with the ball if you factor in wear and tear on a defense.
  3. All those close games we have been winning in the past few years under Harbaugh has come back to swing against us now.
  4. We need to stop shooting ourselves in the foot and stop being so comfortable when we have a lead. I don't blame the refs this week as most of our penalties were correct calls.
Overall, I'm not as worried as some because I see some very good things and the main reason for the losses has been us. I just want us to go for some more homeruns on offense...especially when we have a lead.

Well what worries me the most are the inconsistent play on both offense and defense and, in particular, the lack of discipline. It's like you see the good side of Harbaugh's philosophy (last 3 seasons) and the bad side (last 3 games). The worst part I see is Harbaugh right there with the players on the sidelines beaking off. When things get ugly in Harbaugh-land, they get really ugly? I dunno, but it better stop. Win or lose, I'd like to think of the 49ers as a professional organization that conducts itself at a higher standard than what I have seen recently.

The worrying trend for me is the lack of focus in the second half of football games. It's like Roman the thinker is utterly fantastic at scripting an offense for an opponent with a week to think, but has difficulty adjusting to things happening on the field. Two games in a row now that the offense has come out for a second half siesta.
  • 9er2k
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,395
What happened to the creative Greg Roman ?The one who was doing all those crazy shifts and formations in the run game his first season?
Loved the no-huddle, something I've been begging for, and it worked great. Also like the short passing game, although you've still got to take some shots downfield which, save for one "semi-deep" target of Lloyd down the sideline, they did not do. And I love the draft pick for the fast kid out of South Carolina, he can run decoy on a fake fly sweep better than anyone...that is why he was drafted, right?

And I hear Gore wasn't happy about his lack of carries...now maybe the bit I heard was misconstuing Gore, maybe he was just upset about the loss, but if he was mad about his role: Tough S**t. You're one of the greats #21, but it ain't about you. Yes, I think the 49ers could have kept Cards spread out with 4-WR and tried to run Gore/Hyde out of that, but no guarantee it would've worked...the Cards are d**n good vs the run.

Boldin has got some nerve blaming the officials...yes he has a legitimte gripe, but the simple fact is the 49ers have a 1st & Goal at the 5 if he just walks his a** back to he huddle.

And while we're on the refs, without question those were TERRIBLE calls on Skuta and Willis. But the 49ers did catch a break when Jimmie Rumph, er, I mean WARD flat-out speared Stanton and shockingly did not get flagged. But overall, the 49ers are killing themselves with penalties...until the NFL hopefully realizes they're just further killing the game with their "points of emphasis", guys have just got to figure it out that something as innocuous as a hand-check 10 yds downfield is probably going to get called.

Defense...yeah I know who they're missing, but if the loss of those guys is weighing on them mentally, they need to buck the f**k up because they ain't coming back anytime soon. Has Brooks done anything yet this season? If Fangio thinks he can just rush 3 or 4 next week and lay back in coverage, Foles is going to dissect them like a frog in science class. I don't see any way around the fact they will need to blitz more...and if they're going to corner blitz with Ward, he needs to learn to anticipate the snap count and cheat closer to the line, because on a 3rd & 12 he took FOREVER to just get close to the pocket, Stanton flipped it out to where Ward vacated and hit Carlson who was able to run for the 1st down.

At this point I'd be happy with 3-4 going into the bye, but with the way they're playing (in 2nd half anyways) I wouldn't be shocked at 2-5.
[ Edited by DelCed2486 on Sep 22, 2014 at 9:48 AM ]
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,400
I'm really sick to my stomack on this one fellas.. I really am...

Not only did our D get beaten by a 2nd stringer, he's a second stringer that have not played that much.. Arizona had no business keeping w/us on this game, but our whole coaching staff seem to forget that we are a running team..

The coaching staff needs to sit and decide whether we wanna look pretty and be like Detroit, Green Bay, or even New England.. and yes, even New England.. these are the same teams that often looks good offensively, be in the playoffs, and ends up being short all the time.. Why??? it's because they forgot to run the ball.. and that's exactly what had become of us... a team w/ a bunch of great skilled position, but can not put it together because we rather be pretty..
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone