I gave up trying to out think the draft experts years ago, I limit myself to monday morning quarterbacking!
There are 710 users in the forums
All Idiots
May 10, 2014 at 6:47 AM
- GolittaCamper
- Veteran
- Posts: 7,284
I gave up trying to out think the draft experts years ago, I limit myself to monday morning quarterbacking!
May 10, 2014 at 7:02 AM
- Rubberneck36
- HOF
- Posts: 141,822
It's ok to want a particular player, or think you need a particular position, but its unfair to rush to judgment. In two years if the player doesn't work out, then we definitely have the right to b***h. After all, if the fans didnt spend the money, there wouldn't be a team. In 12 hours after the browns drafted Manziel, they sold 1200 season tickets. People pay for certain players. Its a fact of life.
May 10, 2014 at 8:00 AM
- Existence
- Veteran
- Posts: 356
All good points -- 'You think you know, but you just...don't...know.'
The problem is that we can barely remember what we had for breakfast yesterday, or what the weather was last week. This results in the need for immediate assessment and reaction to events, as opposed to thoughtful retrospection.
I mean, Kiper, McShay, these other draft experts get it almost totally wrong year after year, but we never hold them accountable, let alone judge our own GM for picks a third round pick made three years ago...
The problem is that we can barely remember what we had for breakfast yesterday, or what the weather was last week. This results in the need for immediate assessment and reaction to events, as opposed to thoughtful retrospection.
I mean, Kiper, McShay, these other draft experts get it almost totally wrong year after year, but we never hold them accountable, let alone judge our own GM for picks a third round pick made three years ago...
May 10, 2014 at 8:17 AM
- Phoenix49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 132,928
I think its fine to like and wish for a particular player to be drafted by the 49ers but not good when you become butt hurt when they don't. I think we start to convince ourselves that a player is so good that there is no way the 49ers should pass on him but in the grand scheme of things, we just dont know, NFL teams have 100 page scouting reports on players, hundreds of hours of tape, psych interviews, background evals, interviews with coaches, friends and family, all this stuff that as fans we have no access to. It truly becomes the height of arrogance to assume we know better and that their draft board should be like ours.
Now if the picks dont turn out, thats another thing entirely but jumping all over Baalke for not drafting the guy you wanted is just silly.
Now if the picks dont turn out, thats another thing entirely but jumping all over Baalke for not drafting the guy you wanted is just silly.
May 10, 2014 at 8:31 AM
- theduke85
- Veteran
- Posts: 3,745
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:Yep, exactly.
I think its fine to like and wish for a particular player to be drafted by the 49ers but not good when you become butt hurt when they don't. I think we start to convince ourselves that a player is so good that there is no way the 49ers should pass on him but in the grand scheme of things, we just dont know, NFL teams have 100 page scouting reports on players, hundreds of hours of tape, psych interviews, background evals, interviews with coaches, friends and family, all this stuff that as fans we have no access to. It truly becomes the height of arrogance to assume we know better and that their draft board should be like ours.
Now if the picks dont turn out, thats another thing entirely but jumping all over Baalke for not drafting the guy you wanted is just silly.
How many times do you see, "why would they take XXXX with YYYY still on the board?" Well, because obviously XXXX is higher than YYYY on the organization's internal draft board!
Then again, there's nothing wrong with having a different opinion on a player than the team. By no means am I trying to say that we should just blindly slurp every pick Baalke makes.
May 10, 2014 at 11:59 AM
- TheRickestRick
- Veteran
- Posts: 10,450
Was anyone else expecting the standard MD quote of "Should of picked Watt" in that article?
May 10, 2014 at 5:50 PM
- Tru2RedNGold25
- Veteran
- Posts: 8,024