Originally posted by DirtyP:
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
I think the bottom line is you need more out of a top 10 pick.
A top ten pick shouldn't be expected to be one of the leagues premier players within his 3rd year. That thought process is a byproduct of the absurd way teams used to pay their draft picks. If Crabtree had gotten drafted last year at #10 he would barely be making 2 million a year. For that price I think he has performed pretty darn well as the teams perennial receptions leader.
When you draft in the top 10 you are hoping for a cornerstone player (i.e. Willis, Davis). Production is a part of it, but attitude is another. Davis is a great example. The first few years people thought he was a near bust, but you couldn't doubt his heart, work ethic and commitment to this team. Crabtree's production is ok, but I'm certainly not confident about his heart, work ethic and commitment to this team.
Edit: If Crabtree was picked where we got AJ, I would agree with you.
[ Edited by Oakland-Niner on Aug 1, 2012 at 7:30 PM ]