49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 638 users in the forums

Week 15 Player Evaluation

Shop Find 49ers gear online
It depends on your definition of role play, but as a returner you don't get much more core than Ginn. His receiving is improving as well, but take him out of the equation and we are struggling on O. He delivers field position and safe receptions.

We don't ask Akers or Lee to do more than kick and punt. Because of injuries we have had to use Ginn more, and that has exposed his weakness. But he is here as a returner and as a returner there is only one player in the League better. Core.
Originally posted by English:
It depends on your definition of role play, but as a returner you don't get much more core than Ginn. His receiving is improving as well, but take him out of the equation and we are struggling on O. He delivers field position and safe receptions.

We don't ask Akers or Lee to do more than kick and punt. Because of injuries we have had to use Ginn more, and that has exposed his weakness. But he is here as a returner and as a returner there is only one player in the League better. Core.

Fly sweep!
  • Karma
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,190
Originally posted by English:
It depends on your definition of role play, but as a returner you don't get much more core than Ginn. His receiving is improving as well, but take him out of the equation and we are struggling on O. He delivers field position and safe receptions.

We don't ask Akers or Lee to do more than kick and punt. Because of injuries we have had to use Ginn more, and that has exposed his weakness. But he is here as a returner and as a returner there is only one player in the League better. Core.

That is a good argument. I guess I don't consider him a core guy until we have enough wide receiver depth so that we don't have to rely on him making catches every game. Our field position has been a big reason for our success.
So many rising stars! Just thinking about the future of this team gives me a major boner.

[ Edited by MILFS on Dec 23, 2011 at 4:42 AM ]
Good post, I hope we keep Ginn. I like Spencer too, but I agree with you that he probably won't be back.
  • BobS
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,143
Originally posted by English:
It depends on your definition of role play, but as a returner you don't get much more core than Ginn. His receiving is improving as well, but take him out of the equation and we are struggling on O. He delivers field position and safe receptions.

We don't ask Akers or Lee to do more than kick and punt. Because of injuries we have had to use Ginn more, and that has exposed his weakness. But he is here as a returner and as a returner there is only one player in the League better. Core.
Agreed, remember what a liability our punt return game was before Ginn got here?
Originally posted by MILFS:
So many rising stars! Just thinking about the future of this team gives me a major boner.

Great analysis. Although I think you may be selling Whitner a little short. I think he plays the run extremely well and Goldson owes much of his success this year to Whitner. Last year when Lewis left and R. Smith and Mays came in Goldsons production went way down. I think Whitner is a 'core' player. But that's just me.
I think smith has pretty core to our offense with all the pre-snap reads, but there is definite improvement to be had at the position
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone