49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 843 users in the forums

The 2000 Ravens/Dilfer example.....

Shop Find 49ers gear online
TO ratio would be an interesting comparison as well.
Originally posted by NCommand:
TO ratio would be an interesting comparison as well.

Niners: +24 (projected)
Ravens: +23
Bucs: +2

Woah...that is interesting. Score one for the Ravens comparison.
[ Edited by Marvin49 on Nov 10, 2011 at 11:43 AM ]
Also, the ravens did it primarily on the road. (at tennesse and oakland.)
Wanna see something else interesting?

Alex stat line projected over 16 games.....
264 Comp, 412 Att, 64.1%, 2,934 Yards, 20 TDs, 4 INTs, 97.3 Rating

Now compare it to these 3 season:

302 Comp, 473 Att, 63.8%, 3,445 Yards, 23 TDs, 14 INTs, 89.5 Rating
271 Comp, 392 Att, 69.1%, 3,100 Yards, 15 TDs, 6 INTs, 99.0 Rating
280 Comp, 432 Att, 64.8%, 3,304 Yards, 16 TDs, 7 INTs, 93.6 Rating

Who is that second guy? That would be Hall of Fame QB Troy Aikman in his three super bowl seasons.

...but, but.....they had Emmitt......

Gore projected over 16 games:
318 Carries, 1564 Yards, 4.9, 10 TDs

Emmitt in those same 3 seasons...

373 Carries, 1,713 Yards, 4.6, 18 TDs
283 Carries, 1,486 Yards, 5.3, 9 TDs
377 Carries, 1,773 Yards, 4.7, 25 TDs

Wow. Emmitt sure scored alot of TDs.

I think you guys can see the similarities tho. You can say that was 20 years ago and the NFL has changed, but I'm convinced the NFL is cyclical and everything comes back around.
[ Edited by Marvin49 on Nov 10, 2011 at 12:41 PM ]
How about the Dallas D?
49ers: #1 in pts against, #9 in Yards against

1992: #5 in pts against, #1 in Yards against
1993: #2 in pts against, #10 in Yards against
1995: #3 in pts against, #9 in Yards against
Originally posted by Marvin49:


Alex (through 8 games):132 ATT, 206 COMP,, 64.1%,

Dilfer (11 Games):134 ATT, 226 COMP,, 59.3%


FAIL
Originally posted by endcapitalism:
Originally posted by Marvin49:


Alex (through 8 games):132 ATT, 206 COMP,, 64.1%,

Dilfer (11 Games):134 ATT, 226 COMP,, 59.3%


FAIL

Opps. got them backwards....corrected.
I refuse to compare them because they're two completely different teams playing in completely different times.
Originally posted by Whomeam:
I refuse to compare them because they're two completely different teams playing in completely different times.

Well...thats kinda my point.

I did a whole bunch of comparison in this thread to kinda show that making comparisions is pointless. That includes comparing the Niners stats to all of the passing offenses that are so popular. The Niners are just doing it differently. You don't have to throw the ball 40 times per game to win. The Niners are proving that.
Here are two more sets of numbers to compare:

488 Att, 311 Comp, 63.7%, 3,565 Yards, 19 TD, 12 INT, 88.4 Rating (222yds/game avg)
397 Att, 238 Comp, 59.9%, 2,981 Yards, 18 TD, 10 INT, 87.9 Rating (213yds/game avg)

Those are Joe Montana's numbers in 1981 and 1988.

Alex Smith (Before playing 5 of 8 games against awful division opponents) is trending better than the best QB in history during two of his four championship seasons.

Fantasy football has truly destroyed the sports IQ of fans ...
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Originally posted by Whomeam:
I refuse to compare them because they're two completely different teams playing in completely different times.

Well...thats kinda my point.

I did a whole bunch of comparison in this thread to kinda show that making comparisions is pointless. That includes comparing the Niners stats to all of the passing offenses that are so popular. The Niners are just doing it differently. You don't have to throw the ball 40 times per game to win. The Niners are proving that.

Joe Montana played 192 regular season games in his career, and threw 5,391 passes for an average of ~28 attempts per game.

The Bill Walsh offense was about controlling the clock, not trying to post gaudy numbers on the box score. Green Bay effectively plays a modified run & shoot system. They beat Pittsburgh in the Super Bowl because the Steelers defense was designed to stop the run, but didn't generate enough QB pressure to force turnovers.

The Run & Shoot is great for beating up on weak defenses, but will get absolutely chewed up by a decent pass rush.
I posted this same thing a while back. It was ignored and lost in the hundreds of pages of another thread.
[ Edited by OnTheClock on Nov 10, 2011 at 1:57 PM ]
I think the 2000 Ravens makes a better comparison because of Patrick Willis is our Ray Lewis.

Ray Lewis was the one mainly responsible for that Superbowl year. Wasn't he the Superbowl MVP!?

I can see Willis doing the same!
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Several times over the past month I have heard the 2000 Baltimore Ravens as the example of how the 49ers cold win it all this year. I've also heard people say that it's a passing league now and how that could never happen again.The example of Trent Dilfer=Alex Smith have been used over and over. After looking at the stats…I now think that's complete BS. Let's look at a few stats (not just Alex).

Alex (through 8 games):132 COMP, 206 ATT, 1,467 Yards, 64.1%, 10 TDs, 2 INTs, 97.3 Rating

Dilfer (11 Games):134 COMP, 226 ATT, 1,502 Yards, 59.3%, 12 TDs, 11 INTs, 76.6 Rating

Maybe I'm smoking something but that isn't even close. Yeah, the attempts and completiong are close, but TDs (remember, 3 fewer games), INTs, and rating are miles apart.

Lets try a little experiment....

Lets look at Alex number projected over 13 games (I'll explain in a bit).

Alex (13 games):214 COMP, 334 ATT, 2,383 Yards, 64.1%, 16 TDs, 3 INTs, 97.3 Rating

...and now compare to another set of numbers

281 COMP, 451 ATT, 3,049 Yards, 62.3%, 22 TDs, 6 INTs, 92.9 Rating

Yes, more att, comps, yards, TDs......but the statline is pretty similar on a per attempt basis. Moreover, Alex will probably see his statline improve quite a bit once he starts playing the rest of the NFC West.

Who does that second statline belong to? Brad Johnson. 2003. Buccaneers. He only played 13 games that year, so thats why I projected Alex over 13. I don't recall him winning the Super Bowl being anywhere near the miracle people make the Dilfer Super Bowl out to be.

Lets try comparing Defenses.

Niners: #1 in points allowed, #9 in total D, on pace to allow 5214 yards

Ravens 2000: #1 in points allowed, #2 in total D, allowed 3967 yards.

Bucs 2003: #4 in points allowed, #5 in total D, allowed 4466 yards.

Hrmmm.....both of those defenses allowed fewer yards, but the Niners are actually BETTER than the Bucs in points against.

How about the run game....

Niners: 2202 Yards (projected), 4.5 per carry

Ravens: 2199 Yards, 4.5 per carry

Bucs: 1648 Yards, 3.9 per carry

Hrmm.....Niners better than BOTH teams (altho MARGINALLY better than Ravens).

Conclusion:No freakin' idea. ;-) I think tho that the Bucs are a bit closer a comparison than the Ravens. Alex is playing much more like Johnson than Dilfer and the D is closer to the Bucs than the Ravens. Saying Alex is playing like Dilfer that year is complete nonsense.

The run game tho...IMO, is superior to both.


Well Cone, bravo!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone