Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 601 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
For everyone crying about stats just remember that we we're playing against a very good defense. Going into this game Detroit was ranked SIXTH in the league. These boys are not slouches by any stretch of the imagination. Alex definitely left some plays out there but against that D-line (and with Rachal playing) it could have been a hell of a lot worse.

And with the comebacks against Philly, Detroit, and for hanging in there against a surprisingly good Cincinnati defense...I hereby grant Alex the title of "clutch."


  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Alex Smith did his job in a hostile environment, he made some poor throws but overall kept this team in the game, I don't care what anyone says, good job Alex Smith.

Wow! I was expecting you to bash Alex Smith. Class act by a person known as an "Alex hater".

Honestly if you've followed all my replies of Alex Smith, I didn't bash him once this year, just wasn't as high on him as most of you are.
not a great game. he's gotta fix those high passes to Crabtree. Harbaugh did him no favors by limiting the run calls--unless that was on Smith, audibile-ing out of them.

But hey, he made some clutch throws, and that game-winning pass was absolutely perfect.
Also remember that with Alex taking more shots down-field, it is keeping safeties back from the line and opening up lanes for Gore.

By Alex making some lower percentage passes from time to time it is helping Frank to chew up the clock.
come from behind win against a previously unbeaten team, and delivering with the game on the line
Stats are not important today. The only one that counts is the W. Great throw on 4 th down, Alex. You won that game.

Go Niners !
Lovin it!!!!!
Originally posted by HearstFan:
17 of 32 for 125 yards? Hmmm. We need to get him some more weapons. Hopefully Braylon comes back after the bye and makes a big difference. Although they have missed 5 weeks of chemistry building.

He HAS GOT to get those high throws corrected. I'm sure Crabtree is frustrated by that.

Props though, he is not falling apart after the mistakes happen. He is showing poise and leadership. Go Alex.

Despite this fantastic win and the high most of us are riding, we should be concerned that Smith reverted back to form and sailed ALOT of passes today. That old consistency problem reared it's ugly head and could have cost us the game had it not been for our all-world defense and Frank's running. Unfortunately, many of those high passes were to Crabtree, which shouldn't do much to improve their relationship. Smith STILL does not throw to where his receivers have the best chance for YAC, ofetn requiring them to stretch way out or up and leaving them vulnerable to the hit. There's no question he's improved under Harbaugh and hopefully will continue to do so, but let's not anoint him just yet. Let's be honest, today was a very mediocre performance by Alex, despite a couple of clutch throws.
Jamie Dukes has been trashing Alex Smith all afternoon long.

"I'd pick 20 other QBs ahead of Alex Smith to lead my team."

"He was 17 for 34, 125 yds, 1 int, and 1 pick."

"With Alex Smith as your QB you'll never be able to top an Aaron Rodger's led Packers team." (paraphrasing here)
Originally posted by fortyninerglory:
Jamie Dukes has been trashing Alex Smith all afternoon long.

"I'd pick 20 other QBs ahead of Alex Smith to lead my team."

"He was 17 for 34, 125 yds, 1 int, and 1 pick."

"With Alex Smith as your QB you'll never be able to top an Aaron Rodger's led Packers team." (paraphrasing here)

Yawn...sure thing...btw who can stop them right now?
alex by all means did not play great. so many inaccurate throws. but i give him a pass, on the road, lions D.
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by fortyninerglory:
Jamie Dukes has been trashing Alex Smith all afternoon long.

"I'd pick 20 other QBs ahead of Alex Smith to lead my team."

"He was 17 for 34, 125 yds, 1 int, and 1 pick."

"With Alex Smith as your QB you'll never be able to top an Aaron Rodger's led Packers team." (paraphrasing here)

Yawn...sure thing...btw who can stop them right now?

Dukes is the biggest waste of airtime in the history of the NFL. His opinion means absolutely nothing. In fact, less than nothing.
Originally posted by fortyninerglory:
Jamie Dukes has been trashing Alex Smith all afternoon long.

"I'd pick 20 other QBs ahead of Alex Smith to lead my team."

"He was 17 for 34, 125 yds, 1 int, and 1 pick."

"With Alex Smith as your QB you'll never be able to top an Aaron Rodger's led Packers team." (paraphrasing here)

Would rather have a QB that can find a way to win the game at the end even while not have great numbers the rest of the game, sort of Montanaesque
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Alex Smith came up huge when it counted. all that mattered was that 4th and 5 and he gets us a TD. The Legend is growing... we love you alex!!!

'The Catch' in Detroit Clutch by Smith and D-Lay

Man, that knee look like it went down early.. I was sick to my stomach at the replay.
Seems to be a very personal dislike. Odd and very unprofessional. I like the way the other guys are starting the needle him about it. Dukes probably prefered Terry Bradshaw to Montana.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 16, 2011 at 3:40 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone