There are 698 users in the forums
Alex Smith Thread
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:26 AM
- qnnhan7
- Veteran
- Posts: 35,276
I think Cam Newton has better athletic skills then Alex Smith. Can't deny that from watching both of them. Cam Newton doesn't have the great coaching combo of Nolan and Singletary to stunt his growth either, so I'm pretty sure he's better off at this early stage then Smith was.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:36 AM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
Cam Newton is a really good rookie QB but he is rated 15th QB for a reason...won/loss record being primary. He has the same number of TDs as Smith but six times the Ints! Sounds pretty bad until you realize Smith has one. Not sure how good Newton will become but he will likely be a great QB if he has the right coach.
I would still take Smith for the here and now. He makes few mistakes and his passing is incredibly effective--high completion percentage, excellent turn over ratio and a 4-1 record.
I would still take Smith for the here and now. He makes few mistakes and his passing is incredibly effective--high completion percentage, excellent turn over ratio and a 4-1 record.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:42 AM
- Mr.Mcgibblets
- Veteran
- Posts: 15,079
Cam is doing some good things and probably will develop into a good QB. Now that said, the Panthers are allowing him to play "back-yard" ball. You know... "run around and chuck up some deep ones, just go nuts, kid." He makes some dangerous throws, and sometimes gets bailed out by a wide-open and awesome WR in Steve Smith. He also has a beastly running duo of DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart.
It's exciting football, but reminds me a bit of the JTO/Martz experiment. Chunks of yards, but turnovers and losses come with it. I also can see Cam being injured soon with all that scrambling around... this ain't college, son.
It's exciting football, but reminds me a bit of the JTO/Martz experiment. Chunks of yards, but turnovers and losses come with it. I also can see Cam being injured soon with all that scrambling around... this ain't college, son.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:50 AM
- English
- Moderator
- Posts: 41,473
Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:Originally posted by jdc49:Originally posted by Leathaface:Originally posted by backontop:Originally posted by Leathaface:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:But he didn't have 430 yards, 3 picks and lose the game like Cam Newton.....
You realize that by continuously comparing Alex Smith to Cam Newton, you only make Smith look worse right?
Does not compute? Alex Smith has looked better than Cam Newton and the 49ers have a better record thus far.
Alex Smith>>>Cam Newton
LOLOLOL
Alex Smith has looked better than Cam Newton? First of all, no. Second of all, like I said, you realize you're comparing him to the 1st overall pick right?
Cam Newton has every excuse in the world to suck right now, but he doesn't. Why? Because he has IT. That thing Alex Smith will never have.
Alex Smith is afforded every excuse in the book in year 7 (LOL) of his career and yet Cam can't even get credit for throwing for 900 yards in his first 2 games on a s**t squad.
And SanDiego, 430 yards and a loss IS BETTER than 125 and a win for the Panthers/Newton. They're building for the future. They know they have a star in the making with Cam Newton. They'd gladly have him play lights out and lose right now than him look like s**t and win a few meaningless games.
thats absurd, leatherface, stats are overrated, its a team effort, and in the words of the late Al Davis, just win baby.
Yeah, I don't quite understand the bolded.
Its pretty clear. He's saying that wins arent important for the Panthers right now. They are in rebuild mode and arent going anywhere special this season. So a W does nothing for them but big figures from their rookie qb shows they might have their QBOTF and a few other facets of their O in place.
And for the guy who quoted Al Davis, Al wasnt always right. Stats may be overrated but settling your rookie QB into the NFL and blooding him certainly isnt. So whilst I would generally go for a win, in this context I would agree with Leather.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:52 AM
- 9erfanAUS
- Veteran
- Posts: 16,281
Originally posted by English:
Its pretty clear. He's saying that wins arent important for the Panthers right now. They are in rebuild mode and arent going anywhere special this season. So a W does nothing for them but big figures from their rookie qb shows they might have their QBOTF and a few other facets of their O in place.
And for the guy who quoted Al Davis, Al wasnt always right. Stats may be overrated but settling your rookie QB into the NFL and blooding him certainly isnt. So whilst I would generally go for a win, in this context I would agree with Leather.
And I'm sure every member of the Panther's organization including Newton thinks differently.
Winning and losing games plays a big part in knowing whether you have your QBOTF.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:53 AM
- blizzuntz
- Veteran
- Posts: 56,594
I will be cheering for Alex Smith today.
Oct 16, 2011 at 7:54 AM
- smithgdwg
- Veteran
- Posts: 20,473
Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:
Originally posted by jdc49:
Originally posted by Leathaface:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by Leathaface:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
But he didn't have 430 yards, 3 picks and lose the game like Cam Newton.....
You realize that by continuously comparing Alex Smith to Cam Newton, you only make Smith look worse right?
Does not compute? Alex Smith has looked better than Cam Newton and the 49ers have a better record thus far.
Alex Smith>>>Cam Newton
LOLOLOL
Alex Smith has looked better than Cam Newton? First of all, no. Second of all, like I said, you realize you're comparing him to the 1st overall pick right?
Cam Newton has every excuse in the world to suck right now, but he doesn't. Why? Because he has IT. That thing Alex Smith will never have.
Alex Smith is afforded every excuse in the book in year 7 (LOL) of his career and yet Cam can't even get credit for throwing for 900 yards in his first 2 games on a s**t squad.
And SanDiego, 430 yards and a loss IS BETTER than 125 and a win for the Panthers/Newton. They're building for the future. They know they have a star in the making with Cam Newton. They'd gladly have him play lights out and lose right now than him look like s**t and win a few meaningless games.
thats absurd, leatherface, stats are overrated, its a team effort, and in the words of the late Al Davis, just win baby.
Yeah, I don't quite understand the bolded.
Teaching him how to win is a lot more important than teaching him how to look good on fantasy football.
Oct 16, 2011 at 8:05 AM
- JThomas
- Veteran
- Posts: 9,553
I think today is the day it all comes crashing down. Hope I'm wrong.
Still very timid to put anything on Alex. He's going to need to show up, and use his athleticism to get out of the pocket. we'll see.
Still very timid to put anything on Alex. He's going to need to show up, and use his athleticism to get out of the pocket. we'll see.
Oct 16, 2011 at 8:10 AM
- English
- Moderator
- Posts: 41,473
Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:Originally posted by English:Its pretty clear. He's saying that wins arent important for the Panthers right now. They are in rebuild mode and arent going anywhere special this season. So a W does nothing for them but big figures from their rookie qb shows they might have their QBOTF and a few other facets of their O in place.
And for the guy who quoted Al Davis, Al wasnt always right. Stats may be overrated but settling your rookie QB into the NFL and blooding him certainly isnt. So whilst I would generally go for a win, in this context I would agree with Leather.
And I'm sure every member of the Panther's organization including Newton thinks differently.
Winning and losing games plays a big part in knowing whether you have your QBOTF.
We are going to have to agree to disagree. If a team assesses a young qb by the win/loss column, they are making decisions based on the wrong data.
Oct 16, 2011 at 8:10 AM
- AXEGRINDER
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,685
Originally posted by Jt8786:I think today is the day it all comes crashing down. Hope I'm wrong.
Still very timid to put anything on Alex. He's going to need to show up, and use his athleticism to get out of the pocket. we'll see.
man up son
Oct 16, 2011 at 8:11 AM
- unst4bl3
- Member
- Posts: 7,568
Lets go alex, here is the day for people to either get on, or off your bandwagon.
1. I hope he shows up.
2. I hope he doesn't get injured against the lions.
1. I hope he shows up.
2. I hope he doesn't get injured against the lions.
Oct 16, 2011 at 8:13 AM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by Jt8786:
I think today is the day it all comes crashing down. Hope I'm wrong.
Still very timid to put anything on Alex. He's going to need to show up, and use his athleticism to get out of the pocket. we'll see.
man up son
Indeed! Harbaugh has out coached his adversaries this year and I hope it continues. He and his coaches are really the difference today. And stopping Stafford and Johnson from playing keepaway with/from our DBs! I expect some interference penalties today.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 16, 2011 at 8:15 AM ]
Oct 16, 2011 at 9:05 AM
- taney71
- Veteran
- Posts: 18,642
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
Lets go alex, here is the day for people to either get on, or off your bandwagon.
1. I hope he shows up.
2. I hope he doesn't get injured against the lions.
If the second happens I fear for how our season turns out.
Oct 16, 2011 at 9:11 AM
- Sunshine
- Veteran
- Posts: 3,508
An emoticon history of Jim Harbaugh versus other teams:












Oct 16, 2011 at 10:46 AM
- 8to80
- Member
- Posts: 265
I never wanted to compare their stats, just responding to:Originally posted by dtg_9er:On topic--comparing QBs, whether Smith to Montana or Smith to Dilfer has to be done in context, it is a team sport and stats are somewhat meaningless except when taken as a total at the end of a career. Sports are a great pasttime because we can all watch the same game and take different things from it. I liked Brad Johnson a lot but he was fairly fragile if memory serves me correctly. 1999 was a decent year, 10-6. Won a game in the playoffs, lost to TB for the Div.
As for Trent Dilfer I never cared for him. Very few complete seasons and his best QBRing came in a partial year...started four games.
Now Montana! He was the best QB I have ever watched. Statistically, it can be argued that his QBR wasn't as high as some, but that demonstrates my concern with stats...they do not take in the actual team/game context.
Lastly, you occasionally post some good points but they are undermined by your confrontational approach to other posters. Difficult to take you seriously at times. Hope you will consider this and keep posting but on a higher level. Chiding you has only made things worse, so my mistake.
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:Yeah man, never mind that Alex Smith's career numbers are better than Trent Dilfer's in every way imaginable.
And yes, if I see a dumb post or someone says something I think makes no sense, I'll respond bluntly. But if people run out of things to say and want to take it personally, they. can. I'm just arguing a point

thats absurd, leatherface, stats are overrated, its a team effort, and in the words of the late Al Davis, just win baby.
