49ers on NFLN Path to the Draft

Originally posted by Norcal9erfan:

Originally posted by zozell:
I want McNabb because Smith nor Carr can do this...

That's actually in large part why lots of people don't like him IMO. He's a goofball and cocky at times and sometimes comes across as arrogant.

I thought it was cuz he's black.

Originally posted by SybErkRimInAL:

Originally posted by Norcal9erfan:

Originally posted by zozell:
I want McNabb because Smith nor Carr can do this...

That's actually in large part why lots of people don't like him IMO. He's a goofball and cocky at times and sometimes comes across as arrogant.

I thought it was cuz he's black.

I wont go there...

Originally posted by joeymac49s:
One more reason we don't need his headache... btw how come they aren't trading Kolb or Vick?? I only hear trade rumors about McNabb.... funny isn't it?? Like i said, you want to see the real McNabb go back past the years and see the numbers he puts up against bad teams against teams that are half decent... he doesn't rise to the occassion... that's not what you want in a QB. Montana in the Super Bowl had 11 tds and 0 ints. that's called rising to the occassion.... not throwing up on the 50 yard line during what should have been the game winning drive....

have you seen alex smith?

You want to talk about his numbers against "good teams"

Originally posted by joeymac49s:
Trust me, I was born in Philly and now live 15 min from Philly... in the heart of eagle country... read my lips WE DONT WANT MCNABB............. if hes such a great qb still why are the eagles willing to take a 2nd rd pick for him?? Think we can get Brady, Manning, Brees hell Rivers, Romo or Big Ben (ok bad example) for a 2nd Rd. pick?? Hell no!! McNabb's numbers are pretty yes but trust me, dig deeper... he has GREAT games vs. washington and cleveland and buffalo and teams like that but look at when he plays teams that are just as good as his perfect example in the playoffs.... McNabb is a true choke artist... ask any eagle fan and they'll tell you b/c they see it EVER season... as soon as something starts to go wrong mcnabb somehow gets hurt. PLEASE NINERS DON'T EVEN TRADE A 5TH RD PICK FOR HIM.............

True choke artist??? we have our own... his name is Alex Smith. I dont disagree with u on McNabb, but at least he knows what it feels to play in the post season.
Not like Alex who is still """developing"""

Originally posted by elguapo:

Originally posted by hubbyt:

Originally posted by GORO:

Originally posted by 49erJim:

Originally posted by jones49:

Originally posted by 49erRider:

Originally posted by yummy12:
Everyone outside 49ers front office believe Smith not the long term answer. Anyone surprised by that is kidding themselves...

Which is why we are an 8-8 team, and 5 of those wins came within a horrible division. Everyone sees it except the front office and a bunch of people here on the Zone (big surprise).

I want him to be the man but I agree with you.

well if it makes you feel any better, one of my buds is from philly and a die hard fan and hes begging the 49ers to take him out of philly.

How many come from behind wins does Mcnabb have ? How many superbowls?
Mcnabb had two big games against the cowboys he won neither of them. Gave up in the Superbowl. He would have played poorly against our Niner defense but desean Jackson just kept getting wide open so it was easy for him to pad his stats.

Alex Smith stats 18 Td to Mcnabb 22. Alex 12 int to 10 for McNabb. If Alex played all season he would have had more Td then Mc Nabb.

Mcnabb has talent all over at the Wr and rb position. The niners are just starting to develop those weopons.

In Summary Mcnabb is overated. Even if the cardinals were to get him we would still sweep them next year. Kurt Warner was far better then he will ever be.

I hope absolutely nobody on here is buying what you are selling. Alex Smith doesnt belong in the same conversation as Donovan McNabb. I want Alex to BALL OUT this year but we cannot sit here in denial. If Alex Smith were half as good as McNabb has been nobody would be talking about the 49ers trading for him. If the 49ers decide to go with Alex Smith thats great but dont down McNabb to make yourself feel good about Alex. They are not on the same level. Not even close.

I also hope NOBODY is buying what you are selling....because everyone knows that McNabb would do alot worse as a niner behind NO OL than the Eagles with a very good OL WR whole offense as a matter of fact. Last year McNabb did above average with a very good team and Smith did above average......even VERY GOOD given our offensive situation behind our OL. I seem to remember whenever McNabb has a bad OL game, he does horrible (see many DAL and NYG games) and with our OL i do not think he would do much better than Alex....if not worse.

Nobody is saying Smith is a BETTER QB than McNabb, however, you need to accept reality and see through the lines use your logic and say would McNabb be a better qb if he were on the niners (NO!) and would Alex be a better qb if he were on the eagles (YES!).

So in review, McNabb is a better qb BUT he is on the eagles, a better team with better weapons and an OL with a great OC. Smith is on a far worse offense with a horrible OL and an above average OC. That is a fact.

To even put McNabb in the conversation against Alex Smith is kind of ignorant. Numbers dont lie. For sooooooo many years McNabb didnt have receivers at all and put up good #s. It wasnt until TO went to Philly that McNabb had a true #1 receiver and that was only for one year. He now has Desean Jackson yes but lets not make it seem as though he has had a plethora of receivers and tight ends to throw the ball too many times he makes them appear better than they are. He had several years with Freddie Mitchell and company stinkin it up. Yes Philly overall has had much more talent than San Fran and much more stability on the coaching staff but dont knock McNabb because of that. He has always been a good QB. We are still trying to determine if Alex CAN be good. I dont doubt McNabb could struggle initially if he came to San Fran but to make it seem as though we are better off without McNabb given the chance of trading for him I think is homerism. I'm not downing Alex Smith but he is not even close to better than McNabb I dont see how anyone could argue that.

Originally posted by tohara3:
Didn't really like the segment on the 49ers. Normally I do agree & like most of there info. Guess we will just have to wait & see what happens.

I agree! Why the hell talk to Eric Davis when you can get Matt M from Press Democrat who's much more knowledgeable...
I'd like us to take Spiller or Dez at 13,Iupati at 17 and trade 2nd rounder for Jared Gaither of Ravens to start at tackle(supposedly he's available for a 2nd). We would then have a good O-line,another threat at WR and also a great punt returner..All remaining picks go to Defense!
Unless a quality back was available in later rounds..

[ Edited by Mister49 on Mar 31, 2010 at 19:23:47 ]

Originally posted by BigDaddy:
Shouldn't there be a punishment for posting this to early? Like he has to stand in the corner or wear a Raiders jersey till tomorrow.

Kinda harsh, ya would have to make it be a rice raiders jersey! Wait a minute, that's even worse! Never shoulda let him go!