Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 592 users in the forums

Training Camp Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Look like i said im not goin to say hill did bad, obviously he didnt. and yeah he mightve went 5/5. but if smith throws that interception but goes 5/5 in 11 vs 11 you guys are all over him for it. but if hill does it then it doesnt count. and an int is an int no matter how you slice it. so yea hill mightve done well and i give him props for that. but for me, an int can easily turn a good practice into an average one. i dont see why you have a problem with that.

I agree with you. It's just that the statement was made that both struggled when Hill only had one mistake compared to Smith who was overthrowing and underthrowing receivers. I would use the shoulder as an excuse if he didn't use to have accuracy issues when he was healthy, but this is far past becoming a problem; his accuracy. I think it's getting time to conclude that he's just not an accurate QB.
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Look like i said im not goin to say hill did bad, obviously he didnt. and yeah he mightve went 5/5. but if smith throws that interception but goes 5/5 in 11 vs 11 you guys are all over him for it. but if hill does it then it doesnt count. and an int is an int no matter how you slice it. so yea hill mightve done well and i give him props for that. but for me, an int can easily turn a good practice into an average one. i dont see why you have a problem with that.

Yeah man, you are correct. Reading a few of their posts is funny at times.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Look like i said im not goin to say hill did bad, obviously he didnt. and yeah he mightve went 5/5. but if smith throws that interception but goes 5/5 in 11 vs 11 you guys are all over him for it. but if hill does it then it doesnt count. and an int is an int no matter how you slice it. so yea hill mightve done well and i give him props for that. but for me, an int can easily turn a good practice into an average one. i dont see why you have a problem with that.

I agree with you. It's just that the statement was made that both struggled when Hill only had one mistake compared to Smith who was overthrowing and underthrowing receivers. I would use the shoulder as an excuse if he didn't use to have accuracy issues when he was healthy, but this is far past becoming a problem; his accuracy. I think it's getting time to conclude that he's just not an accurate QB.


the thing is they were both under throwing receivers during practice. Hill just seemed to get it together for 11 on 11 where as Smith continued to struggle aparently
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Look like i said im not goin to say hill did bad, obviously he didnt. and yeah he mightve went 5/5. but if smith throws that interception but goes 5/5 in 11 vs 11 you guys are all over him for it. but if hill does it then it doesnt count. and an int is an int no matter how you slice it. so yea hill mightve done well and i give him props for that. but for me, an int can easily turn a good practice into an average one. i dont see why you have a problem with that.
I agree with you. It's just that the statement was made that both struggled when Hill only had one mistake compared to Smith who was overthrowing and underthrowing receivers. I would use the shoulder as an excuse if he didn't use to have accuracy issues when he was healthy, but this is far past becoming a problem; his accuracy. I think it's getting time to conclude that he's just not an accurate QB.


eh he supposedly did get the team down the field though it wasnt pretty in the one twitter quote from lambda. i thought his accuracy was about what youd expect in the broncos game. i dunno, i think his shoulder is finally okay, if you want to chalk it up to something other than a bad day id say rust but i dunno. i cant wait until saturday lol.
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Look like i said im not goin to say hill did bad, obviously he didnt. and yeah he mightve went 5/5. but if smith throws that interception but goes 5/5 in 11 vs 11 you guys are all over him for it. but if hill does it then it doesnt count. and an int is an int no matter how you slice it. so yea hill mightve done well and i give him props for that. but for me, an int can easily turn a good practice into an average one. i dont see why you have a problem with that.
I agree with you. It's just that the statement was made that both struggled when Hill only had one mistake compared to Smith who was overthrowing and underthrowing receivers. I would use the shoulder as an excuse if he didn't use to have accuracy issues when he was healthy, but this is far past becoming a problem; his accuracy. I think it's getting time to conclude that he's just not an accurate QB.


eh he supposedly did get the team down the field though it wasnt pretty in the one twitter quote from lambda. i thought his accuracy was about what youd expect in the broncos game. i dunno, i think his shoulder is finally okay, if you want to chalk it up to something other than a bad day id say rust but i dunno. i cant wait until saturday lol.

Ohh that is another excuse. Hill is the only one that can have just a "bad day" Smith just sucks and has excuses.
Remember one thing guys, WE are all 49ers fans
These last couple of pages of posts were all regarding to this statement, which is the only reason why Hill's play was compared to Smith in more detail.

Quote:
wow Smith and Hill seemed to struggle today. Maybe it was windy
Originally posted by Joecool:
These last couple of pages of posts were all regarding to this statement, which is the only reason why Hill's play was compared to Smith in more detail.

Quote:
wow Smith and Hill seemed to struggle today. Maybe it was windy

Yes and that statement was based on this

1:08:49 pm 49ers QBs Shaun Hill and Alex Smith are off to a rough start in a 7-on-7 drill. Smith's deep wobbler should have been picked off by Raiders CB Stanford Routt but was dropped. Raiders FS Hiram Eugene then intercepted Hill's underthrown pass intended for WR Josh Morgan.
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!

and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!

and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.

But only 30% of the time.
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!
and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.


yup. valuable practices for the whole team. especially the qbs, wrs, and dl imo.
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!
and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.


yup. valuable practices for the whole team. especially the qbs, wrs, and dl imo.

I agree 100%.
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!
and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.


yup. valuable practices for the whole team. especially the qbs, wrs, and dl imo.

I agree 100%.

Only 100%?
Originally posted by Carney16:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by tohara3:
Sounds like are guys are getting some good practice in against a different team. Hopefully it continues & we also stay healthy!
and most importantly IMPROVE!! The Raiders have one hell of a secondary. If the passing game can succeed it should mean good things. Also the defense needs to be able to stop their run game.


yup. valuable practices for the whole team. especially the qbs, wrs, and dl imo.

I agree 100%.

Only 100%?

stop being so greedy. Who are you? Michael Crabtree?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone