Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:Originally posted by niner4life21:
You have to be good in the past to get the comeback player of the year award.....
thats what makes it a "comeback"....
smith was s**t before his injuries, and if he does hopefully have a breakout season, he won't get that award...
True but it's probably also given to the guy who had to overcome obstacles in the face of being called a bust etc.
-9fA
Exactly, John Kitna, Drew Brees, and Tommy Maddox were all crap before winning the award. Keep in mind Brees is stellar now but there was a reason SD drafted Rivers in the 1st round back then. It typically goes to the "feel good story" of the year. Brooks could get it from straightening out his life and realizing his athletic potential, and Smith could get it from surviving the adversity and clearing the bust label.
