Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Kilgore
Law
Lance
Marshall
Durant
L Robinson
Barrett
Taaffe
How do we not draft Jalon Kilgore here...
Taaffe or Kilgore please.
There are 672 users in the forums
Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Kilgore
Law
Lance
Marshall
Durant
L Robinson
Barrett
Taaffe
How do we not draft Jalon Kilgore here...
Originally posted by frankieuc68:
We got 3 picks coming up. Make it worth it! OL,S,LB
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Raiders and Kubiak having a god draft.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Kilgore
Law
Lance
Marshall
Durant
L Robinson
Barrett
Taaffe
How do we not draft Jalon Kilgore here...
Taaffe or Kilgore please.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Why do we just assume every draft pick is based off Kyle's wants and he's not listening to anyone else? Why would any FO personnel or scout work here if that was the case? Why would Jed pay them millions of dollars to do their job if they had no input or say into how the team is being built.
I hear everything everyone is saying, we're all frustrated. I think folks are forcing their frustrations on one person when in reality it's a collection of poor decisions from A LOT of people.
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by Afrikan:Kyle is Tony Soprano.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Slept on it and I f**king hate this draft. I mean I think Height is a solid pick but it doesn't make up for the f**king stupidity with the other two picks.
Everyone is roasting them and rightfully so. I'm so done with Lynch and this whole scouting department. Why do they have to make this s**t so hard
I know it hurts to admit it to yourself NY, but Kyle IS the Final Boss. He makes/allows the decisions.
Originally posted by frankieuc68:
Our DL is set. Maybe a LB and S. OL please!
Originally posted by NYniner85:Because its blatantly obvious Kyle calls the shots.
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:Well said,theres a big difference between input and control.
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by NYniner85:They absolutely need a real GM as opposed to a front man the question is will Kyle be agreeable to that.
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
This is a great take. Not good, but GREAT! Completely explains why this team has waisted drafts and lacks depth. This whole "wouldn't start over the current starter anyway" approach has been ruinous to the roster.
Indeed there is something fundamentally wrong with this team's approach to the draft. It's called Shanny having too much of a say on personnel decisions and the team not having a real talent evaluating roster building GM who knows how to work the draft.
The Yorks (not Jed) are gonna have to put their foot down, fire Lynch, bring in a true talent evaluating roster building GM who knows how to work the draft, and demand that Shanny focuses on coaching the final 53 and gameday roster. It should be clear to all by now that Shanny is the best at scheming but horrible at personnel decisions.
Jed is the boss not his parents. He's the owner. It's his responsibility to say something…results will determine that. Dispite the poor drafting they're still winning so the train keeps moving.
Kyle is a great head coach…any coach worth anything will have a say on how the roster is built. We need a better GM who can control a little bit more of all of this.
And because THAT is even a question is the problem!
@NYniner85. I never said that Kyle shouldn't have a say on how the roster is built. The problem is that he has too much of a say about how the roster is built. You mention Lynch. We all know that Lynch don't have the final say. Kyle does. He basically hired Lynch, so Lynch is doing what Kyle wants. You're right, Jed is the boss. My point in saying . . . :
The Yorks (not Jed) are gonna have to put their foot down . . .
. . . . is because that message to Kyle won't come from Jed. Frankly, I don't get the impression that he don't have the balls to confront Kyle on this. That'll have to come from mommy and daddy York. Now will that happen? Likely not. But that don't take away from the fact that Shanny's say and power over the roster and the draft needs to be curtailed - not eliminated, but curtailed. Because anyone that's been paying attention over the last several drafts can plainly see that something is fundamentally wrong with the 49ers draft and evaluation process, and it ain't gonna be fixed simply by firing Lynch. Shanny's role HAS to be changed.
Why do we just assume every draft pick is based off Kyle's wants and he's not listening to anyone else? Why would any FO personnel or scout work here if that was the case? Why would Jed pay them millions of dollars to do their job if they had no input or say into how the team is being built.
I hear everything everyone is saying, we're all frustrated. I think folks are forcing their frustrations on one person when in reality it's a collection of poor decisions from A LOT of people.
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Why do we just assume every draft pick is based off Kyle's wants and he's not listening to anyone else? Why would any FO personnel or scout work here if that was the case? Why would Jed pay them millions of dollars to do their job if they had no input or say into how the team is being built.
I hear everything everyone is saying, we're all frustrated. I think folks are forcing their frustrations on one person when in reality it's a collection of poor decisions from A LOT of people.
this^