I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
There are 890 users in the forums
11th pick 2018draft
11th pick 2018draft
Jan 2, 2018 at 11:21 AM
- NinerLegionnaire
- Veteran
- Posts: 160
Jan 2, 2018 at 11:24 AM
- susweel
- Hall of Nepal
- Posts: 122,284
Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:
I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
no way Mayfield and Jackson go in the top 10.
Jan 2, 2018 at 11:25 AM
- mayo49
- Veteran
- Posts: 65,216
Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:
I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
Nelson has to be the pick - got to protect the franchise. We can get a DB in the 2nd.
Jan 2, 2018 at 11:32 AM
- 49erWill
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 86,410
Originally posted by ajsjohnson:So when exactly does this coin flip happen?
Combine.
Jan 2, 2018 at 12:21 PM
- genus49
- Moderator
- Posts: 28,609
Originally posted by susweel:
no way Mayfield and Jackson go in the top 10.
I wouldn't say no way with QBs. At the end of the day teams know QBs sell tickets and win football games. If there is a QB run desperate teams may pull the trigger.
If Mayfield was 2 inches taller he'd be a sure top 5 pick imo.
Jan 2, 2018 at 12:24 PM
- NinerLegionnaire
- Veteran
- Posts: 160
Originally posted by susweel:Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
no way Mayfield and Jackson go in the top 10.
...ok? It would be nice if you added some context as to why.
I see 4 QB needy teams in the top 10. Unless 2 of those teams sign/trade for QB's, logic dictates 4 will go top 10. Because there are multiple teams besides those top 4 that need QB's. Browns and Giants are assumed by many to be almost guaranteed to take QB's. Denver may be attractive to top QB's but the Jets aren't and the Jags are probably even more attractive then Denver. Just because players aren't worthy of a top 10 pick doesn't mean they won't be picked there especially the QB position. If either of those teams believe 1 of Rudolph, Mayfield, or Jackson, will be efficient productive and win games they will be picked with that teams 1st pick. If any team outside of the top 10 wants 1 of those guys they will need to trade in front of or with the Broncos/Jets or at least ahead of other teams in front them.
Jan 2, 2018 at 12:35 PM
- NinerLegionnaire
- Veteran
- Posts: 160
Originally posted by mayo49:Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
Nelson has to be the pick - got to protect the franchise. We can get a DB in the 2nd.
I would pick him as well more than likely I think the main focus should be developing through (FA/Draft) a top 5 o-line, but it would depend on KS and the coaching staffs/scouts belief in him executing they're system at a high level. I think the team would most likely take Fitzpatrick or Key though because of guys like Billy Price, Braden Smith, and Frank Ragnow possibly being available in the 2nd/3rd. Both Lynch and Saleh have been quoted talking of the importance of an edge player and Lynch more than anybody will know how important Fitzpatrick can be to the defense as well. I would be ecstatic with any of the 3 though. Key has question marks but I trust this new regime to identify and coach up players.
Jan 2, 2018 at 12:39 PM
- susweel
- Hall of Nepal
- Posts: 122,284
Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:
I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
no way Mayfield and Jackson go in the top 10.
...ok? It would be nice if you added some context as to why.
I see 4 QB needy teams in the top 10. Unless 2 of those teams sign/trade for QB's, logic dictates 4 will go top 10. Because there are multiple teams besides those top 4 that need QB's. Browns and Giants are assumed by many to be almost guaranteed to take QB's. Denver may be attractive to top QB's but the Jets aren't and the Jags are probably even more attractive then Denver. Just because players aren't worthy of a top 10 pick doesn't mean they won't be picked there especially the QB position. If either of those teams believe 1 of Rudolph, Mayfield, or Jackson, will be efficient productive and win games they will be picked with that teams 1st pick. If any team outside of the top 10 wants 1 of those guys they will need to trade in front of or with the Broncos/Jets or at least ahead of other teams in front them.
Yes teams may need QBs but that doesn't mean they will reach that much. Jackson is being talked about as a WR by some teams, Mayfield once he tests at the combine will probably be under 6ft and arm strength will not wow anyone. jmo but we'll see.
Jan 2, 2018 at 1:15 PM
- NinerLegionnaire
- Veteran
- Posts: 160
Originally posted by susweel:Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:Originally posted by susweel:Originally posted by NinerLegionnaire:I think the draft goes:
1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Connor Williams
4. Saquan Barkley
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Lamar Jackson
7. Bradley Chubb
8. Courtland Sutton
9. Roquan Smith (Raiders)
10. Minkah Fitzpatrick
Fitzpatrick, Quenton Nelson, Calvin Ridley, and Arden Key could all still be available at our pick. If you think Tampa takes Fitz then Chubb would be available but I would take Key or Nelson over him. If Indy takes Saquan then Cleveland probably takes Minkah and Tampa then takes Chubb/Key, leaving Nelson, Ridley,& Key/Chubb as possibilities. I really think Elway goes for Darnold if he comes out or he could take either Rudolph or Jackson as well as Mayfield at 5, but trades are a crapshoot especially before FA and Mayfield's moxie might remind him of himself. I also think the Jets take Jackson, his dual threat ability can get them a few wins on it's own in the 1st year if he can learn the offense with a guy like McCown mentoring/ playing until he's ready. This dual threat ability could theoretically add another dimension for possible wins on a bland offensive roster giving him an extra year or 2 to stay and supplememt the roster. Although I think it's more than likely he needs to reach the playoffs or get to 10-6 and just miss out to stay around next year.
no way Mayfield and Jackson go in the top 10.
...ok? It would be nice if you added some context as to why.
I see 4 QB needy teams in the top 10. Unless 2 of those teams sign/trade for QB's, logic dictates 4 will go top 10. Because there are multiple teams besides those top 4 that need QB's. Browns and Giants are assumed by many to be almost guaranteed to take QB's. Denver may be attractive to top QB's but the Jets aren't and the Jags are probably even more attractive then Denver. Just because players aren't worthy of a top 10 pick doesn't mean they won't be picked there especially the QB position. If either of those teams believe 1 of Rudolph, Mayfield, or Jackson, will be efficient productive and win games they will be picked with that teams 1st pick. If any team outside of the top 10 wants 1 of those guys they will need to trade in front of or with the Broncos/Jets or at least ahead of other teams in front them.
Yes teams may need QBs but that doesn't mean they will reach that much. Jackson is being talked about as a WR by some teams, Mayfield once he tests at the combine will probably be under 6ft and arm strength will not wow anyone. jmo but we'll see.
All good points, fair enough.
There's still Rudolph and I completely forgot about Josh Allen who some teams apparently love his potential. I just think especially recently, teams have seen the impact a young qb can have on a team. Winston, Mariota, Goff, Wentz, Watson, Mahomes, etc and the perceived failures of the teams that have missed out by trading or not trading for their guy will make the teams who identify these guys do whatever it takes to get them resulting in 4 in the top 10. I think 1 or 2 at the most of the top 6 goes around top of the 2nd. There doesn't seem to be as many of the typical guys who fill out the teens and later. WR, DB, LB, Interior Line, and RB. Instead those guys are all bunched closely with guys that will go 2/3. Meaning there should be 2nd/3rd round WR, LB, DB, IL, and RB who get on the field and produce. Which to me means teams will be willing to sacrifice picks to get their guy knowing they can still get a player that will produce for them later. To me not counting QB's you have 1 RB, 1 DB, 1 LB, and 1 OG who grade out as true blue chip prospects. So that's 4 top 10 worthy guys in my opinion, to some Bradley Chubb and Arden Key may also slot here, but to me Chubb isn't an elite rusher just solid and Key is to weak in run defense. Leaving 6 spots for top tier impact players. Any QB that a team feels will be able to execute the offense efficiently and can grow, to me, is automatically slotted in these spots due to market and scarcity of the position. So with 4 to at most 6 blue chip prospects there are 4 to 6 spots open for QB's that won't be considered a reach if they can execute.