49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 1,048 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by tankle104:
Would you expect him to say "those interceptions are so and so fault"? what kind of leader would do that? Im not saying he is innocent but you can find easily 5 of that werent really on him. that is a huge percentage of them already.

My only problem with your original statement was saying most were not his fault. It's just not true. If you're gonna say that then you gotta mention all the times he got lucky balls weren't picked.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by jcs:
http://www.ninersnation.com/2017/2/14/14615680/deshaun-watson-film-breakdown-17-interceptions-2016



Lemme get a summary. I've seen the video of all his interceptions*, not gonna watch a 30 min video on it.

That 1/2 of the picks are Watson's fault directly, the other half had variables from tipped passes, receivers falling down or running the wrong route​ to exceptional plays by the defender like the Hooker pick in the playoffs that everyone loves to post as his highlight.

The one consistency is that he didn't repeat any of his mistakes.
[ Edited by jcs on Apr 23, 2017 at 12:20 AM ]
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Would you expect him to say "those interceptions are so and so fault"? what kind of leader would do that? Im not saying he is innocent but you can find easily 5 of that werent really on him. that is a huge percentage of them already.

My only problem with your original statement was saying most were not his fault. It's just not true. If you're gonna say that then you gotta mention all the times he got lucky balls weren't picked.

First of all, being "lucky" happens to everyone. that is like saying Joe montanas pass to john taylor isn't that great because the play before he got lucky and the defender dropped the ball, Montana threw it directly between his numbers. That is just part of the game. I said more often then not, It wasn't neccessarily his fault. if you watch the video posted on the page before this one, its a break down of all his pics and the sequence of events that lead to the interception.

some are poor throws on his part or bad reads, some are just great defensive plays, some are miscommunications and a WR ran the wrong route and some are tipped balls. So it isn't like 90% of his interceptions are his fault. I'm not saying he is perfect, what i am saying is that he isn't an interception machine.
Originally posted by jcs:
That 1/2 of the picks are Watson's fault directly, the other half had variables from tipped passes, receivers falling down or running the wrong route​ to exceptional plays by the defender like the Hooker pick in the playoffs that everyone loves to post as his highlight.

The one consistency is that he didn't repeat any of his mistakes.


Wasn't the hooker play where he threw it to lil Renfrow in double coverage?
Originally posted by tankle104:
First of all, being "lucky" happens to everyone. that is like saying Joe montanas pass to john taylor isn't that great because the play before he got lucky and the defender dropped the ball, Montana threw it directly between his numbers. That is just part of the game. I said more often then not, It wasn't neccessarily his fault. if you watch the video posted on the page before this one, its a break down of all his pics and the sequence of events that lead to the interception.

some are poor throws on his part or bad reads, some are just great defensive plays, some are miscommunications and a WR ran the wrong route and some are tipped balls. So it isn't like 90% of his interceptions are his fault. I'm not saying he is perfect, what i am saying is that he isn't an interception machine.

And I agree he is not an interception machine. He threw a s**t load of passes and had 17 picks which isn't that crazy. Winstons final year was way worse with td-int ratio and he didn't get as much s**t as Watson.

Watson made a good amount of bad decisions last year and s**t happens. It's on him if he gets better.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by jcs:
That 1/2 of the picks are Watson's fault directly, the other half had variables from tipped passes, receivers falling down or running the wrong route​ to exceptional plays by the defender like the Hooker pick in the playoffs that everyone loves to post as his highlight.

The one consistency is that he didn't repeat any of his mistakes.


Wasn't the hooker play where he threw it to lil Renfrow in double coverage?

No, it was pretty clear that the wr was open the moment the ball was released and had a step on the cb, Hooker just made a great play going across 3/4 of the field to beat the wr to the ball.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by tankle104:
First of all, being "lucky" happens to everyone. that is like saying Joe montanas pass to john taylor isn't that great because the play before he got lucky and the defender dropped the ball, Montana threw it directly between his numbers. That is just part of the game. I said more often then not, It wasn't neccessarily his fault. if you watch the video posted on the page before this one, its a break down of all his pics and the sequence of events that lead to the interception.

some are poor throws on his part or bad reads, some are just great defensive plays, some are miscommunications and a WR ran the wrong route and some are tipped balls. So it isn't like 90% of his interceptions are his fault. I'm not saying he is perfect, what i am saying is that he isn't an interception machine.

And I agree he is not an interception machine. He threw a s**t load of passes and had 17 picks which isn't that crazy. Winstons final year was way worse with td-int ratio and he didn't get as much s**t as Watson.

Watson made a good amount of bad decisions last year and s**t happens. It's on him if he gets better.
Watson also passed for 41 TDs to go with another 9 on the ground. He also I believe is the only QB to ever pass for 4,000 yards and rush for 1,100 yards in the same season.

I think the craziest stat with Watson are 97 total TD's in two seasons... And only losing 2 games over that stretch.
[ Edited by jcs on Apr 23, 2017 at 12:36 AM ]
Originally posted by jcs:
No, it was pretty clear that the wr was open the moment the ball was released and had a step on the cb, Hooker just made a great play going across 3/4 of the field to beat the wr to the ball.

Yea , you don't throw that ball. I'm sure it was a quality cb on renfrow. Then If you see Hooker start to take off toward him then you avoid that area like the plague. Easy play for Hooker since he knows Watson only uses half the field.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by jcs:
No, it was pretty clear that the wr was open the moment the ball was released and had a step on the cb, Hooker just made a great play going across 3/4 of the field to beat the wr to the ball.

Yea , you don't throw that ball. I'm sure it was a quality cb on renfrow. Then If you see Hooker start to take off toward him then you avoid that area like the plague. Easy play for Hooker since he knows Watson only uses half the field.

That was not an easy play, anyone but hooker and it's a TD
Originally posted by jcs:
Watson also passed for 41 TDs to go with another 9 on the ground. He also I believe is the only QB to ever pass for 4,000 yards and rush for 1,100 yards in the same season.


Tajh Boyd had 44 total td and 11 int on that team right before Watson started playing. Year before that had 46 total td and 13 int. Both were about 4000(100 or so short) yard passing seasons in 13 games.
Originally posted by jcs:
That was not an easy play, anyone but hooker and it's a TD


That's why you know who's out there and you don't force it. Everyone by then knew what hooker was capabale of.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
That's why you know who's out there and you don't force it. Everyone by then knew what hooker was capabale of.

That's a shot you want your QB to take every time, just didn't work out on that play. Watson still won that game 31 - 0
[ Edited by jcs on Apr 23, 2017 at 12:40 AM ]
Originally posted by jcs:
That's a shot you want your QB to take every time, just didn't work out on that play. Watson still won that game 31 - 0



Not me, I'd rather my qb not force it downfield when you got the best Safety in the league running it down.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Tajh Boyd had 44 total td and 11 int on that team right before Watson started playing. Year before that had 46 total td and 13 int. Both were about 4000(100 or so short) yard passing seasons in 13 games.

Boyd never passed for more than 36 TDs or 3800 yards in a season. He also never had the measurables that Watson put up at the combine or lead his teams to national championship runs in back to back seasons. Boyd also never rushed for more than 500 yards in a single season.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,964
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
Originally posted by jcs:
That's a shot you want your QB to take every time, just didn't work out on that play. Watson still won that game 31 - 0


Not me, I'd rather my qb not force it downfield when you got the best Safety in the league running it down.

To me it's better than the timid QB like Alex Smith or Keap who is always looking for the check down rather than the big play.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone