49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 792 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by genus49:
We're attracting free agents without a QB, we can certainly attract them next year. What happens if Cousins gets injured here?

This is a rebuilding effort. IMO we should hold our cards and see how things shake out. What happens if we're in position to draft one of the stud QBs next season? We wait and we can get Cousins for nothing while seeing what we have and where we stand for next year's draft and how that QB class shakes out.

#2 to #17 is a huge drop. There will be a quality player available there as well but not on the level at #2. If we have a chance at getting a guy at #2 and Cousins next year you hold out. Unless Washington wants to throw in a 2nd rounder or take a lower round pick we shouldn't let them off their stupid hook.
We have to pay extra to get guys here and no one is coming here to win a championship right now. We get Cousins, have a good draft, and get to around 500 next season and we will be looked at as a playoff contender.

I dont think we are as bad as we were last year. Injuries (a ton of injuries) and bad coaching fits have made us look a lot worse than we should be. If we are bad and in a position to draft high next year then we can spend that pick on something other than QB (edge rusher, WR, etc.).

#2 to #17 is a big drop, but to get our starting QB for the foreseeable future at the low cost of dropping down 15 spots is a steal. Look at the prior QB trades: Bradford for a 1st and 4th, Smith for 2 2nds, Palmer for 1st and 2nd, Cutler for 2 1sts and some extras.

Cousins could probably be compared to Cutler when he was traded. QBs cost a ton to get when you need one and moving 15 spots for a guy in his prime that fits our system is the steal of all steals. Granted we would be bailing the Redskins out a bit because they are screwed, but it adds a ton of value and credibility to us right away.
Originally posted by genus49:
We're attracting free agents without a QB, we can certainly attract them next year. What happens if Cousins gets injured here?

This is a rebuilding effort. IMO we should hold our cards and see how things shake out. What happens if we're in position to draft one of the stud QBs next season? We wait and we can get Cousins for nothing while seeing what we have and where we stand for next year's draft and how that QB class shakes out.

#2 to #17 is a huge drop. There will be a quality player available there as well but not on the level at #2. If we have a chance at getting a guy at #2 and Cousins next year you hold out. Unless Washington wants to throw in a 2nd rounder or take a lower round pick we shouldn't let them off their stupid hook.


If Kirk has a great year they could slap the transition tag on him and match whatever we offer. If he has a great year they'll do whatever they can to keep him, even if we frontload the hell out of it. Maybe before the season ends, they fix their relationship and offer him a massive contract. He might like Kyle but money talks. He'd be in a situation where he takes the offer or waits and plays through the rest of the season and risks an injury just to take the same offer from Kyle.

I wouldn't be greedy, I'd just take him and swap picks just to make sure we got him. Won't feel safe until it's announced that Kirk is ours. So many things can happen, especially in football.
Originally posted by hohbie:
We have to pay extra to get guys here and no one is coming here to win a championship right now. We get Cousins, have a good draft, and get to around 500 next season and we will be looked at as a playoff contender.

I dont think we are as bad as we were last year. Injuries (a ton of injuries) and bad coaching fits have made us look a lot worse than we should be. If we are bad and in a position to draft high next year then we can spend that pick on something other than QB (edge rusher, WR, etc.).

#2 to #17 is a big drop, but to get our starting QB for the foreseeable future at the low cost of dropping down 15 spots is a steal. Look at the prior QB trades: Bradford for a 1st and 4th, Smith for 2 2nds, Palmer for 1st and 2nd, Cutler for 2 1sts and some extras.

Cousins could probably be compared to Cutler when he was traded. QBs cost a ton to get when you need one and moving 15 spots for a guy in his prime that fits our system is the steal of all steals. Granted we would be bailing the Redskins out a bit because they are screwed, but it adds a ton of value and credibility to us right away.

If the team shows improvement and growth that brings in free agents.

Don't forget about the legal tampering period. If Cousins is available everyone will know he's coming here so those free agents will be just as likely to sign. If anything maybe more so because the assumption will be his game will only get better with Shanahan as HC.

What if we trade for him now and he doesn't light the world on fire? That could make some guys question him as a legit QB here.

All those other trades the teams trading them had serious leverage. Washington totally blew this for themselves and everyone is laughing at them and their dysfunctional front office. We shouldn't give them a life line.
Originally posted by GhostOfBaalke:
If Kirk has a great year they could slap the transition tag on him and match whatever we offer. If he has a great year they'll do whatever they can to keep him, even if we frontload the hell out of it. Maybe before the season ends, they fix their relationship and offer him a massive contract. He might like Kyle but money talks. He'd be in a situation where he takes the offer or waits and plays through the rest of the season and risks an injury just to take the same offer from Kyle.

I wouldn't be greedy, I'd just take him and swap picks just to make sure we got him. Won't feel safe until it's announced that Kirk is ours. So many things can happen, especially in football.

Meh...I guess a part of me still questions how great Kirk is. He's going to be 29 this season.

I'd rather we ride it out, use this draft to improve the team and see where we stand at the end of next season. Next year's QB class could be stacked. I'd love to see our options before committing not only a huge contract but giving up some serious draft capital.
Still don't see the infatuation for Kirk. He has nice stats, but he failed to win a do or die situation against the giants. If were really worth it, he wouldn't even be close to available and the redskins wouldve offered him a huuuge contract. Yes theyre dysfunctional but I don't think its all one sided. There is something wrong in Kirks side also.
Originally posted by genus49:
If the team shows improvement and growth that brings in free agents.

Don't forget about the legal tampering period. If Cousins is available everyone will know he's coming here so those free agents will be just as likely to sign. If anything maybe more so because the assumption will be his game will only get better with Shanahan as HC.

What if we trade for him now and he doesn't light the world on fire? That could make some guys question him as a legit QB here.

All those other trades the teams trading them had serious leverage. Washington totally blew this for themselves and everyone is laughing at them and their dysfunctional front office. We shouldn't give them a life line.
I guess we will have to just disagree.

Our coach knows Cousins as good as anyone not on the Redskins right now, so he would know if he was worth it or not.

What if the Patriots trade Garappolo and Brady decides to retire at the end of next season? All the sudden a team with a lot of cap room and a lot more talent would have an opening and would be a lot more attractive than the 49ers.

I disagree with the leverage part. We didnt have a ton of leverage with Smith. Kaep was going to start, so we could have hung on to Smith for one year as a backup (not much leverage there). Cutler made it well known he wanted out of Denver at the time so same thing there.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by Jcool:

somewhere, Rascal and Wu are jizzing themselves
Cousins isn't just going to come here and light it up. There's going to be a transition period with him too. The quicker you get him in the quicker we turn this ship around. If Wsh offers 17 and Cousins for 2 I'd be all over it. I'll take the extra wins this year and next. I think genus has a valid point in that next year's draft class is loaded why not wait and see what they bring but remember Shanny's system is complex as Hell and takes vets years to pick up. Will Shanny want to develop a rookie over Cousins? Unlikely. As long as Cousins is available and doesn't tear his arm off I think he'll be our qb. If we can make it happen tomorrow for a reasonable price hell yeah I'm down.
Originally posted by Jcool:

Please god no.
  • Cjez
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 170,912
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
Please god no.

i'd lose all faith in lynch/ks if they went RB with our 1st pick.
Originally posted by ChazBoner:
i'd lose all faith in lynch/ks if they went RB with our 1st pick.

NOT ME!
Get Cousins then Edge and WR with the first 2 picks and we're instantly a whole lot better.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Cousins isn't just going to come here and light it up. There's going to be a transition period with him too. The quicker you get him in the quicker we turn this ship around. If Wsh offers 17 and Cousins for 2 I'd be all over it. I'll take the extra wins this year and next. I think genus has a valid point in that next year's draft class is loaded why not wait and see what they bring but remember Shanny's system is complex as Hell and takes vets years to pick up. Will Shanny want to develop a rookie over Cousins? Unlikely. As long as Cousins is available and doesn't tear his arm off I think he'll be our qb. If we can make it happen tomorrow for a reasonable price hell yeah I'm down.

If we can swap 1sts and get Kirk that would be amazing.
Originally posted by ChazBoner:
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
Please god no.

i'd lose all faith in lynch/ks if they went RB with our 1st pick.

I would as well
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone