49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 965 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by NYniner85:
The MMQB's Peter King calls the Bears big fans of Stanford EDGE/DL Solomon Thomas.

King has Thomas off the board at No. 2, but doesn't seem confident in the selection. Thomas to the Bears makes a lot of sense with John Fox's history and the team having talent along the defensive front but lacking a susperstar. Still, Thomas might be on the board longer than we expect.

I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.
[ Edited by Willisfn4life on Apr 25, 2017 at 8:00 AM ]
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Throw in AJ Green and we may have a conversation.

That I'd definitely do.
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

I'd be thrilled as hell with either player.

I think Garrett is going to be a stud but I also think Thomas' best football is ahead of him and he's a lot more versatile than Garrett. Still I'd prefer Garrett because he would be a perfect fit for what we need most and has the crazy athletic ability to go with a proven track record. He may not have the same mean streak on the field as Thomas but I think last year he was hurt and just trying to get to the NFL.

Many people were kind of trashing Joey Bosa and Clowney for similar seasons before entering the draft and Bosa had no problems even after a holdout. Clowney had some injury issues but he's now a dominant force out there. I think Garrett will have no problem making an impact in the NFL. Hopefully either he or Thomas are doing it for the 49ers.
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
The MMQB's Peter King calls the Bears big fans of Stanford EDGE/DL Solomon Thomas.

King has Thomas off the board at No. 2, but doesn't seem confident in the selection. Thomas to the Bears makes a lot of sense with John Fox's history and the team having talent along the defensive front but lacking a susperstar. Still, Thomas might be on the board longer than we expect.

I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

edge rushers are the sexy flashy pick...Myles is that and his measurables are nuts

People forget how important interior pass rush is though (Justin Smith says hi). Quickest way to a QB is a straight line. Thomas doesn't come off the field either and is a stud in the running game.

Shaw was on NFL radio last week and was very objective on Solomon. He stated his get off as a interior DL is unmatched in this draft. He diagnosis plays (pass/rush) so fast and he's speed/strength are crazy for a guy his size. He lined him up inside because of this and feels that's his best position in the NFL (not LEO)

People that don't want him at two IMO base it purely on the fact that we've drafted DL the past two yrs. I get it, but one guy hasn't shown he's a starter in this league and the fact that we will be in nickle like 70% of the time makes his versatility even more important.

This is a new regime past drafts shouldn't really affect future drafts unless they're pro-bowlers and last I saw we had zero of those last yr.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
The MMQB's Peter King calls the Bears big fans of Stanford EDGE/DL Solomon Thomas.

King has Thomas off the board at No. 2, but doesn't seem confident in the selection. Thomas to the Bears makes a lot of sense with John Fox's history and the team having talent along the defensive front but lacking a susperstar. Still, Thomas might be on the board longer than we expect.

I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

edge rushers are the sexy flashy pick...Myles is that and his measurables are nuts

People forget how important interior pass rush is though (Justin Smith says hi). Quickest way to a QB is a straight line. Thomas doesn't come off the field either and is a stud in the running game.

Shaw was on NFL radio last week and was very objective on Solomon. He stated his get off as a interior DL is unmatched in this draft. He diagnosis plays (pass/rush) so fast and he's speed/strength are crazy for a guy his size. He lined him up inside because of this and feels that's his best position in the NFL (not LEO)

People that don't want him at two IMO base it purely on the fact that we've drafted DL the past two yrs. I get it, but one guy hasn't shown he's a starter in this league and the fact that we will be in nickle like 70% of the time makes his versatility even more important.

This is a new regime past drafts shouldn't really affect future drafts unless they're pro-bowlers and last I saw we had zero of those last yr.

Exactly.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

I'd be thrilled as hell with either player.

I think Garrett is going to be a stud but I also think Thomas' best football is ahead of him and he's a lot more versatile than Garrett. Still I'd prefer Garrett because he would be a perfect fit for what we need most and has the crazy athletic ability to go with a proven track record. He may not have the same mean streak on the field as Thomas but I think last year he was hurt and just trying to get to the NFL.

Many people were kind of trashing Joey Bosa and Clowney for similar seasons before entering the draft and Bosa had no problems even after a holdout. Clowney had some injury issues but he's now a dominant force out there. I think Garrett will have no problem making an impact in the NFL. Hopefully either he or Thomas are doing it for the 49ers.

Guys like Solomon Thomas or Jamal Adams seem to fit more in line with the type of talents that Lynch and Shanahan have continued to preach that their on the outlook for. They are "safer" picks. Guys with a nasty on the field physicality where the motor shows up pretty consistently, but are well spoken, well mannered off the field. They have seemingly less character concerns. They are on field leader types.

However if a talent like Garrett falls into your lap, it's really hard to pass it up. Garrett has it all physically. The arm length, the moves, the burst, the straight line speed, everything you covet in a dynamic pass rusher. Dude has hall of fame/game changing physical ability, but does he have a hall of famer's desire to be great? Gonna be one heck of an interesting draft.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
edge rushers are the sexy flashy pick...Myles is that and his measurables are nuts

People forget how important interior pass rush is though (Justin Smith says hi). Quickest way to a QB is a straight line. Thomas doesn't come off the field either and is a stud in the running game.

Shaw was on NFL radio last week and was very objective on Solomon. He stated his get off as a interior DL is unmatched in this draft. He diagnosis plays (pass/rush) so fast and he's speed/strength are crazy for a guy his size. He lined him up inside because of this and feels that's his best position in the NFL (not LEO)

People that don't want him at two IMO base it purely on the fact that we've drafted DL the past two yrs. I get it, but one guy hasn't shown he's a starter in this league and the fact that we will be in nickle like 70% of the time makes his versatility even more important.

This is a new regime past drafts shouldn't really affect future drafts unless they're pro-bowlers and last I saw we had zero of those last yr.

So if Thomas doesn't pan out like the "others" do the Niners draft a DL for the the FOURTH year in a row next year?
[ Edited by VA9erfan on Apr 25, 2017 at 8:34 AM ]
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

I'd be thrilled as hell with either player.

I think Garrett is going to be a stud but I also think Thomas' best football is ahead of him and he's a lot more versatile than Garrett. Still I'd prefer Garrett because he would be a perfect fit for what we need most and has the crazy athletic ability to go with a proven track record. He may not have the same mean streak on the field as Thomas but I think last year he was hurt and just trying to get to the NFL.

Many people were kind of trashing Joey Bosa and Clowney for similar seasons before entering the draft and Bosa had no problems even after a holdout. Clowney had some injury issues but he's now a dominant force out there. I think Garrett will have no problem making an impact in the NFL. Hopefully either he or Thomas are doing it for the 49ers.

Guys like Solomon Thomas or Jamal Adams seem to fit more in line with the type of talents that Lynch and Shanahan have continued to preach that their on the outlook for. They are "safer" picks. Guys with a nasty on the field physicality where the motor shows up pretty consistently, but are well spoken, well mannered off the field. They have seemingly less character concerns. They are on field leader types.

However if a talent like Garrett falls into your lap, it's really hard to pass it up. Garrett has it all physically. The arm length, the moves, the burst, the straight line speed, everything you covet in a dynamic pass rusher. Dude has hall of fame/game changing physical ability, but does he have a hall of famer's desire to be great? Gonna be one heck of an interesting draft.

definitely shaping up to be our most interesting draft in years
Originally posted by VA9erfan:
So if Thomas doesn't pan out like the "others" do the Niners draft a DL for the the FOURTH year in a row next year?

We'll be drafting the Leo or Sam in the 1st next year so yeah it would be DL 4 years in a row.
John Lynch can evaluate the safety position well, because he's played it. If Adams is the #2 pick, then we'll know why.
[ Edited by ComeOnDeberg on Apr 25, 2017 at 8:36 AM ]
Originally posted by post_primitive:
Gotcha.

I guess I'm extra salty about Mixon b/c I go to OU. And I personally have a strong aversion toward violence against women. Lots of fans defending him here in some fashion or another and it kind of pisses me off.

I definitely ain't defending his actions. Let's get that right.
Greg Gabriel (@greggabe) tweeted at 11:03 AM on Tue, Apr 25, 2017:
Keep being told that some in the Cleveland FO want to use #1 on Trubisky. They feel SF will take him at 2. But SF IS NOT TAKING A QB AT 2!
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
The MMQB's Peter King calls the Bears big fans of Stanford EDGE/DL Solomon Thomas.

King has Thomas off the board at No. 2, but doesn't seem confident in the selection. Thomas to the Bears makes a lot of sense with John Fox's history and the team having talent along the defensive front but lacking a susperstar. Still, Thomas might be on the board longer than we expect.

I see the argument here for some. To me from down to down, I think Solomon was a more consistent disruption over Garrett so it really comes down to self belief. Was Garrett's inconsistencies because he was playing through injury or were they tied to him taking plays off? There are theories that he was taking plays off to rest up a bit for his NFL career and not risk further injury. It's a tough call that a GM will have to make. The dude has hall of fame talent and measurables on the outside of his body. You always are taking a risk no matter who you draft on the measurables that you can't put on a stat sheet.

edge rushers are the sexy flashy pick...Myles is that and his measurables are nuts

People forget how important interior pass rush is though (Justin Smith says hi). Quickest way to a QB is a straight line. Thomas doesn't come off the field either and is a stud in the running game.

Shaw was on NFL radio last week and was very objective on Solomon. He stated his get off as a interior DL is unmatched in this draft. He diagnosis plays (pass/rush) so fast and he's speed/strength are crazy for a guy his size. He lined him up inside because of this and feels that's his best position in the NFL (not LEO)

People that don't want him at two IMO base it purely on the fact that we've drafted DL the past two yrs. I get it, but one guy hasn't shown he's a starter in this league and the fact that we will be in nickle like 70% of the time makes his versatility even more important.

This is a new regime past drafts shouldn't really affect future drafts unless they're pro-bowlers and last I saw we had zero of those last yr.

I've been very supportive of that as well. Shanahan and Lynch have zero ties to anyone that was on this roster before they were hired and those guys are going to have to work for that approval, if they want to stay 49ers. Alot of the Solomon debate comes from people putting faces and measurable similarity in line with the Seahawks' depth chart and running our cover 3 scheme parallel to the way that they do it. Because we already have Buckner and Armstead, how do we fit them in and Thomas who are all better interior rushers. I have to agree though, you don't pass up a guy like Thomas because of those questions. You put talent on the field, let it compete and let the best players emerge, and that's how winners are built. The Patriots are infamous for this. Outside of Tom Brady, nobody on that roster is safe on a year to year basis. Belichick constantly adds to the competition. Do you think he cares who's in place on the depth chart. Heck no. The better players will emerge and play and the losers will either but cut or pushed down the depth chart.

We can still be a single high defense and not do it just like the Seahawks. We may still not come out of this draft with a traditional LEO type rusher or one who can immediately contribute in that role but coaches are hired to plan around the talent they have. Thomas is still a great talent that too me doesn't complicate things but just simply adds to the dline competition. Saleh would just have to think outside of the box if he doesn't have that more traditional LEO THIS year. Afterall, it's what he gets paid for.
[ Edited by Willisfn4life on Apr 25, 2017 at 8:47 AM ]
Originally posted by Niner_Faithful_MTL:
Greg Gabriel (@greggabe) tweeted at 11:03 AM on Tue, Apr 25, 2017:
Keep being told that some in the Cleveland FO want to use #1 on Trubisky. They feel SF will take him at 2. But SF IS NOT TAKING A QB AT 2!


Gabriel just wrote a few days ago that the 49ers are enamored with Watson at #2.


I like him but he has been all over the place recently.
Originally posted by ComeOnDeberg:
John Lynch can evaluate the safety position well, because he's played it. If Adams is the #2 pick, then we'll know why.

Same exact concept for Trubisky by Kyle.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone