49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 630 users in the forums

Which QB would you rather take in the draft?

Browse 49ers books and videos

Which QB would you rather take in the draft?

Originally posted by PGENZ:
I just don't think Niners go QB at #2.

The 2016 49ers had the WORST run defense in team history!

Must sure up the defense and try to hit on a QB in rounds 3/4.

If not 2018 is loaded with QB talent.

This is how I feel. Fix other areas, and hope for a later round Dak. If we got our defense good we could play the Kansas City style, with whatever average QB we kept around for one season.
Originally posted by PGENZ:
I just don't think Niners go QB at #2.

The 2016 49ers had the WORST run defense in team history!

Must sure up the defense and try to hit on a QB in rounds 3/4.

If not 2018 is loaded with QB talent.

Meh. Get a competent DC, sign a quality free agency NT and suddenly the run defense just got a lot better.

Bad playcalling, bad scheme and injuries were the main culprits for the state of the run defense.


QB and pass rush are still the biggest needs by far on this roster. If you cant pass the ball, if you cant rush the passer, you cant win.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by PGENZ:
I just don't think Niners go QB at #2.

The 2016 49ers had the WORST run defense in team history!

Must sure up the defense and try to hit on a QB in rounds 3/4.

If not 2018 is loaded with QB talent.

Meh. Get a competent DC, sign a quality free agency NT and suddenly the run defense just got a lot better.

Bad playcalling, bad scheme and injuries were the main culprits for the state of the run defense.


QB and pass rush are still the biggest needs by far on this roster. If you cant pass the ball, if you cant rush the passer, you cant win.

Damn right
  • Rascal
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,926
OK, all this talk about the Browns trading for Garoppolo, that means they are determined to take Myles Garrett at 1.

The 9ers could be moving closer and closer to Trubisky at 2.
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
None. Peterman, mahomes, or jimmy
None of them. This is a weak QB draft IMO. At least at the top it is. I would not take any QB high in this draft. Now if we are talking 2nd or 3rd or 4th round to take a shot on somebody that is a different story. I don't think there is any QB in the 2017 draft worth the #2 pick. Lord I hope they don't do that. It would be a terrible move as far as I am concerned.
  • Rascal
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,926
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
None of them. This is a weak QB draft IMO. At least at the top it is. I would not take any QB high in this draft. Now if we are talking 2nd or 3rd or 4th round to take a shot on somebody that is a different story. I don't think there is any QB in the 2017 draft worth the #2 pick. Lord I hope they don't do that. It would be a terrible move as far as I am concerned.

They say the same sh*t every year cos people don't have the guts nor conviction to go after a legit QB prospect because they are scared of losing their jobs if the QB turns out to be a bust. Well, I got news for you, it happens and that is not confined to the QB position neither.

If there is an intent to go out there and identify the next franchise QB, then all options must be explored. And if for example they feel Trubisky is the guy, I am cool with it!
I agree with you. Take a QB in the 2nd, 3rd or 4th round as a developmental pick (Mahomes, Peterman, or Webb) Use our first round pick for an immediate need. I predict we trade down from 2 and pick up additional draft picks. We need ILB, OLB, NT, and WR to name a few.

Who knows what Lynch will do in the draft....he as no experience so it will be unpredictable.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Meh. Get a competent DC, sign a quality free agency NT and suddenly the run defense just got a lot better.

Bad playcalling, bad scheme and injuries were the main culprits for the state of the run defense.


QB and pass rush are still the biggest needs by far on this roster. If you cant pass the ball, if you cant rush the passer, you cant win.

This. It is way easier to sign quality FAs on defense than on Offense. We need a NT, an ILB, an OLB and a CB/S (depending on the position Ward is going to play) to fill all the big holes on defense. If the niners won't take a QB at #2 (or one after trading down a few spots), they will end up with 4-5 QBs off the board at #34.

The Browns, Texans, Rams, and the Bills missed several starting QBs in the last 5 drafts or so, despite picking early and often.
Originally posted by Poldarn49:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Meh. Get a competent DC, sign a quality free agency NT and suddenly the run defense just got a lot better.

Bad playcalling, bad scheme and injuries were the main culprits for the state of the run defense.


QB and pass rush are still the biggest needs by far on this roster. If you cant pass the ball, if you cant rush the passer, you cant win.

This. It is way easier to sign quality FAs on defense than on Offense. We need a NT, an ILB, an OLB and a CB/S (depending on the position Ward is going to play) to fill all the big holes on defense. If the niners won't take a QB at #2 (or one after trading down a few spots), they will end up with 4-5 QBs off the board at #34.

The Browns, Texans, Rams, and the Bills missed several starting QBs in the last 5 drafts or so, despite picking early and often.

As this is a multi year rebuild I want BPA. I want a team which after 2 years is challenging and after 3 is at or near the top. No compromises. We need QB, pass rush and NT at the top of the list but we aren't going to miss out on much by thinking more long term. No more Reggie McGrew's!
Patrick Mahomes
Originally posted by Boldjames:
Patrick Mahomes😎😎😎

This
Trent Baalke QB scouting video discovered in his office after he left.

Hopefully none. The value will be later on. Draft the best player available and hope you can hit on a Dak Precott, Alex Smith level guy that can make plays and won't lose the game for you later on.
Watson in round 1, Mahomes in round 2 or Peterman in round 3..
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone