Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 998 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Two-Third day picks

1. Seth Russell - Baylor - A bit injury prone
2. Patrick Towles - Boston College - He may go higher than expected (Paxton Lynch clone)
3. Bart Houston - Wisconsin - Looks the part but not much production
4. Tyler O'Connor - Michigan St. - Not the douche Conor Cook is, but doesn't have anywhere near the production either, played in 12 games in 3 yrs.
5. Greyson Lambert - Georgia - Prototypical size and arm strength, but something screams out career back up in his play.

Please dont take this as an attack on you personally....you just happen to be the latest post I have seen similar to posts I have a huge problem with.

WE NEED TO STOP LOOKING PAST THE FIRST OR SECOND ROUND FOR A QUARTERBACK!!!

I am getting SO tired of people having the opinion that we should look for diamonds in the rough late in the draft for our future QB. When will people understand that the chances a QB drafted late in the draft will turn out is next to zero? Phoenix made a GREAT thread about it before and more people need to read it and learn it.

Drafting a QB period is a huge risk. A large percentage dont turn out. So why wouldn't you want to take a QB who has the BEST chance of turning out, rather than essentially wasting picks later in the draft? You can get good value late in the draft for a lot of positions. QB simply is not one of them.

(and Kolohe for the record, I have no idea who any of the guys you listed are. What I do know is if they are all slated to be third day picks, I would be willing to bet money that none of them amount to a damn thing.)
Originally posted by Mertonschickendance:
Was not sure if already posted but is there a list of top QBs coming up in the draft? I think its obvious niners will be in the hunt for QB w/ one of their higher picks in the upcoming draft. Would appreciate if anybody can add to the list:

1. Deshawn Watson
2. Brad Kaaya
3. Chad Kelly
4. Luke Falk
5. Baker Mayfield
6. Josh Dobbs

Like all but Dobbs only because I havent watched Dobbs yet.

Would switch 5 and 4. Switch 3 and 2.

1. Watson
2.Kelly
3.Kaaya
4.Mayfield
5.Faulk

This will probably change this year as the season plays out.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Please dont take this as an attack on you personally....you just happen to be the latest post I have seen similar to posts I have a huge problem with.

WE NEED TO STOP LOOKING PAST THE FIRST OR SECOND ROUND FOR A QUARTERBACK!!!

I am getting SO tired of people having the opinion that we should look for diamonds in the rough late in the draft for our future QB. When will people understand that the chances a QB drafted late in the draft will turn out is next to zero? Phoenix made a GREAT thread about it before and more people need to read it and learn it.

Drafting a QB period is a huge risk. A large percentage dont turn out. So why wouldn't you want to take a QB who has the BEST chance of turning out, rather than essentially wasting picks later in the draft? You can get good value late in the draft for a lot of positions. QB simply is not one of them.

(and Kolohe for the record, I have no idea who any of the guys you listed are. What I do know is if they are all slated to be third day picks, I would be willing to bet money that none of them amount to a damn thing.)

Some of those QBs could move up the boards, some could fall off entirely. Things are going to be pretty fluid until the season is over.


There are two or three QBs that I fe pretty good right now, another 5 or so that are intriguing but who knows how the season shakes out. Only time will tell.
I like Luke Falk, Gunner Kiel and Deshaun Watson. Personally. But I also don't know a damn thing about scouting or reviewing a QBs play. Just from what I've seen on YouTube Falk looks like the kinda QB that will leapfrog Watson in the draft. The ball explodes out of his hand and anticipates passes from what I see. Gunner on the other hand is inconsistent but his completion % is that bad and is asked to carry the entire offense at Cinn. People said Goff didn't have any talent around him yet Fowler, Treggs a RB all are on pro teams currently. Kiel had Peake and a O-linemen last year right? Anyways I'll stick with defensive backs where I have had pretty good success in the past few drafts.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,686
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Two-Third day picks

1. Seth Russell - Baylor - A bit injury prone
2. Patrick Towles - Boston College - He may go higher than expected (Paxton Lynch clone)
3. Bart Houston - Wisconsin - Looks the part but not much production
4. Tyler O'Connor - Michigan St. - Not the douche Conor Cook is, but doesn't have anywhere near the production either, played in 12 games in 3 yrs.
5. Greyson Lambert - Georgia - Prototypical size and arm strength, but something screams out career back up in his play.

Please dont take this as an attack on you personally....you just happen to be the latest post I have seen similar to posts I have a huge problem with.

WE NEED TO STOP LOOKING PAST THE FIRST OR SECOND ROUND FOR A QUARTERBACK!!!

I am getting SO tired of people having the opinion that we should look for diamonds in the rough late in the draft for our future QB. When will people understand that the chances a QB drafted late in the draft will turn out is next to zero? Phoenix made a GREAT thread about it before and more people need to read it and learn it.

Drafting a QB period is a huge risk. A large percentage dont turn out. So why wouldn't you want to take a QB who has the BEST chance of turning out, rather than essentially wasting picks later in the draft? You can get good value late in the draft for a lot of positions. QB simply is not one of them.

(and Kolohe for the record, I have no idea who any of the guys you listed are. What I do know is if they are all slated to be third day picks, I would be willing to bet money that none of them amount to a damn thing.)

No I didn't take it as a personal attack but thanks for the concern.

But the reason I listed those QB's well the title does say 2017 QB Draft Class. The QB's I mentioned were meant for research and added names to the list. Some fans may like them and some may not.

With that being said, Luke Falk and maybe Mason Rudolph are the only QB's I want from this draft.
Rather wait for the cant miss QB in Josh Rosen
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,686
Originally posted by 49er_Rider:
Rather wait for the cant miss QB in Josh Rosen

Trust me, lucky I'm not the GM of the 49ers, I'd be sending players and picks to move up to get Rosen. I just don't see any possible scenario that the 49ers can come away with Rosen in 2018.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49er_Rider:
Rather wait for the cant miss QB in Josh Rosen

Trust me, lucky I'm not the GM of the 49ers, I'd be sending players and picks to move up to get Rosen. I just don't see any possible scenario that the 49ers can come away with Rosen in 2018.

Let's be the 76ers of the NFL! Garrett this year and Rosen next. Boom! Get the best corner this year in the second cause Desmond King will drop. Or grab Butt(yes pun intended)
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Let's be the 76ers of the NFL! Garrett this year and Rosen next. Boom! Get the best corner this year in the second cause Desmond King will drop. Or grab Butt(yes pun intended)

LOL....this. What world does that dude live in. Rosen isn't happening. When he does come out he will most likely be the #1 pick and nobody is trading that pick away, so unless people are planning on this team being absolutely dreadful for two straight seasons, its not happening.

You take a QB when you can get one. Big Ben, Flacco, Aaron Rodgers and several other 1st round QB's weren't Top 3 picks and they've all done okay for themselves I guess.

In next year's draft I think both Watson and Falk are very good fits for various reasons assuming they both do well in this upcoming season.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Aug 30, 2016 at 6:44 PM ]
Assuming Falk and Watson both have a good upcoming seasons, they might be the no 1 and 2 picks again even tho Garrett will be the top rated player. Its wayy too early for this but I think it might take a 3-13 type of year to land any of the "top tier" QBs.
I'm no OU fan but I'll take Baker Mayfield in this offense with Chip Kelly any day! Watch him this year, he will surprise you. Poor mans Russel Wilson.
Originally posted by Mertonschickendance:
Assuming Falk and Watson both have a good upcoming seasons, they might be the no 1 and 2 picks again even tho Garrett will be the top rated player. Its wayy too early for this but I think it might take a 3-13 type of year to land any of the "top tier" QBs.

Falk is a poor man's Jared Goff in my opinion and I'm not even sure Goff would have been picked before Garrett if they came out the same year. Falk is a little less athletic than Goff without as much arm strength (doesn't have the same velocity on the run or the same deep ball) or pocket presence. I just can't see him moving all the way up to #1 or #2 without an elite arm or much athleticism and with the same thin frame Goff had. That said, he's pretty accurate on intermediate throws and does everything pretty well so he should still wind up being taken in the first 2 rounds and he'd be a good fit here. I'm rooting for all the draft eligible QB's to improve so we have as many options as possible in the first few rounds.

Guys like Kaaya and Kelly have the arm talent to go top 2 or 3 along with Watson, but Kaaya is a statue and Kelly has significant off field issues and may be a little undersized (looks 6'0 or 6'1). Seth Russell, Patrick Mahomes, and Deshone Kizer are other guys with a ton of upside who could move up a lot with good seasons. Mahomes has a huge arm (can throw 65 yards from his knees), Russell has a ton of athleticism (4.6 40 and 40" vertical) and good arm strength, and Kizer has size, decent athleticism, and arm strength.

Daniel Jeremiah recently predicted Kizer would win the Heisman, but I don't know how he'll put up monster numbers with Torii Hunter as his top returning receiver.
http://notredame.247sports.com/Bolt/NFL-analyst-picks-Notre-Dame-QB-Deshone-Kizer-to-win-Heisman-46960113

This is one writer's opinion of the strongest arms in college football:
http://www.nfl.com/photoessays/0ap3000000665982
Originally posted by Mertonschickendance:
Assuming Falk and Watson both have a good upcoming seasons, they might be the no 1 and 2 picks again even tho Garrett will be the top rated player. Its wayy too early for this but I think it might take a 3-13 type of year to land any of the "top tier" QBs.

I don't see Falk being a Top 3 pick. I expect him to move up, especially with a good season but I don't think he'll go that high. Watson is the likely #1 if he doesn't completely suck it up this season.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
I like Luke Falk, Gunner Kiel and Deshaun Watson. Personally. But I also don't know a damn thing about scouting or reviewing a QBs play. Just from what I've seen on YouTube Falk looks like the kinda QB that will leapfrog Watson in the draft. The ball explodes out of his hand and anticipates passes from what I see. Gunner on the other hand is inconsistent but his completion % is that bad and is asked to carry the entire offense at Cinn. People said Goff didn't have any talent around him yet Fowler, Treggs a RB all are on pro teams currently. Kiel had Peake and a O-linemen last year right? Anyways I'll stick with defensive backs where I have had pretty good success in the past few drafts.

Gunner Kiel isn't even starting for Cincinnati anymore. He's the backup.

And Peake played for Clemson, not Cincinnati.
[ Edited by Travisty13 on Aug 31, 2016 at 6:15 AM ]
Originally posted by Travisty13:
Gunner Kiel isn't even starting for Cincinnati anymore. He's the backup.

And Peake played for Clemson, not Cincinnati.

Interesting, I hadn't heard that.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone