Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 967 users in the forums

2016 Draft Picks

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by REB4:
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
In a way, this was very much like a Scot McCloughan draft...head-scratching is the initial reaction, but 2-3 years down the road you start to see the impact of their contributions.

Arik Armstead - Likely inactive a lot in 2015, but should anchor the LDE position for years to come.
Jaquiski "Pop" Tartt - Special teamer now, but could be the eventual starter next to Reid with size, speed and athleticism
Eli Harold - Could be an excellent nickel pass rusher or eventual starter should Aldon/Lynch regress
Blake Bell - Love his size at the TE position and could be a match-up nightmare
Mike Davis - LOVE THIS PICK. Reminds me a lot of Gore and think he's an ideal compliment to Hyde
DeAndre Smelter - LOVE THIS PICK EVEN MORE. IMO, potential #1 talent once healthy. Major steal here
The punter - No comment
Ian Silberman - ???
Trenton Brown - If he can keep his weight in check, has the potential to be a dominating o-lineman
Rory "Busta" Anderson - Great height/speed combo at TE; could be a major steal if he can develop and stay healthy

Clearly it all depends on how they develop, but there is absolutely no doubt that they drafted a ton of talent with the common themes of size, speed and ability.
Respect your posts, but have to just point out that your comments on our top 3 picks all have qualifiers of could/should. That's a lot of maybe/possibly/hopefully wishful thinking. Unless they are QBs, the top 3 picks are supposed to be guys that are ready to help/compete RIGHT NOW! We have holes RIGHT NOW at WR, CB, OL, ILB. If this was a top elite team, then it can afford to draft guys that are would/could/should help you at some point in the future. But those types of projects need to be drafted in later rounds.This isn't a top elite team anymore.

Anyone who speaks about the draft in terms of "certainties" is either delusional, ignorant, uninformed or all of the above. NOBODY knows what any of these guys will do for certain, ever. That's the nature of the draft whether it be football, baseball, basketball, chess, tag or marbles. Also, what you call "projects" are what other people call "system fits."

IMO, teams get into trouble when they chase after needs in the draft...it often leads to getting guys who might fill a hole today all while passing on guys who you've graded as better football players who could end up being stars in your system down the road. I liken it to companies who cut corners in order to meet their short-term quarterly numbers, sacrificing more sustainable practices and negatively impacting their long-term health and viability. Short-term sugar highs as opposed to lesser-tasting-but-much-healthier fruits and veggies is another way of looking at it.

It definitely takes discipline to stay true to your vision and do the right things for your long-term viability (see Jeff Bezos as an example of this)...it's also very often mistaken for hubris or incompetence.

Anyway, that's my take.
[ Edited by GhostofFredDean74 on May 3, 2015 at 2:32 PM ]
Originally posted by REB4:
Respect your posts, but have to just point out that your comments on our top 3 picks all have qualifiers of could/should. That's a lot of maybe/possibly/hopefully wishful thinking. Unless they are QBs, the top 3 picks are supposed to be guys that are ready to help/compete RIGHT NOW! We have holes RIGHT NOW at WR, CB, OL, ILB. If this was a top elite team, then it can afford to draft guys that are would/could/should help you at some point in the future. But those types of projects need to be drafted in later rounds.This isn't a top elite team anymore.

And those guys are just as likely to bust. Aaron Curry is the ultimate example of that. Considered the safest, can't fail, can't miss, most NFL ready prospect in his draft class, HUGE, enormous bust.

Nothing is ever guaranteed when it comes to the draft, not in Round 1, not even with the very first pick of the draft. The reality is until these guys actually get out on to the field, you honestly don't know what you have.
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
Anyone who speaks about the draft in terms of "certainties" is either delusional, ignorant, uninformed or all of the above. NOBODY knows what any of these guys will do for certain, ever. That's the nature of the draft whether it be football, baseball, basketball, chess, tag or marbles. Also, what you call "projects" are what other people call "system fits."

IMO, teams get into trouble when they chase after needs in the draft...it often leads to getting guys who might fill a hole today all while passing on guys who you've graded as better football players who could end up being stars in your system down the road. I liken it to companies who cut corners in order to meet their short-term quarterly numbers, sacrificing more sustainable practices and negatively impacting their long-term health and viability. Short-term sugar highs as opposed to lesser-tasting-but-much-healthier fruits and veggies is another way of looking at it.

It definitely takes discipline to stay true to your vision and do the right things for your long-term viability (see Jeff Bezos as an example of this)...it's also very often mistaken for hubris or incompetence.

Anyway, that's my take.


You win the analogy sweepstakes.


Fans think short term, bad GM's think short term, good GM's think short and long term in their draft approach.
Still going to need:

WR-Boldin is gone and Simpson won't be a long term guy.

QB-Gabbert is crap so a real backup and developmental guy is needed

OT/OG-Boone should be gone. Hopefully Martin and Thomas play LG and RG. But that leaves a hole at backup OG/C and a real dedicated swing OT.

CB-Once we drop the one year projects we still could use somebody to push for a starting role against Johnson and Brock.

ILB-Need the heir to Willis and Bowman at some point. Who and when is the unknown but we need that next great guy.

NT-Still see a need for a monster to come in and kick either Dorsey, TJE, or Williams off the roster.

K-If we have the balls to drop Lee over salary we can do the same to Dawson.

PR/KR-Can we get somebody that can score TD's and hold onto the ball. I want a real return specialist soon!
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
I don't quite understand 2 TEs, we just gave Carrier a $400K bonus on a 2yr extension, we have former 2nd rd pick McDonald, and Vernon, plus Celek re-signed, plus we have Asante Cleveland and Xavier Grimble under contract, now we have 8 TEs on the roster, 9 if you count Kyle Nelson.

I love the Harold, Davis, and Smelter picks. I think Brown can beat out Looney for a spot, I've never been impressed by Looney.

I don't get Tartt in the 2nd, we needed an ILB more than a SS. Does this mean we have no faith in Ward, who is a SS.

Armstead is a risky 1st rd pick, when if Justin retires, he may have to play year 1.

A Punter? Why? Andy Lee is still good, sure he cots $2.5M, but only $500K is guaranteed in that, so maybe they cut him, which idk if is smart.

Agree with the TE picks that makes me

Looks like they will use Tartt in passing downs and take MW out, he will cover TEs...I can get on board with this pick.

My favorite picks are Smelter and Harold for sure.

The punter pick in the 5th IMO was the biggest ??

Might as will add this draft to the 2016 draft because we will not see a ton of these players on the field in 2015, I knew Baalke had holes filled based on FA and the past two drafts, that's why I wanted to move up for a game changer
Originally posted by jreff22:
Still going to need:

WR-Boldin is gone and Simpson won't be a long term guy.

QB-Gabbert is crap so a real backup and developmental guy is needed

OT/OG-Boone should be gone. Hopefully Martin and Thomas play LG and RG. But that leaves a hole at backup OG/C and a real dedicated swing OT.

CB-Once we drop the one year projects we still could use somebody to push for a starting role against Johnson and Brock.

ILB-Need the heir to Willis and Bowman at some point. Who and when is the unknown but we need that next great guy.

NT-Still see a need for a monster to come in and kick either Dorsey, TJE, or Williams off the roster.

K-If we have the balls to drop Lee over salary we can do the same to Dawson.

PR/KR-Can we get somebody that can score TD's and hold onto the ball. I want a real return specialist soon!

Smelter has some real promise if he can get back to 100% He has Decker Nicks,Boldin written all over him.

I'd love for SF to sign Collins if he is cleared today,imagine that one but I agree unless one of the late picks shows up OL help will be needed in 2016.

We are fine at NT IMO.

PR/KR-Ellington was fine last year and they brought in a ton of UDFA WRs that could handle this.

I wasn't in love with any of the ILBs in this draft...still would like to get Kendricks in a trade or FA this year.
Man, barely any talk about our draft on the local radio. I wish we would have made sexy picks just so I can hear Niners talk on the radio. Baalke is trying too hard to be different/unique underground style where only his circles know and talk about the players he selected.
[ Edited by Joecool on May 4, 2015 at 8:51 AM ]
Originally posted by Gore_21:
^ nothing to do with this thread.

Yeah an extra 5 and extra 6 plus should have a 4th or 5th round comp. Maybe a 7th too.

I put this in another thread but it fits here too:

1. WR - It depends on if boldin leaves and how Patton/Ellington play and what they think of Smelter.
2. TE - If vernon is gone it could be a big need depending on how McDonald, Bell and Carrier do.
3. G - Boone likely gone can the guys who dont win LG this year take over (say Thomas LG, then Martin/Looney/Brown)
4. ILB - Ideally we upgrade over Wilhoite but he's likely here long term at least as a backup. How do Wheeler/Bishop do? Need a #3/2?
5. CB - Depends on how all these young guys play.

Could be needs but probably mid to lower rounds if at all: RB, FB, QB?, OLB, S, DL?

Depends how the 49ers finish. No idea how this team will fare. Division will be extremely difficult this year. Perhaps the 49ers will "Drop for Goff" (tm)
With those extra late round pick we could pick up a pair of kickers
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
Originally posted by REB4:
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
In a way, this was very much like a Scot McCloughan draft...head-scratching is the initial reaction, but 2-3 years down the road you start to see the impact of their contributions.

Arik Armstead - Likely inactive a lot in 2015, but should anchor the LDE position for years to come.
Jaquiski "Pop" Tartt - Special teamer now, but could be the eventual starter next to Reid with size, speed and athleticism
Eli Harold - Could be an excellent nickel pass rusher or eventual starter should Aldon/Lynch regress
Blake Bell - Love his size at the TE position and could be a match-up nightmare
Mike Davis - LOVE THIS PICK. Reminds me a lot of Gore and think he's an ideal compliment to Hyde
DeAndre Smelter - LOVE THIS PICK EVEN MORE. IMO, potential #1 talent once healthy. Major steal here
The punter - No comment
Ian Silberman - ???
Trenton Brown - If he can keep his weight in check, has the potential to be a dominating o-lineman
Rory "Busta" Anderson - Great height/speed combo at TE; could be a major steal if he can develop and stay healthy

Clearly it all depends on how they develop, but there is absolutely no doubt that they drafted a ton of talent with the common themes of size, speed and ability.
Respect your posts, but have to just point out that your comments on our top 3 picks all have qualifiers of could/should. That's a lot of maybe/possibly/hopefully wishful thinking. Unless they are QBs, the top 3 picks are supposed to be guys that are ready to help/compete RIGHT NOW! We have holes RIGHT NOW at WR, CB, OL, ILB. If this was a top elite team, then it can afford to draft guys that are would/could/should help you at some point in the future. But those types of projects need to be drafted in later rounds.This isn't a top elite team anymore.

Anyone who speaks about the draft in terms of "certainties" is either delusional, ignorant, uninformed or all of the above. NOBODY knows what any of these guys will do for certain, ever. That's the nature of the draft whether it be football, baseball, basketball, chess, tag or marbles. Also, what you call "projects" are what other people call "system fits."

IMO, teams get into trouble when they chase after needs in the draft...it often leads to getting guys who might fill a hole today all while passing on guys who you've graded as better football players who could end up being stars in your system down the road. I liken it to companies who cut corners in order to meet their short-term quarterly numbers, sacrificing more sustainable practices and negatively impacting their long-term health and viability. Short-term sugar highs as opposed to lesser-tasting-but-much-healthier fruits and veggies is another way of looking at it.

It definitely takes discipline to stay true to your vision and do the right things for your long-term viability (see Jeff Bezos as an example of this)...it's also very often mistaken for hubris or incompetence.

Anyway, that's my take.

This. I used to tape drafts and go back and watch them. They become quite comical a few seasons down the line. None of this is certain. Even the guys that appear to be, you don't really know what you are going to get.
Originally posted by English:
The qualifiers are on account of Ghost understands the draft. Incidentally, where does it say that the top three picks are supposed to be contributors? You haven't picked up on the way Baalke drafts.
sorry, what did you say?
So we'll have 3 comp picks plus the 9 we already have? Gosh. This guy is ridiculous...haha...I swear over the last 3 years we've had more picks than any team in the nfl
Originally posted by simplyfloyd:
So we'll have 3 comp picks plus the 9 we already have? Gosh. This guy is ridiculous...haha...I swear over the last 3 years we've had more picks than any team in the nfl

Yep! The draft is a lottery; the more tickets you buy the better chance you have at winning (or finding a gem in the draft's case). I bet you are right...10, 12, 11, 7, 10

So his 5 years as running the draft (wont count 2010 since not there the year before to build comp or do the trading, although did the picking) we have 50 picks so 10 a year. I bet the average is 8ish.

Plus at least 10 next year if not 11 or 12. We might not go for the superstars,which hardly works out long term ever, but I'll take 10 picks a year average over the teams like the redskins who spent 5 or so years trading away their draft picks and some years only having 4-5 picks most in the mid to late rounds. Even 10 over 7 is a huge advantage because having multiple picks in the same round allows you to move up or down and it allows you to take bpa more. It also allows you a little more leeway to take risks (injury/off the field).
[ Edited by Gore_21 on May 5, 2015 at 5:51 PM ]
Can someone verify how many comp picks the 49ers are projected to get. I count two, but most reports are saying three.

Lost:
Gore, Crabtree, Lupati, Cox, Skuta, Culliver.

Gained:
Bellore, Pears, Smith, Wright.
(Bush, Dockett, Simpson, Wheeler.) Don't count towards comp picks.

Is this about right?
Originally posted by WerschingMachine:
Can someone verify how many comp picks the 49ers are projected to get. I count two, but most reports are saying three.

Lost:
Gore, Crabtree, Lupati, Cox, Skuta, Culliver.

Gained:
Bellore, Pears, Smith, Wright.
(Bush, Dockett, Simpson, Wheeler.) Don't count towards comp picks.

Is this about right?

Right now OTC(OverTheCap.com, not our OTC here) has us at 3, a 4th, 5th, and 6th.

4th for Cully, 5th for Cox, and 6th for Skuta.

They also count Josh Johnson as a lose, even though he signed a vet minimum deal, will depend on how much he plays, and if he even makes the Bengals roster.

Iupati and Smith cancel each other out.

Bellore, Pears, and Wright cancel out Crabs, Gore, and Josh Johnson.

And correct Bush, Dockett, Simpson, and Wheeler don't count as they were either cut or out of football in 2014.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone