49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 577 users in the forums

Breaking down the 2012 QB class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by MadDog49er:
I think next year's class has more upside that this year's class.

I believe the QB draft order will go like this:

1) Luck- first overall
2) Landry Jones- third overall
3) Matt Barkley- seventh overall
4) Nick Foles- thirteenth overall

Weeden probably is a first rounder, as well. Five first round QB's make sense to me.

The top three guys are pretty good players, and beat the top three from this year's class.

Do you actually expect the top 3 to declare for the draft?? Like you said, those three are better than this years top 3. One of them could easily go #1 overall in the 2013 draft.

BUT if all 3 to declare I have no doubt in my mind teams are gonna be knocking over other teams for these 3 guys.

Btw I think Nick Foles is horrible, no way that guy is a 1st round pick. Slow feet, leaves his receivers out to dry, stares down his targets, decision making stinks. I wouldn't select this guy in the 2nd round.

Completely agree. I don't know what others see in him despite his prototypical size.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,667
Originally posted by SF69ers:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by MadDog49er:
I think next year's class has more upside that this year's class.

I believe the QB draft order will go like this:

1) Luck- first overall
2) Landry Jones- third overall
3) Matt Barkley- seventh overall
4) Nick Foles- thirteenth overall

Weeden probably is a first rounder, as well. Five first round QB's make sense to me.

The top three guys are pretty good players, and beat the top three from this year's class.

Do you actually expect the top 3 to declare for the draft?? Like you said, those three are better than this years top 3. One of them could easily go #1 overall in the 2013 draft.

BUT if all 3 to declare I have no doubt in my mind teams are gonna be knocking over other teams for these 3 guys.

Btw I think Nick Foles is horrible, no way that guy is a 1st round pick. Slow feet, leaves his receivers out to dry, stares down his targets, decision making stinks. I wouldn't select this guy in the 2nd round.

Completely agree. I don't know what others see in him despite his prototypical size.

I don't know either, but I think your right too it may just be his prototypical size. I don't see anything else in him that makes him a 1st round pick.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SF69ers:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by MadDog49er:
I think next year's class has more upside that this year's class.

I believe the QB draft order will go like this:

1) Luck- first overall
2) Landry Jones- third overall
3) Matt Barkley- seventh overall
4) Nick Foles- thirteenth overall

Weeden probably is a first rounder, as well. Five first round QB's make sense to me.

The top three guys are pretty good players, and beat the top three from this year's class.

Do you actually expect the top 3 to declare for the draft?? Like you said, those three are better than this years top 3. One of them could easily go #1 overall in the 2013 draft.

BUT if all 3 to declare I have no doubt in my mind teams are gonna be knocking over other teams for these 3 guys.

Btw I think Nick Foles is horrible, no way that guy is a 1st round pick. Slow feet, leaves his receivers out to dry, stares down his targets, decision making stinks. I wouldn't select this guy in the 2nd round.

Completely agree. I don't know what others see in him despite his prototypical size.

I don't know either, but I think your right too it may just be his prototypical size. I don't see anything else in him that makes him a 1st round pick.

I'm a Wildcat so I'm obviously biased, but I like Foles quite a bit as a low 1st or 2nd round pick. He's accurate, has a strong arm, he's more mobile than you're giving him credit for, and he's got a penchant for dramtic comebacks against good teams (not always wins, but he's one of those QBs who makes you feel like you've still got a chance as long as he's playing).

Unfortunately he's also got a bit of Eli Manning in him - he'll throw a boneheaded pick that keeps the other team alive when we should be finishing them off, and he does force some ill-advised passes. With a coach like Harbaugh I'd think he can minimize these mistakes.

Watching Gabbert leading up to this draft reminded me a lot of him - I bet Foles runs the 40 0.2 seconds slower (4.8 or so), but his college stats will be quite a bit better (and he'll have 3 years as a starter under his belt).
These list are fun but sooo much can change in a year of college football and going through the draft process.

Here is the list in the zone after the 2009 draft.


Top 2010 NFL Draft Prospects (Quarterbacks)
Player Rank Position College Height Weight Projection
Colt McCoy 0 QB Texas 6-3 216 Top 10 Pick
Tim Tebow 0 QB Florida 6-3 238 3rd-4th Round
Dan LeFevour 0 QB Central Michigan 6-3 228 2nd-3rd Round
Zac Robinson 0 QB Oklahoma State 6-3 212 3rd Round
Tim Hiller 0 QB Western Michigan 6-5 228 2nd-3rd Round
Sam Bradford* 0 QB Oklahoma 6-4 214 Top 15 Pick
Jevan Snead* 0 QB Ole Miss. 6-3 215 Top 10 Pick
Jimmy Clausen* 0 QB Notre Dame 6-3 217 1st-2nd Round
Pat Devlin* 0 QB Delaware 6-4 220 2nd Round
Jake Locker* 0 QB Washington 6-3 223 1st-2nd Round
Juice Williams 0 QB Illinois 6-2 233 4th-5th Round
Jarrett Brown 0 QB West Virginia 6-4 220 4th-5th Round
Darryl Clark 0 QB Penn State 6-2 231 5th Round
Rusty Smith 0 QB Florida Atlantic 6-5 230 5th Round
Tony Pike 0 QB Cincinnati 6-6 225 3rd-4th Round
Max Hall 0 QB BYU 6-1 201 6th Round
Ryan Perriloux 0 QB Jacksonville State 6-3 222 6th-7th Round
Matt Grothe 0 QB South Florida 6-0 210 7th-UDFA
Joe Cox 0 QB Georgia 6-1 210 7th Round
Matt Nichols 0 QB Eastern Washington 6-2 220 7th-UDFA
Kyle Reed 0 QB San Jose State 6-3 215 7th-UDFA
Riley Skinner 0 QB Wake Forest 6-1 200 7th-UDFA
T.J. Yates* 0 QB North Carolina 6-3 205 6th-UDFA
Todd Reesing 0 QB Kansas 5-11 200 7th-UDFA
Jonathan Crompton 0 QB Tennessee 6-4 224 7th-UDFA
Patrick Pinkney 0 QB East Carolina 6-0 198
Colin Kaepernick* 0 QB Nevada 6-6 215
Billy Cundiff 0 QB Ashland 6-2 209 6th Round
Joseph Webb 0 QB UAB 6-4 220 7th-UDFA
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
Is Luck really that great of a prospect? I know he is hot this year, and I would love to have him, but how much was due to having superior coaching, and how much is his own skill set? Apparently he is extremely accurate. Anything else that makes him such a fantastic prospect? How does he compare as a prospect to the hot prospects of the past like Elway, Marino, and the Mannings?
Originally posted by fryet:
Is Luck really that great of a prospect? I know he is hot this year, and I would love to have him, but how much was due to having superior coaching, and how much is his own skill set? Apparently he is extremely accurate. Anything else that makes him such a fantastic prospect? How does he compare as a prospect to the hot prospects of the past like Elway, Marino, and the Mannings?

I'm wondering that myself. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: I believe that Andrew Luck's draft stock could take a hit now that Jim Harbaugh left Stanford for the 49ers HC job.
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
I am also wondering if he will have a Sam Bradford type fall. Really hot going into his final college season, but production dips (I think because Bradford was injured). He still gets drafted number 1, but it was not a given that it would happen before the draft.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone