Everyone has different opinions on how good a player is, and how well he fits on a team, but when you look at what we got, we had a nearly ideal draft.
1st -- We address the pass rush, something we have been lacking on the outside since the mid-90's. We didn't like the quarterbacks here, and we couldn't trade down.
2nd -- We get an historically talented college quarterback that Harbaugh likes. We had to move up and get our guy, it would be insane to risk losing the guy who Harbaugh thinks can restore the 49ers franchise.
3rd -- We get a physical, extremely athletic DB who also addresses our needs as a punt returner. If he is just OK at nickel, but above average as a punt returner, he is well worth the 80th pick; but his athletic upside leaves plenty of room for more.
4th -- We get our change of pace back. Too much talent to pass on him at this spot.
5th -- We address the guard position, giving some competition for Rachal, and for the uncertainty at center.
6th -- We get a WR who runs routes and catches the ball, a player who is intimately known by our WR coach. Most flash is trash at WR. We needed this kind of reliability and depth from the position.
After this we go for special teams and more depth.
The arguments about how good the players are, go on forever; but there is no doubt that we addressed needs at nearly the ideal place in each round. The first 6 picks all have a very good shot at not only making the team, but filling in at crucial times next season.
As far as long term is concerned, Colin Kaepernick (and to a lesser extent, Aldon Smith) will decide this draft, not guys like Colin Jones or Bruce Miller. Harbaugh believes he can get the best out of one of the most statistically and physically impressive college quarterbacks of all-time. His track record, gets me very excited about his chances.
Grading how good the draft is, comes years later. Grading for the types of players we needed, at the places we needed them. This draft is an A+.
[ Edited by BrianGO on May 1, 2011 at 19:49:15 ]
There are 807 users in the forums
49er Draft Grades by Round
May 1, 2011 at 7:47 PM
- BrianGO
- Veteran
- Posts: 10,300
May 1, 2011 at 9:21 PM
- buck
- Veteran
- Posts: 13,137
In my estimate, the value of round must be incorporated into any grading system.
There are seven rounds in the draft, so I assigned each a scaled value from 7 for a first round pick to 1 for a seventh round pick.
I gave each pick a score on a 4.00 scale used in grading, but with an A being the highest grade possible--4.00.
A plus raises the base score by .33 points and a minus lowers the base score by .33 points.
An B+ would have a has a value of 3.33 and a B- a value of 2.67.
Then I calculated the grade the same way as the GPA is calculated in school.
My final grade for the draft is 3.15—a solid B.
Here are the individual grades.
Smith A-
Kap A
Culliver C
Hunter A
Kilgore C+
Jones C+
Johnson B
Miller C+
Person B
Holcomb C
[ Edited by buck on May 1, 2011 at 21:25:11 ]
There are seven rounds in the draft, so I assigned each a scaled value from 7 for a first round pick to 1 for a seventh round pick.
I gave each pick a score on a 4.00 scale used in grading, but with an A being the highest grade possible--4.00.
A plus raises the base score by .33 points and a minus lowers the base score by .33 points.
An B+ would have a has a value of 3.33 and a B- a value of 2.67.
Then I calculated the grade the same way as the GPA is calculated in school.
My final grade for the draft is 3.15—a solid B.
Here are the individual grades.
Smith A-
Kap A
Culliver C
Hunter A
Kilgore C+
Jones C+
Johnson B
Miller C+
Person B
Holcomb C
[ Edited by buck on May 1, 2011 at 21:25:11 ]
May 1, 2011 at 9:40 PM
- dj43
- Moderator
- Posts: 38,633
I am glad they chose the 2nd best pass rusher in the draft instead of the 2nd best CB in the draft. That alone improves my view of the draft. Too many get distracted by flashy CBs and forget that a pass rush makes all the secondary look much better than they would if only 1/4 of the secondary had been improved. GRADE: B
As to Kaep, I am going to jump on the Harbaugh bandwagon and say, "if he thinks he is the guy, then I'm fine with it."
Culliver does not seem like the best value but does fill a need. "meh" = C
Hunter sounds like the guy we have been lacking for a long time.
The word "speed" came up in a lot of the bios. That is something this team has lacked for too long. All three phases lacked speed. A quick, nimble QB, a faster safety/CB/returner, a faster RB, more speed on ST...all those add up to an improvement...if they all make the team.
I don't know enough about the rest to make an intelligent comment other than "look again in two years..."
[ Edited by dj43 on May 1, 2011 at 21:44:12 ]
As to Kaep, I am going to jump on the Harbaugh bandwagon and say, "if he thinks he is the guy, then I'm fine with it."
Culliver does not seem like the best value but does fill a need. "meh" = C
Hunter sounds like the guy we have been lacking for a long time.
The word "speed" came up in a lot of the bios. That is something this team has lacked for too long. All three phases lacked speed. A quick, nimble QB, a faster safety/CB/returner, a faster RB, more speed on ST...all those add up to an improvement...if they all make the team.
I don't know enough about the rest to make an intelligent comment other than "look again in two years..."
[ Edited by dj43 on May 1, 2011 at 21:44:12 ]
May 4, 2011 at 12:11 AM
- Jd925
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,286
Originally posted by dj43:
I am glad they chose the 2nd best pass rusher in the draft instead of the 2nd best CB in the draft. That alone improves my view of the draft. Too many get distracted by flashy CBs and forget that a pass rush makes all the secondary look much better than they would if only 1/4 of the secondary had been improved. GRADE: B
As to Kaep, I am going to jump on the Harbaugh bandwagon and say, "if he thinks he is the guy, then I'm fine with it."
Culliver does not seem like the best value but does fill a need. "meh" = C
Hunter sounds like the guy we have been lacking for a long time.
The word "speed" came up in a lot of the bios. That is something this team has lacked for too long. All three phases lacked speed. A quick, nimble QB, a faster safety/CB/returner, a faster RB, more speed on ST...all those add up to an improvement...if they all make the team.
I don't know enough about the rest to make an intelligent comment other than "look again in two years..."
Yeah having a good pass rush is crucial. Peterson will probably be a star, but he was gone. I thought there was really good value with corners in the later rounds(specifically Chekwa/Davon House/Johnny Patrick.. even Richard Sherman) so I don't think Prince was worth a 7th pick. Unfortunately we chose Culliver in the 3rd.
May 4, 2011 at 12:20 PM
- OldJoe
- Veteran
- Posts: 885
Originally posted by BrianGO:
Everyone has different opinions on how good a player is, and how well he fits on a team, but when you look at what we got, we had a nearly ideal draft.
1st -- We address the pass rush, something we have been lacking on the outside since the mid-90's. We didn't like the quarterbacks here, and we couldn't trade down.
2nd -- We get an historically talented college quarterback that Harbaugh likes. We had to move up and get our guy, it would be insane to risk losing the guy who Harbaugh thinks can restore the 49ers franchise.
3rd -- We get a physical, extremely athletic DB who also addresses our needs as a punt returner. If he is just OK at nickel, but above average as a punt returner, he is well worth the 80th pick; but his athletic upside leaves plenty of room for more.
4th -- We get our change of pace back. Too much talent to pass on him at this spot.
5th -- We address the guard position, giving some competition for Rachal, and for the uncertainty at center.
6th -- We get a WR who runs routes and catches the ball, a player who is intimately known by our WR coach. Most flash is trash at WR. We needed this kind of reliability and depth from the position.
After this we go for special teams and more depth.
The arguments about how good the players are, go on forever; but there is no doubt that we addressed needs at nearly the ideal place in each round. The first 6 picks all have a very good shot at not only making the team, but filling in at crucial times next season.
As far as long term is concerned, Colin Kaepernick (and to a lesser extent, Aldon Smith) will decide this draft, not guys like Colin Jones or Bruce Miller. Harbaugh believes he can get the best out of one of the most statistically and physically impressive college quarterbacks of all-time. His track record, gets me very excited about his chances.
Grading how good the draft is, comes years later. Grading for the types of players we needed, at the places we needed them. This draft is an A+.
Took a nice stab at addressing our needs
May 4, 2011 at 12:26 PM
- OldJoe
- Veteran
- Posts: 885
We often use Bill Walsh as the standard to judge NFL talent. But we forget why he was great. Not that he got every player right, but when he was right he was right.
Look how many RBs he drafted until he got Roger Craig (two are todays first rounders)
yr rnd pck# player pos
1979 2 29 James Owens RB
1979 5 119 Jerry Aldridge RB
1979 7 166 Phil Francis RB
1980 1 13 Earl Cooper RB
1981 5 139 Newton Williams RB
1981 6 151 Vince Williams RB
1982 2 49 Roger Craig RB
or the entire 1979 draft - exclude Joe Montana and Dwight Clark and you have a complete whiff. But just Montana made it a super draft.
Look how many RBs he drafted until he got Roger Craig (two are todays first rounders)
yr rnd pck# player pos
1979 2 29 James Owens RB
1979 5 119 Jerry Aldridge RB
1979 7 166 Phil Francis RB
1980 1 13 Earl Cooper RB
1981 5 139 Newton Williams RB
1981 6 151 Vince Williams RB
1982 2 49 Roger Craig RB
or the entire 1979 draft - exclude Joe Montana and Dwight Clark and you have a complete whiff. But just Montana made it a super draft.
May 4, 2011 at 12:38 PM
- WildBill
- Veteran
- Posts: 6,241
Originally posted by OldJoe:
We often use Bill Walsh as the standard to judge NFL talent. But we forget why he was great. Not that he got every player right, but when he was right he was right.
Look how many RBs he drafted until he got Roger Craig (two are todays first rounders)
yr rnd pck# player pos
1979 2 29 James Owens RB
1979 5 119 Jerry Aldridge RB
1979 7 166 Phil Francis RB
1980 1 13 Earl Cooper RB
1981 5 139 Newton Williams RB
1981 6 151 Vince Williams RB
1982 2 49 Roger Craig RB
or the entire 1979 draft - exclude Joe Montana and Dwight Clark and you have a complete whiff. But just Montana made it a super draft.
Cooper wan't great but served his purpose. Technically all you need to hit on is one or two in your coaching career.
May 4, 2011 at 12:41 PM
- Hitman49
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,040
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
May 4, 2011 at 12:49 PM
- oldninerdude
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,330
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
1-A-49ers have needed a pass-rusher for the longest time, this guy just on potential seems like a major beast.
2-A-QB of the future that Harbaugh feels comfortable molding and it didn't cost them a lot.
3-B-This guy seems like a great prospect but he's really raw for the third round although a lot of publications had him going in that range. Very athletic, can be developed into either a starting safety or CB. Seeing as how our track record has been in the 3rd round, I don't feel bad about the 49ers giving this guy a shot if they think he can be a starter down the road.
4-A-Love the pick, kind of a steal, perfect young change-of-pace back to mix in with Gore, he's got great vision and is ready to go from Day One.
5-B-Like the attitude, for too long this team has been about as intimidating as the Care Bears and by all accounts Kilgore is a bad, bad man. Very raw, but also has lots of room to develop and has the right attitude and desire to improve, I have no problem with them giving up a late 7th round pick to get the guy they wanted.
6-B-Love the Colin Jones pick, he looks like a future special teams ace, an athletic freak that will be a terror out on the field. Like a faster Curtis Buckley. As far as Johnson, he's had issues with drops but he's a talented WR that can stretch the field, is willing to go over the middle, Harbaugh's obviously familiar with him so I see this as a value pick.
7-A-Love both picks a lot, if Miller sticks as an OLB he could very well become a valuable part of the rotation, if not, he's still going to be a special teams terror. Like the Person pick, by all accounts he's a solid OL prospect with room to develop, good value for where he was picked. Don't know much about Holcomb but he sounds just like the rest, raw, hard worker, coachable...etc, could be a good special teams addition if nothing else.




Totally agree, both on the previous marshmellow soft, complete lack of intimidation factor, and on the "Kilgore is a bad, bad man" point you make.
Good post.
Go Niners.
May 4, 2011 at 12:54 PM
- oldninerdude
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,330
Originally posted by Hitman49:
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
Isn't Culliver really pretty much a clone of Patrick Peterson--similar size and athletic ability, but without the big school experience and media attention.
Not saying they're identical, but physically, athletically similar, and if Culliver can get coached up, maybe he's a diamond in the rough.
Speed kills.
Go Niners.
[ Edited by oldninerdude on May 4, 2011 at 12:56:05 ]
May 4, 2011 at 1:11 PM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,608
Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by Hitman49:
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
Isn't Culliver really pretty much a clone of Patrick Peterson--similar size and athletic ability, but without the big school experience and media attention.
Not saying they're identical, but physically, athletically similar, and if Culliver can get coached up, maybe he's a diamond in the rough.
Speed kills.
Go Niners.
physically and athletically pretty close, its the technique and instincts that we have to figure out.
May 4, 2011 at 2:27 PM
- oldninerdude
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,330
Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by Hitman49:
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
Isn't Culliver really pretty much a clone of Patrick Peterson--similar size and athletic ability, but without the big school experience and media attention.
Not saying they're identical, but physically, athletically similar, and if Culliver can get coached up, maybe he's a diamond in the rough.
Speed kills.
Go Niners.
physically and athletically pretty close, its the technique and instincts that we have to figure out.
The technique he'll get from the coaches.
The instincts--well, we'll see. But he's got the athletic ability (which as you say, cannot be coached), and the team must believe he's got the competitive drive, . . .
What's not to like?

Go Niners.
May 4, 2011 at 6:26 PM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,608
Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by Hitman49:
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
Isn't Culliver really pretty much a clone of Patrick Peterson--similar size and athletic ability, but without the big school experience and media attention.
Not saying they're identical, but physically, athletically similar, and if Culliver can get coached up, maybe he's a diamond in the rough.
Speed kills.
Go Niners.
physically and athletically pretty close, its the technique and instincts that we have to figure out.
The technique he'll get from the coaches.
The instincts--well, we'll see. But he's got the athletic ability (which as you say, cannot be coached), and the team must believe he's got the competitive drive, . . .
What's not to like?
Go Niners.
if he can take over for T Brown then I'm for it
May 4, 2011 at 9:43 PM
- wysiwyg
- Veteran
- Posts: 16,424
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
1-A-49ers have needed a pass-rusher for the longest time, this guy just on potential seems like a major beast.
2-A-QB of the future that Harbaugh feels comfortable molding and it didn't cost them a lot.
3-B-This guy seems like a great prospect but he's really raw for the third round although a lot of publications had him going in that range. Very athletic, can be developed into either a starting safety or CB. Seeing as how our track record has been in the 3rd round, I don't feel bad about the 49ers giving this guy a shot if they think he can be a starter down the road.
4-A-Love the pick, kind of a steal, perfect young change-of-pace back to mix in with Gore, he's got great vision and is ready to go from Day One.
5-B-Like the attitude, for too long this team has been about as intimidating as the Care Bears and by all accounts Kilgore is a bad, bad man. Very raw, but also has lots of room to develop and has the right attitude and desire to improve, I have no problem with them giving up a late 7th round pick to get the guy they wanted.
6-B-Love the Colin Jones pick, he looks like a future special teams ace, an athletic freak that will be a terror out on the field. Like a faster Curtis Buckley. As far as Johnson, he's had issues with drops but he's a talented WR that can stretch the field, is willing to go over the middle, Harbaugh's obviously familiar with him so I see this as a value pick.
7-A-Love both picks a lot, if Miller sticks as an OLB he could very well become a valuable part of the rotation, if not, he's still going to be a special teams terror. Like the Person pick, by all accounts he's a solid OL prospect with room to develop, good value for where he was picked. Don't know much about Holcomb but he sounds just like the rest, raw, hard worker, coachable...etc, could be a good special teams addition if nothing else.
Mr. Dilfer, is that you?
Lol, j/k
May 6, 2011 at 12:10 AM
- nw9erfan
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,497
Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by oldninerdude:Originally posted by Hitman49:
I don't know much about Culliver but I like the pick. The guy has speed, and that was a big weakness in the secondary. And u know what they say "you can't teach speed"
Isn't Culliver really pretty much a clone of Patrick Peterson--similar size and athletic ability, but without the big school experience and media attention.
Not saying they're identical, but physically, athletically similar, and if Culliver can get coached up, maybe he's a diamond in the rough.
Speed kills.
Go Niners.
physically and athletically pretty close, its the technique and instincts that we have to figure out.
The technique he'll get from the coaches.
The instincts--well, we'll see. But he's got the athletic ability (which as you say, cannot be coached), and the team must believe he's got the competitive drive, . . .
What's not to like?
Go Niners.
if he can take over for T Brown then I'm for it
I think the thing that many of you are missing is this....Culliver was the second ranked safety prospect in the draft. He was an excellent college safety before his coaching staff at South Carolina moved him to CB his senior year, where he played just 7 games.
Yes, the Niners think they can coach him up so he can play CB. If so, great. If not, then they have a starting FS for years to come....faster and with a much higher ceiling than Goldson.
Obviously, if the Niners liked him in the third round, they must have been pretty high on the guy and thought he wouldn't be on the board much longer. Many teams had him ranked as a third round talent or thereabouts (and Maddog had him ranked exactly where the Niners ended up picking him...pick number 80).
The larger point is this. Safety was and still is a big need on this team. R Smith, Mays, and even Goldson are not solid players yet....and may never be. That entire secondary was disastrous last year so they needed faster, better players. At the very least, Culliver can be an effective starting safety in the NFL so I'm quite cool with the pick.
Did they need a CB more than a FS? Probably. But they got someone who can help...in the short term and the long term. I give the pick a solid B grade.