Results: My Composite vs. OTC's Mock vs. Maddog's Mock; Post #18

Paul_Hofer · 2011-04-27T07:16:44-07:00

This Big Board of 254 is a composite of 27 mocks (including those of the Webzone’s own Oldman, OTC, Maddog and AB83) that are available online without subscription. A player had to be selected at least 12 times to make the list. Because it is an averaging of mock drafts, it is more of a Big Board than a mock itself. From the composite, I made my predictions for the Niners’ picks. Bolded numbers are where the Niners pick; bolded names are my suggested selections where the composite placed them. If you aren’t familiar with a player or wish to take issue, blurbs on my selections (including one trade—which is why there are only 11 bolded names) follow below. This strategy helped me pick three of the Niners' pick from last year, tying me with Ninertico. 1 Patrick Peterson CB 2 Marcell Dareus DE 3 Von Miller DE 4 A.J. Green WR 5 Cam Newton QB 6 Blaine Gabbert QB 7 Robert Quinn DE 8 Julio Jones WR 9 Nick Fairley DT 10 Prince Amukamara CB 11 Da'Quan Bowers DE 12 Tyron Smith T 13 Cameron Jordan DE 14 Aldon Smith DE 15 J.J. Watt DE 16 Anthony Castonzo T 17 Ryan Kerrigan DE 18 Gabe Carimi T 19 Mark Ingram RB 20 Mike Pouncey G 21 Corey Liuget DT 22 Jake Locker QB 23 Derek Sherrod T 24 Jimmy Smith CB 25 Cameron Heyward DE 26 Nate Solder T 27 Adrian Clayborn DE 28 Phil Taylor DT 29 Muhammad Wilkerson DT 30 Akeem Ayers OLB 31 Brooks Reed OLB 32 Brandon Harris CB 33 Ryan Mallett QB 34 Justin Houston OLB 35 Christian Ponder QB 36 Stephen Paea DT 37 Kyle Rudolph TE 38 Aaron Williams CB 39 Martez Wilson ILB 40 Andy Dalton QB 41 Torrey Smith WR 42 Mikel Leshoure RB 43 Danny Watkins G 44 Rahim Moore FS 45 Marvin Austin DT 46 Leonard Hankerson WR 47 Jabaal Sheard DE 48 Benjamin Ijalana T/G 49 Jonathan Baldwin WR 50 Ryan Williams RB 51 Colin Kaepernick QB 52 Stefen Wisniewski C 53 Christian Ballard DT 54 Davon House CB 55 Marcus Cannon T/G 56 Randall Cobb WR 57 Drake Nevis DT 58 Rodney Hudson G/C 59 Ras-I Dowling CB 60 Titus Young WR 61 Curtis Brown CB 62 Bruce Carter OLB 63 Mason Foster LB 64 Allen Bailey DE 65 Sam Acho DE 66 Jerrel Jernigan WR 67 Quan Sturdivant ILB 68 James Carpenter T 69 Brandon Burton CB 70 Dontay Moch OLB 71 Kenrick Ellis DT 72 Clint Boling T/G 73 DeAndre McDaniel SS 74 Orlando Franklin T/G 75 Jarvis Jenkins DT 76 Quinton Carter FS 77 Jurrell Casey DT 78 Greg Little WR 79 DeMarco Murray RB 80 Jordan Todman RB 81 Ricky Stanzi QB 82 Luke Stocker TE 83 Johnny Patrick CB 84 Daniel Thomas RB 85 Kendall Hunter RB 86 Chris Carter OLB 87 Jason Pinkston T 88 Edmund Gates WR 89 Kelvin Sheppard ILB 90 Greg Jones ILB 91 James Brewer T 92 Marcus Gilbert T/G 93 Chimdi Chekwa CB 94 D.J. Williams TE 95 Will Rackley G 96 Tyler Sash SS 97 Shane Vereen RB 98 Marcus Gilchrist CB 99 Curtis Marsh CB 100 Lance Kendricks TE 101 Taiwan Jones RB 102 Colin McCarthy LB 103 Jerrell Powe DT 104 Tandon Doss WR 105 Lawrence Guy DT 106 John Moffitt G 107 K.J. Wright ILB 108 Shareece Wright CB 109 Robert Sands FS 110 Casey Matthews ILB 111 Austin Pettis WR 112 Jalil Brown CB 113 Rashad Carmichael CB 114 Buster Skrine CB 115 Lawrence Wilson OLB 116 Greg Romeus OLB 117 Sione Fua DT 118 Deunta Williams FS 119 Nate Irving ILB 120 Jordan Cameron TE 121 Virgil Green TE 122 Jacquizz Rodgers RB 123 Jaiquawn Jarrett FS 124 Ahmad Black SS 125 Terrell McClain DT 126 Pernell McPhee DE 127 DeMarcus Love T 128 Chris Culliver CB 129 Niles Paul WR 130 Kris O'Dowd C 131 Stephen Schilling G 132 Vincent Brown WR 133 Joseph Barksdale T 134 Lee Ziemba OT 135 Brandon Fusco C 136 Greg McElroy QB 137 Chris Conte FS 138 Terrance Toliver WR 139 Delone Carter RB 140 Kendric Burney CB 141 Greg Salas WR 142 Mark Herzlich OLB 143 Ian Williams DT 144 Ronald Johnson WR 145 Rob Housler TE 146 Ross Homan ILB 147 Ricky Elmore DE 148 Derrick Locke RB 149 Jeremy Beal DE 150 Jamie Harper RB 151 Jeron Johnson CB/S 152 Owen Marecic FB 153 Tim Barnes C 154 DeMarcus Van Dyke CB 155 Chris Hairston T 156 Pierre Allen DE 157 Ugo Chinasa OLB 158 Chykie Brown CB 159 Denarius Moore WR 160 Jah Reid T 161 Martin Parker DT 162 Derek Newton T 163 Julius Thomas TE 164 Roy Helu RB 165 Brandon Hogan CB 166 Cortez Allen CB 167 Jake Kirkpatrick C 168 Pat Devlin QB 169 Jeremy Kerley WR 170 Joe Lefeged S 171 Cliff Matthews OLB 172 Da'Norris Searcy S 173 Justin Rogers LB 174 Cedric Thornton DT 175 Bruce Miller OLB 176 Stanley Havili FB 177 Alex Henery K 178 Dion Lewis RB 179 Bilal Powell RB 180 Korey Lindsey CB 181 Dwayne Harris WR 182 Jerrard Tarrant FS 183 Shiloh Keo SS 184 Steven Friday OLB 185 Cecil Shorts WR 186 Brian Rolle LB 187 Doug Hogue OLB 188 Chris Rucker CB 189 Zach Hurd T/G 190 Stephen Burton WR 191 Da'Rel Scott RB 192 Mario Harvey ILB 193 Charles Clay FB/TE 194 Richard Sherman CB 195 Derek Hall T 196 Mike Mohamed ILB 197 Stevan Ridley RB 198 Will Hill FS 199 DeAndre Brown WR 200 Jarriel King T 201 David Arkin G 202 Alex Green RB 203 Thomas Keiser OLB 204 Chris Neild NT 205 Justin Boren G 206 Ryan Jones CB 207 Ricardo Lockette WR 208 Josh Bynes ILB 209 Andrew Jackson G 210 Mario Fannin RB 211 Brandon Bair DE 212 Tyrod Taylor QB 213 David Carter DT 214 Byron Stingily T 215 Willie Smith T 216 Jonas Mouton OLB 217 Henry Hynoski FB 218 Scott Lutrus OLB 219 Keith Williams G 220 Josh Thomas CB 221 Nathan Enderle QB 222 Chris White ILB 223 Adrian Moten LB 224 Jermale Hines FS 225 Andre Smith TE 226 Jeff Maehl WR 227 Jason Kelce C 228 Tori Gurley WR 229 Anthony Allen RB 230 Lee Smith TE 231 Aldrick Robinson WR 232 Mark LeGree FS 233 Alex Linnenkohl C 234 Dane Sanzenbacher WR 235 Zane Taylor C 236 Anthony Gray DT 237 Kai Forbath K 238 Charlie Gantt TE 239 Ryan Whalen WR 240 Markus White OLB 241 Noel Devine RB 242 T.J. Yates QB 243 Darvin Adams WR 244 Nate Williams S 245 Mike McNeill S 246 Byron Maxwell CB 247 Eric Hagg CB/S 248 Ryan Winterswyk DE 249 Schuylar Oordt TE 250 Anthony Gaitor CB 251 Chas Henry P 252 Darren Evans RB 253 Armon Binns WR 254 Ryan Bartholomew C Niners Selection Name, position, pick no., round, trade chart points Robert Quinn OLB 7 R1 1500 Davon House CB 45 R2 450 Ricky Stanzi QB 76 R3 210 Sione Fua NT 108 R4-4 78 Jacquizz Rodgers RB 115 R4-5 64 Owen Marecic FB 141 R5-6 35.5 Rob Housler TE (trade up: between #134-#144) 174 R6-7 22.8 190 R6-8 16.4 Tyrod Taylor QB 211 R7-9 8.4 Alex Linnenkohl C 231 R7-10 2.4 Kai Forbath K 239 R7-11 comp Byron Maxwell CB 250 R7-12 comp Robert Quinn, OLB, 6'4, 265 Cornerbacks (and QBs) will be easier than OLBs to find in free agency. Also, the Niners have not addressed this position for too long. Baalke and college scouting director Joel Patten were present at his Pro Day. According to his school, Quinn recorded 4.57 seconds on his 40-yard dash, 24 reps of 225 pounds, 33-inch vertical leap and a long jump of 10 feet, 51/2 inches. According to Rob Rang, NFLDraftScout.com, Quinn has rare explosion and is still learning and improving with his strength, weight (can add up to 15 lbs) and snap timing. Davon House, CB, 6’0 ½ , 190 House ran a 4.35 40-yard dash at his Pro Day. A native of Palmdale, CA, he ended his NM State career ranked 6th all-time in interceptions with 11 and first in interception return yardage with 319. He returned 3 interceptions for TDs, tallied 198 tackles, 46 pass break ups and three fumble recoveries. Best asset is man coverage. Three-year starter, four years of college experience, never missed a game. Ricky Stanzi, QB, 6-4, 223 Nobody outside of 4949 Centennial Blvd. knows which QB the Niners are targeting. But Stanzi fits the athletic model Harbaugh has described. “Stanzi is like a lot of the underrated players: better on tape than he's been in workouts. He has ideal size and has made consistent improvement throughout his career. Stanzi could prove quite the steal in the middle rounds.” - Rob Rang. Mature leader whose experience (4 years) is second only to Locker. 2010: 25 touchdowns, 6 interceptions, 64.1% accuracy, 3,004 yards. His only negatives could be due to faulty mechanics that Harbaugh could correct. Sione Fua, NT, 6’2, 308 Bull rusher who jolts the offensive lineman and gets leverage early. Has a low firing point and possesses the leg strength to drive blockers into the backfield. Sits into stance and anchors well against double-teams while maintaining the balance and body control to shed inside blocks. Clogs two gaps, keeps his base under him and stays off the ground. Has experience playing the nose in a 3-4 front. Plays with a high motor and relentlessly fights to hold his ground. Jacquizz Rodgers, RB, 5’6 ¾, 192 Jacquizz Rodgers sliced his time in the 40-yard dash from an electronically-timed 4.74 at the Combine to 4.47 at his Pro Day, according to his university's website. While Harbaugh favors big backs, he already has Gore and Dixon. Rodgers is sixth in Pac-10 history in rushing, 3,877 yards. He scored 46 rushing touchdowns. Rodgers is also Oregon State’s career leader in receptions by a running back with 151 and is third with 306 points scored in his career. Could be the Niners’ third or fourth receiver. Rob Housler, TE, 6’6, 249 I propose the Niners trade their sixth round picks (39 points) to a pick between #134 and #144 for Rob Housler. One need only look at Stanford’s 4 TEs each at 6’6 to know Harbaugh’s tendencies at TE. At the Combine, Housler was the fastest TE (4:46). This places him ahead of WRs such as A.J. Green (4:48), even with Randall Cobb and nearly on a par with Denarious Moore and Titus Young (4:43). According to CBS Sports.com, he has better upper-body strength than his frame suggests and does a nice job of gaining a quick release from the line. Has the speed to challenge the seam and shows crisp footwork and good balance as a route-runner. Understands where the holes are against zone coverage and presents a good target to the quarterback. Reliable hands. Can extend and pluck the ball out of the air. Shows some elusiveness after the catch. Blocks with good effort and his technique is well-schooled. Rare maturity. Imagine what Harbaugh could do with VD, Delainie and Housler in disguising the run vs. pass. Owen Marecic, FB, 6’1, 248 Pronunciation: Muh Ree’ sick. Already knows Harbaugh’s offense. Harbaugh knows him—well enough to start him on offense and defense. Lead blocker who helped open holes that sprung Toby Gerhart to a single-season Stanford rushing record of 1,136 yards. Marecic had 5 career rushing TDs. Had only 9 receptions but for an impressive 75 yards. He could catch passes when needed but Harbaugh’s power WCO apparently doesn’t require that of the FB. Marecic should easily replace Norris as starting FB. Should lead on special teams. Tyrod Taylor, QB, 6’1, 216 Fastest QB (4:47). Three-year starter and an athletic dual-threat quarterback prospect who can make big plays with his arm and legs. According to CBS Sports.com, Taylor demonstrates good accuracy and decent arm strength when using proper footwork. Had an outstanding 24-5 TD/INT ratio as a senior, when his ability to read defenses improved vastly. Very fast and elusive. He will reward a creative NFL team as a special team/role player who can spice up a wildcat as a rookie and beyond. Has the athletic ability to be projected as a running back or wide receiver. Alex Linnenkohl, C, 6’2, 304 IMO, Niners want to bolster the center position more than guard. Rachal needs to compete with a vet guard secured through free agency. A rookie at RG alongside Anthony Dixon is not what the team needs. Also, Heitmann’s condition is tenuous. According to CBS Sports.com, Linnenkohl is a sturdy pivot man whose low center of gravity aids him in leverage. Does not get moved off the spot by bull rushers very often. Extends arms immediately after snap in pass pro, maintains distance from defender. Strong help for guards when uncovered, extends arms to get push when tackle's shoulders are turned. Has some mobility to get in front of screens. Coaches laud him for his strong character, toughness, leadership, and work ethic. Plays through pain. Kai Forbath, K, 5’11, 197 Competition for aging Nedney. injured the last two seasons. According to CBS Sports.com, Forbath gets power by taking an aggressive swipe at the ball. Gets plenty of height on kicks, even from 40-plus yards out. Solid 52-55 yard range. Equally dangerous from either hash mark, as well as down the middle. Mentally strong, does not let the pressure eat him up; kicked 51-yard game-winner against Oregon State in 2010 after missing from 46 and 49 yards earlier. Could dwell on Practice Squad as Nedney-insurance. Byron Maxwell, CB, 6’0, 202 According to CBS Sports.com, Maxwell has great length and bulk for the position and possesses above-average speed (4:43). Is aggressive when taking on blocks and has no trouble shedding blocks before finding the ball-carrier. Wraps up and makes sure tackles using his length. Has strong natural instincts and reads passers well in zone coverage. Attacks the ball at its highest point, wins jump balls and catches with soft hands. Physical at the line, uses his length and strength to reroute receivers off the line in press coverage. UDFA: Adam Froman, QB (if not available, Scott Loukas, QB); Brett Brackett, TE; David Ausberry, FB; Johnny Culbreath T; Greg Lloyd, ILB; Evan Royster, RB, Lester Jean, WR; Sealver Siliaga, DT. [ Edited by Paul_Hofer on May 1, 2011 at 12:10:45 ]

Apr 27, 2011 at 8:33 AM

ninertico
Veteran
Posts: 10,259

However, I'm takin' it this time!

lol

Very nicely done sir.

Very, very similar to mine...

RD1 7 SF Quinn, DE/OLB, North Carolina
RD 2 45 SF Ras-I Dowling, CB, Virginia
RD 3 76 SF Ricky Stanzi, QB, Iowa
Rd 4 108 SF Shane Vereen, RB Cal
RD 4 115 SF Sione Fua, NT Stanford
RD 5 141 SF Owen Marecic, FB, Stanford
RD 6 174 SF David Carter, DT/DE, UCLA
RD 6 190 SF Jake Kirkpatrick, C, TCU
RD 7 211 SF Andrew Jackson, OG, Fresno State
RD 7 231 SF Zach Pianalto, TE, North Carolina
RD 7 239 SF Aldrick Robinson, WR, SMU
RD 7 250 SF Kai Forbath, K, UCLA

Great minds...

Apr 27, 2011 at 9:28 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Originally posted by ninertico:
However, I'm takin' it this time! lol

Very nicely done sir.

Very, very similar to mine...

RD1 7 SF Quinn, DE/OLB, North Carolina
RD 2 45 SF Ras-I Dowling, CB, Virginia
RD 3 76 SF Ricky Stanzi, QB, Iowa
Rd 4 108 SF Shane Vereen, RB Cal
RD 4 115 SF Sione Fua, NT Stanford
RD 5 141 SF Owen Marecic, FB, Stanford
RD 6 174 SF David Carter, DT/DE, UCLA
RD 6 190 SF Jake Kirkpatrick, C, TCU
RD 7 211 SF Andrew Jackson, OG, Fresno State
RD 7 231 SF Zach Pianalto, TE, North Carolina
RD 7 239 SF Aldrick Robinson, WR, SMU
RD 7 250 SF Kai Forbath, K, UCLA

Great minds...

Hi Tico,
It will be your Dowling vs. my House; your Vareen vs. my Jacquizz; your Kirkpatrick vs. my Linnenkohl; your Pianalto vs. my Housler. I say po-tay-toe, you say po-tah-toe. Fun.

In the words of our most recent ex-President: Bring it on.

[ Edited by Paul_Hofer on Apr 27, 2011 at 11:00:51 ]

Apr 28, 2011 at 4:58 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Byron Maxwell
7th Round, #250

Apr 28, 2011 at 5:04 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Kai Forbath
7th Round, #239

Apr 28, 2011 at 5:14 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Alex Linnenkohl
7th Round, #231

Apr 28, 2011 at 5:21 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Tyrod Taylor
7th Round, #211

Apr 28, 2011 at 5:58 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Owen Marecic
5th Round, #45

Apr 28, 2011 at 6:08 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Rob Housler
Trade, #134-#144

Apr 28, 2011 at 6:17 AM

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Jacquizz Rodgers
4th Round, #115

Apr 28, 2011 at 6:58 AM

#10

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Ricky Stanzi
3rd Round, #76

Apr 28, 2011 at 7:23 AM

#11

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Davon House
2nd Round, #45

Apr 28, 2011 at 12:37 PM

#12

MadDog49er
Hall of Fame
Posts: 19,400

Very impressive bit of work, and I'm sure a ton of time invested.

I'm not sure the team is really interested in Quinn, but maybe they think he can be a terrific 3-4 OLB. He's one of the big boom and bust players in this draft.

In the end, I think Prince is going to be the pick at 7, but in this wild and wacky year, anything is possible.

I think the board would generally be pleased if the team drafted the players listed in this composite mock.

Apr 28, 2011 at 12:44 PM

#13

lamontb
Veteran
Posts: 33,579

Nice work homie but no way is Rob Housler gonna be there. I think he's gone by the 3rd round.

Apr 28, 2011 at 4:18 PM

#14

Paul_Hofer
Veteran
Posts: 4,089

Robert Quinn
1st Round, #7