YOU are on the clock... (2011 version)

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Two RB's for us in the draft? Interesting...

Niners draft grade so far is a D- to me. Too many questions about the players taken.

Care to elaborate?

1. Quinn
2. Ryan Williams
3. Stanzi
4a. Shareece Wright CB
4b. Austin Pettis WR

Everyone has their own set of guys they love and hate. But we didn't reach on any of these guys, and I would label all of them positions of need. Are you giving it a D- just because we missed on Ponder?

I think we passed on too many other good players, as you said they may just be my guys, but 2 running backs (we changed that one out) and a slow possession receiver don't rate highly on my needs. Quinn really is a prospect that says boom or bust to me.

1. Quinn = too high at 7, Vernon Gholston?, his potential is there but too many ?'s
2. Ryan Williams = decent back but not a need with Gore, won't see field much
3. Stanzi = looks like an average backup, we need a starter with upside
4a. Shareece Wright CB = best pick but has not shown much to evaluate
4b. Austin Pettis WR = a big slow WR is not what this offense needs
5. Ian Williams is a nice pick.

[ Edited by ChaunceyGardner on Feb 12, 2011 at 09:18:33 ]

St Louis Rams select Stephen Schilling G Michigan.

Miami Dolphins select SS Joe Lefeged, Rutgers.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Two RB's for us in the draft? Interesting...

Niners draft grade so far is a D- to me. Too many questions about the players taken.

Care to elaborate?

1. Quinn
2. Ryan Williams
3. Stanzi
4a. Shareece Wright CB
4b. Austin Pettis WR

Everyone has their own set of guys they love and hate. But we didn't reach on any of these guys, and I would label all of them positions of need. Are you giving it a D- just because we missed on Ponder?

No b/c we should have picked QB or CB in the 2nd, not a f**king RB. And I know you're gonna defend that pick because it was yours, but you know that RB isn't as high a need as CB.

So I wasn't right in saying it was all cuz we passed on Ponder in the 2nd?

Did I say it was because of Ponder? Nope. All I said was that a QB and a CB is a bigger need for this team than a RB. that is a fact.

I wonder who take seahawks,rams,cards

Jacksonville Jaguars select CB Korey Lindsey from Southern Illinois.

Raiders select OT Marcus Gilbert from Florida

Philadelphia Eagles select Roy Helu RB from Nebraska.

[ Edited by ChaunceyGardner on Feb 12, 2011 at 18:42:09 ]

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Two RB's for us in the draft? Interesting...

Niners draft grade so far is a D- to me. Too many questions about the players taken.

Care to elaborate?

1. Quinn
2. Ryan Williams
3. Stanzi
4a. Shareece Wright CB
4b. Austin Pettis WR

Everyone has their own set of guys they love and hate. But we didn't reach on any of these guys, and I would label all of them positions of need. Are you giving it a D- just because we missed on Ponder?

No b/c we should have picked QB or CB in the 2nd, not a f**king RB. And I know you're gonna defend that pick because it was yours, but you know that RB isn't as high a need as CB.

So I wasn't right in saying it was all cuz we passed on Ponder in the 2nd?

Did I say it was because of Ponder? Nope. All I said was that a QB and a CB is a bigger need for this team than a RB. that is a fact.

Actually it's an opinion.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Two RB's for us in the draft? Interesting...

Niners draft grade so far is a D- to me. Too many questions about the players taken.

Care to elaborate?

1. Quinn
2. Ryan Williams
3. Stanzi
4a. Shareece Wright CB
4b. Austin Pettis WR

Everyone has their own set of guys they love and hate. But we didn't reach on any of these guys, and I would label all of them positions of need. Are you giving it a D- just because we missed on Ponder?

No b/c we should have picked QB or CB in the 2nd, not a f**king RB. And I know you're gonna defend that pick because it was yours, but you know that RB isn't as high a need as CB.

So I wasn't right in saying it was all cuz we passed on Ponder in the 2nd?

Did I say it was because of Ponder? Nope. All I said was that a QB and a CB is a bigger need for this team than a RB. that is a fact.

Actually it's an opinion.

Ryan Williams, RB, Virginia Tech: There is a lot I like about Williams. In fact, there are elements to his game that I believe translate better to the NFL than Illinois' Mikel LeShoure, who I rated as the 33rd best prospect. However, the struggles with durability concern me as Williams is 5-11, 205 pounds. In a class with as much middle round talent at RB as this one, I believe it drops the value of good, but not special backs like Williams.

Rob Rang Most Hyped 5

Not to bash really but I think this supports the argument that better value is available in other positions and players at the Niners 2nd round pick. Not really the player or picking him as much as when he was taken in the draft.

Minnesota Vikings select....Casey Matthews

Originally posted by HERN:
Minnesota Vikings select....Casey Matthews

Taken...

132. Tampa Bay - from Denver (4-12): Casey Matthews, ILB, Oregon (by: Bay_Area_Fan)

All available:

Henry Hynoski FB
Delone Carter RB
Jacquizz Rogers RB
Pierre Allen DE
Owen Marecic FB
Bilal Powell RB
Stanley Havili FB
Josh Bynes ILB
Chris Carter OLB
Taiwan Jones RB
Ross Homan OLB
Andre Smith TE
Noel Devine RB
Greg Salas WR
Chris Conte FS
Dwayne Harris WR
Cameron Graham TE
Chykie Brown CB
Ricky Elmore DE
John Clay RB
Jake Kirkpatrick  C
Greg McElroy QB
Jordan Cameron TE
Mario Butler CB
Will Hill FS
David Carter DT
Brandon Bair DE
Rob Housler TE
Jermale Hines FS
Zach Hurd G
Justin Rogers CB
Darvin Adams WR
Charles Brown CB
Julius Thomas TE
Nate Williams SS
Mike Mohamed ILB
Alex Henery K
DeAndre Brown WR
Ugo Chinasa DE
Cedric Thornton DT
Chris Hairston OT
Virgil Green TE
Tori Gurley WR
TJ Yates QB

Nice list of available players!

Minnesota Vikings still on the clock.

Vikings take Zach Hurd / G / UCONN