Geek's Semi-Final Mock Plan (#BrickbyBrick)

GEEK · 2017-04-02T21:01:04-07:00

No, we don't get Myles Garrett, the consensus #1 pick of the draft. Here's my take on the #brickbybrick approach of the draft based on some common themes: - 49ers aggressively look to trade in the draft. Adam Peters and Martin Meyhew both worked for franchises that traded frequently in the draft. Meyhew liked to trade back up in the 1st round. I don't think we go to that degree, but we follow a similar strategy. - They have their eyes on certain prospects, and they trade around in order to get the right value for their targets. - They do not aggressively go after QBs early. They mean what they say and let Hoyer start, but they look to add talent at the position on day 2. -- Trade #1: 49ers trade #2 overall for Jaguars #4 and #36 picks. The Panthers rumors really heat up on the eve of the draft, and Coughlin pulls the trigger on the trade to snag their RB of the future in Fournette. 49ers take a value hit with this trade, but it makes sense. Trade #2: 49ers trade #4 overall for the Browns #12 and #33 picks. The Titans are fielding calls to trade down and demand a lot of compensation for teams to leapfrog the Jets. Browns, Jets, Bills, and Chargers are all options for QB to trade up, and ironically they are all AFC teams. We offer the Browns a steal by letting them pay near the draft value chart for a QB, and we continue to stockpile picks. Round 1: Christian McCaffrey - RB/WR - Stanford (via CLE thru PHI) | Lynch's mantra has been adding true pure football players. McCaffrey's ability to play RB, WR, and return duties allow him to immediately see the field on day 1. A formation of Garcon-Goodwin-Kerley-Robinson with McCaffrey rolling out will create so many mismatches to exploit. Plus, he also has ability as a zone RB and #2 behind Hyde. Round 2: Takkarist McKinley - LEO - UCLA (via CLE) | 4.5 speed with 34 inch arms, McKinley has the attributes to be a solid LEO in our 4-3 under scheme. We badly need upgraded talent and McKinley delivers. Another in-state selection for Lynch. Additionally, he's got enough athletic ability to play the WILL position similar to Bruce Irvin or Cliff Avril type guys. Round 2: Jarrad Davis - LB - Florida | Goodbye Ahmad Brooks, hello Jarrad Davis. In normal drafts, he'd be a 1st round lock. However, the defensive talent in this draft pushes him to early 2nd territory. He can play the WILL, MIKE, and SAM positions, but he'll start at SAM. I also like him a security blanket to Bowman if he suffers another injury. Trade #3: 49ers trade #35 and #143 for Panthers #40 and #110. We basically trade down 5 spots and swap our comp #4 round pick for CAR's high 4th. Panthers trade up for Engram, adding an explosive weapon in their 2 WR, 2 TE sets. Engram can also flex as a WR, which is a need for them. Round 2: Kevin King - CB - Washington (via CAR) | I don't buy the hype that King is a first rounder. He's a tall press corner that's physical, but he's not a good scheme fit for every defense. With Ward moving to FS, CB depth becomes an issue. He'll compete with Robinson and Brock for playing time. Round 3: Nate Peterman - QB - Pitt | Some pundits compare him to Derek Carr. I compare him more to Cody Kessler. He's a smart game manager type QB with very good accuracy, pro style offense experience, and an average arm. He's a safe choice to develop as a top end backup with potential starter upside. Round 4: Carlos Watkins - DT - Clemson | Run stuffer x10. He's excellent depth and a guy that could replace Mitchell in 2-3 years. Round 4: Jordan Leggett - TE - Clemson (via CAR) | Back to back Clemson picks. HUGE upgrade to Celek at the #2 spot. He's a receiver, not a blocker. But we have McDonald, Paulsen, and Juszczyk as guys to block. Another chess piece for Shannahan to utilize on offense. Round 5: Aviante Collins - T/G - TCU | Athletic tackle ideal for a zone scheme. We start thinking of the succession plan for Joe Staley. Round 5: Jake Eldrenkamp - OG/C - Washington (via WAS) | Flex interior player that projects best in a zone scheme. Trade #4: 49ers trade 6th (via BAL) for Jaguars Allen Hurns - WR. Hurns production dropped in 2016 and he's fallen out of the graces of the organization. Round 7: Jeremy Clark - CB/S - Michigan (via CLE) | Redshirt in his first year, Clark has good size and strength for a safety conversion. With injury concerns to Reid and Ward, it's good to keep the pipeline going. 53 Man Depth Chart: QB: Hoyer*/Peterman*/Barkley* RB: Hyde/McCaffrey*/Hightower* FB: Juszczyk* TE: McDonald/Leggett*/Paulsen* WR: Garcon*/Hurns* WR: Goodwin*/Robinson* WR: Kerley/Smelter LT: Staley/Collins* LG: Kilgore/Beadles C: Zuttah*/Eldrenkamp* RG: Garnett RT: Brown/Theus 4-3 Under Formation: 5T: Buckner/Dial 0T: Mitchell*/Watkins* 3T: Armstead/Blair DE: Lynch/McKinley*/Harold LB: Davis*/Watson* LB: Bowman/Coyle* LB: Smith*/Armstrong CB: Brock/King*/Reaser CB: Robinson/Redmond/Williams FS: Ward/Jones* SS: Reid/Tartt 4-2-5 Formation (Passing Downs): DE: Lynch/Blair DT: Buckner/Dial/Watkins* DT: Armstead/Mitchell DE: McKinley*/Harold LB: Bowman/Armstrong/Watson* LB: Davis*/Smith*/Coyle* CB: Robinson/King* CB: Brock/Reaser CB: Williams*/Redmond FS: Ward/Jones* SS: Reid/Tartt ST: Gould*, Pinion, Nelson

Apr 2, 2017 at 11:20 PM

Shifty
Veteran
Posts: 23,429

Nice job man! If it played out like this I would be very very happy. I don't know about Jacksonville doing that trade but many crazier things have happened. If I was the Jags I wouldn't make that trade but if they feel Fournette is Adrian Peterson part II then it's very possible.

Apr 3, 2017 at 6:34 AM

kentc1978
Veteran
Posts: 297

I actually like the Allen Hurns trade. Pretty creative

Apr 3, 2017 at 12:51 PM

GEEK
Veteran
Posts: 19,412

Originally posted by Kalen49ers:
Nice job man! If it played out like this I would be very very happy. I don't know about Jacksonville doing that trade but many crazier things have happened. If I was the Jags I wouldn't make that trade but if they feel Fournette is Adrian Peterson part II then it's very possible.

Agreed. Mocking any trade is going to be a stretch, but we do know RB is a weak position for them, and they've been linked to Fournette for some time. That's why I think the 49ers-Panthers trade rumors are very real. McCaffrey is the 49ers prime target, and the 49ers want to aggressively trade down to get him at fair value + stock up on draft choices. On the flip side, Newton would immensely benefit with an enhanced running game. They also need a speedy weapon on the outside, but the draft has plenty of those prospects in the mid-rounds.

Apr 3, 2017 at 12:53 PM

GEEK
Veteran
Posts: 19,412

Originally posted by kentc1978:
I actually like the Allen Hurns trade. Pretty creative

Outside of Mike Williams, there isn't really a big body WR target I would draft. Michigan has two intriguing prospects that remind me a bit of Mohammed Sanu, but we already have possession receivers in Garcon and Kerley. We have the speedsters in Goodwin and Robinson. We have Smelter for the last roster spot (hope he pans out). And Hurns gives us that big body WR we need.

Apr 3, 2017 at 3:35 PM

tohara3
Veteran
Posts: 30,674

Jacksonville just signed Hurns to an extension last year & has yet to sign Allen Robinson to an extension yet so not sure if they would trade him

Apr 10, 2017 at 7:53 AM

m_brockalexander
Veteran
Posts: 13,376

If you're going to dream, dream big. This would be an amazing haul. Trades make sense if the Niners aren't overly concerned with the draft value chart and just look at the value of the players. Taking McCaffrey that early only works with the addition of another big WR which you get in Hurns. Would be very happy if things turn out this way.

Apr 10, 2017 at 9:12 AM

NCommand
Hall of Fame
Posts: 123,365

Originally posted by m_brockalexander:
If you're going to dream, dream big. This would be an amazing haul. Trades make sense if the Niners aren't overly concerned with the draft value chart and just look at the value of the players. Taking McCaffrey that early only works with the addition of another big WR which you get in Hurns. Would be very happy if things turn out this way.

Yeah, if we can go Bill Walsh on all these trades and come away with this, I'd be stoked. This is certainly the draft to take as many trade-backs as you can get as there is so much talent (esp. for our systems) from the 10th pick-6th round, it's insane.

Apr 11, 2017 at 8:18 AM

fan49
Veteran
Posts: 6,293

I dont get the TE pick at all. we have four all whom can touch the field.