Do I make this trade?

Originally posted by HomestarRunner:
So the pertinent information:

14 team PPR league. 1 pt per reception but only .5 pts per 10 receiving yards.

You play 2 WR 2 RB and one FLEX each week

My WRs:
Jordy Nelson, T.Y. Hilton, Pierre Garcon, Danny Amendola, Torrey Smith

My RBs:
Marshawn Lynch, Bilal Powell, Giovani Bernard

Trade proposal:

I get: Doug Baldwin and James White

He gets: Jordy Nelson

Why I'm considering it? I'm ridiculously thin at RB and in a 14 team league, quantity may out weigh quality. But is this fair value? What say you?

I wouldnt make that deal. Yes you suck at RB but I have to believe you can find a better offer out there.

Originally posted by Ninerjohn:

Originally posted by HomestarRunner:
So the pertinent information:

14 team PPR league. 1 pt per reception but only .5 pts per 10 receiving yards.

You play 2 WR 2 RB and one FLEX each week

My WRs:
Jordy Nelson, T.Y. Hilton, Pierre Garcon, Danny Amendola, Torrey Smith

My RBs:
Marshawn Lynch, Bilal Powell, Giovani Bernard

Trade proposal:

I get: Doug Baldwin and James White

He gets: Jordy Nelson

Why I'm considering it? I'm ridiculously thin at RB and in a 14 team league, quantity may out weigh quality. But is this fair value? What say you?

I wouldnt make that deal. Yes you suck at RB but I have to believe you can find a better offer out there.

I think I agree. His other RBs are:
Dalvin Cook
Chris Carson
Rob Kelly
Chris Thompson
Matt Breida

If I counter with Nelson for Dalvin Cook and Doug Baldwin am I asking for too much? Maybe Baldwin and Carson?

Originally posted by HomestarRunner:

Originally posted by Ninerjohn:

Originally posted by HomestarRunner:
So the pertinent information:

14 team PPR league. 1 pt per reception but only .5 pts per 10 receiving yards.

You play 2 WR 2 RB and one FLEX each week

My WRs:
Jordy Nelson, T.Y. Hilton, Pierre Garcon, Danny Amendola, Torrey Smith

My RBs:
Marshawn Lynch, Bilal Powell, Giovani Bernard

Trade proposal:

I get: Doug Baldwin and James White

He gets: Jordy Nelson

Why I'm considering it? I'm ridiculously thin at RB and in a 14 team league, quantity may out weigh quality. But is this fair value? What say you?

I wouldnt make that deal. Yes you suck at RB but I have to believe you can find a better offer out there.

I think I agree. His other RBs are:
Dalvin Cook
Chris Carson
Rob Kelly
Chris Thompson
Matt Breida

If I counter with Nelson for Dalvin Cook and Doug Baldwin am I asking for too much? Maybe Baldwin and Carson?

I would try Cook and Baldwin for Nelson and Bernard. The upgrade at RB would be worth the decline at WR. The other owner will likely decline but its worth a shot.

Eh, he's trying to buy low on jordy so there is ZERO chance you make a deal worth while for you IMO.

no way you make that deal. You're better off picking up someone off of a whim and hoping for the best.


I assume Alvin kamara is taken?

I'd roster Elijah McGuire, Marlon Mack or Wendal Smallwood and hope for the "best"

All 3 are already getting early touches with their teams. An injury or something happens and you're sitting pretty. And since you ha ve Powell McGuire makes the most since. I honestly think you're hurting at WR more than RB.

which further confuses me as to why you'd trade Jordy for that.

Edit: In a 14 team league you're not sitting horribly at RB. But you're not sitting pretty at WR either which is a

Thanks for the input guys. I declined the trade.

Offer him torrey smith and gio Bernard for Chris carson