Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Graziano explains why Kyle Shanahan, 49ers are sticking with Jimmy Garoppolo over Trey Lance

Nov 10, 2021 at 8:19 AM--

Trey Lance is the future for the San Francisco 49ers. Some argue that he needs more on-field experience to help in his development. The rookie quarterback's last snaps came one month ago, in a Week 5 loss to the Arizona Cardinals.

It's worth noting that he was inactive the next game due to a knee sprain. Week 8 was his first game back, but he did not get onto the football field. Some of that may have been the Niners being cautious with a star rookie returning from an injury. However, on Sunday against the Cardinals, a seemingly healthy Lance still had zero snaps, leading some to question the development plan.

Much of that may be because the 49ers' starter, Jimmy Garoppolo, has turned in two of his best performances this season over the last two weeks.

"Jimmy Garoppolo's Total QBR over the past two weeks is 76.8, which is the third-best in the league over that time," ESPN's Dan Graziano recently shared.

Since Week 8, Garoppolo has completed over 66 percent of his passes for 648 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception. His 80.2 overall Pro Football Focus grade in Week 8 and 79.6 grade in Week 9 are the two highest of the season.

That has seemingly been enough to hold off any thoughts of transitioning to Lance. After all, it was the 49ers defense, not Garoppolo's play, that hurt the team during Sunday's embarrassing 31-17 defeat against an injury-ravaged Cardinals team.

Still, Garoppolo didn't receive his typical praise from Shanahan after Sunday's loss.

"I thought Jimmy was alright," Shanahan said. "I thought that pick at the end, those last couple of plays were some bad plays right there, on that last drive when the game was out of hand. But Jimmy was alright."


That's not exactly the glowing review one would hope to receive.

If the 49ers try to find a spark to turn around the disappointing season, it probably won't come from a quarterback change.

"The 3-5 49ers' season is teetering a bit, and they likely could use a boost, but I do not get the sense that Shanahan is about to turn to Lance," Graziano continued. "Whether that's because he doesn't think Lance is ready (likely, since he came into the league as inexperienced as any of the rookie QBs) or whether it's because he feels Garoppolo truly gives them the best chance to win right now, everything points to Shanahan sticking with Garoppolo for Monday night and beyond."

That doesn't mean Lance's time won't come this season. It's unknown if Garoppolo can sustain his current level of play. There are still nine games — over half the season — remaining on the schedule.

Graziano added, "Lance probably starts at some point this season, but it could be a while yet."

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers sticking with Jimmy Garoppolo wasn't a tough decision, says Kyle Shanahan

By David Bonilla
Jan 12

There was a lot of pressure for the San Francisco 49ers to play rookie Trey Lance more. Not just at the start of the season but throughout the entire 2021 campaign. That included the week leading to the regular-season finale against the Los Angeles Rams, especially with starting quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo dealing with a pretty concerning right thumb injury. Garoppolo did play through the pain of his torn ligament and chipped bone in that thumb. He put in a gutsy performance, leading the 49ers to a playoff-clinching 27-24 overtime victory over the Rams. Head coach Kyle Shanahan did what he could to block out the outside noise, never giving in to the pressure to start Lance. It ended up being the right call, but the coach understands why everyone wanted to see the

Kyle Shanahan explains his unwavering trust in Jimmy Garoppolo, says 49ers are 'battle-tested'

By David Bonilla
Jan 17

Jimmy Garoppolo makes his mistakes. That hasn't deterred head coach Kyle Shanahan from sticking with him, though. The San Francisco 49ers quarterback delivered a gutsy performance in the regular-season finale against the Los Angeles Rams, playing through a torn ligament and chipped bone in his right thumb. The Week 18 win set up a playoff matchup against an old rival—the Dallas Cowboys. The 49ers went into AT&T Stadium and emerged with a 23-17 victory, which was anything but pretty. A playoff win is a playoff win, though, and the Niners will move on to Lambeau Field to face the Green Bay Packers. Garoppolo finished the game 16-of-25 passing for a pedestrian 172 yards and a rather ugly interception. But he did so while enduring the pain of throwing. That

49ers-Packers: Kyle Shanahan wants Trey Lance to 'let it rip' while imitating Aaron Rodgers in practice

By David Bonilla
Jan 18

Trey Lance has a tough task this week. No, he is not expecting to start Saturday's playoff game against the Green Bay Packers. As part of the practice squad, the San Francisco 49ers rookie has to mimic future Hall of Fame quarterback Aaron Rodgers for the defense in practice. Lance's development has benefited from imitating opposing quarterbacks all season. Sometimes that is a versatile quarterback like Kyler Murray or Justin Fields. Other times, it is a more stationary passer, like Kirk Cousins. Lance studying Rodgers this week can only make him a better quarterback. "Aaron does a real good job of not making bad decisions and not turning the ball over," head coach Kyle Shanahan told reporters before Tuesday's practice. "But he also makes all the

49ers-Cowboys: Kyle Shanahan provides injury updates on Trent Williams, Jimmy Garoppolo, Jaquiski Tartt, others

By David Bonilla
Jan 10

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan jumped on a conference call with reporters on Monday, one day after his team's thrilling playoff-clinching 27-24 overtime road win over the Los Angeles Rams. He provided several injury updates. Trent Williams, tackle Williams did not play on Sunday. He was inactive due to an elbow injury. Shanahan says Williams will be doing everything he can to play against the Cowboys. However, the coach didn't sound optimistic that his starting left tackle would practice on Wednesday. "He wasn't going to be in good enough shape to protect himself [on Sunday] or the quarterback in the game," Shanahan said. "That was tough on him, but I think he was as excited as anyone after we won because I know he's going to


Trending News

Share 49ersWebzone